Good asset usage (very light, under 100mb, and sets the standard), good use of style. Encounters are acceptable and level design is good. Item drops are bad and detract from what could otherwise be a campaign on par with official campaigns. Equipment availability is very clearly designed around a faux sense of balance which detracts from the fun; it just doesn't make any sense too. Whereas the offical campaigns are liberally sprinkled with gear of all sorts, encouraging you to use them, I can literally count the number of melee weapons I encountered on one hand in the entire campaign, obviously because melee weapons are superior for dealing with the large amounts of common infected. Tier 1 firearms are a dime a dozen, even tier two weapons become more common before you even see your first tier 2 melee. It makes repeated playthroughs (and failures) extremely tedious as your options are limited to the same pool of weaponry as before that limits experimentation and novelty. On realism the near lack of equipment (especially melee availability) makes for an extremely tedious playthrough and is frankly kind of ****** that I encounter literally over a dozen M16s and AK47s and submachine guns but can't find a single shovel. 2/5 enjoyment, 4/5 design. Overall 3/5, wouldn't recommend more than a single playthrough simply because of the tedium generated by lackluster equipment availability. The mechanics of L4d2 are not complex enough for scarcity to generate novelty. The entire time I was filled with a pervasive thought of "this would be a lot less of a PITA if there was an actual melee weapon."

Gracias

eh eh so happy i could die

Great Atmosphere and lots of WTF Setpieces. The Atmosphere is very good the sound and feeling of ash and decay is very noticable and the campaign does have some WTF moments which I am not gonna spoil. But just because you see a saferoom doesn't mean its safe!