Pros:

-gnome thing was cool
-variety of scenery
-custom CI outfits
-unique events, though they didnt always make sense
-just enough supplies, and you usually have to work to get them
-lots of witches (maybe too many)
-buildings scattered around had nice detail
-horde usually came from all sides rather than a bottleneck to make it challenging

Cons:

-boat had water in it
-HORRIBAD FPS when looking at lake
-repetitive: field, containers, sidewalk with trees, rinse, wash, repeat
-didn't make a whole lot of sense
-custom outfit CIs had weird black square under them (missing shadow maybe?)
-bland, overall lack of visual polish

Conclusion:

Pretty generic. Felt like a stock map, only it was more repetitive, wide-open, and nonsensical. The people rating it 9.9 or 10/10 are either OP's alt accounts or friends, because this campaign is definitely not worth your time.

Pros:

- Cool, unique atmosphere
- Lots of neat little details that make it feel more realistic
- Good bot nav (except during the "rescue" if you can call it that)
- Russian voices were neat, especially the broadcasting woman - very creepy
- Music fits well
- Lighting and hints were appropriate
- Not an overabundance of AK47s and health packs

Cons:

- Music when being attacked by special infected/tank is missing
- Needs optimization, FPS was down to 15-20 at some spots
- Anticlimactic finale - at least have us climb into the truck or something...
- Me and someone else both crashed to desktop multiple times
- Reflection on the water was off (on map 3? I think?)
- Loading screen could have more character and could be less pixelated
- A bit too many throwables lying around, imho
- Zombies usually seemed to come from the same spot
- I would have preferred more stray common standing around rather than constant hordes

Conclusion:

Needs a bit of tweaking to make it replayable, but it's definitely got potential.

Pros:

-unique setting
-finally a good map set outside North America that isn't in English or Japanese!
-opening was ultra creepy/cool
-lots of witches, yay!
-realistic, detailed maps... stuff is boarded up and you have to find your way around, for example
-awesome soccer jerseys on the common infected

Cons:

-finale is a bit too hard... I suggest maybe toning down the horde when a tank comes. would love to play on versus, but the finale would just be impossible and would just be a race
-crashed twice with C++ errors... only map that's done it so far. I know Bloue used to have this problem on Dead Series, but I think it got fixed
-too many supplies lying around, if you ask me, and they're too easy to find. You should put more in bathrooms and things instead of out in the open
-bots would get stuck and have to teleport sometimes (my Nick also got stuck down in the subway on the finale)

Conclusion:

Good map, great concept, and lots of attention to detail. It doesn't get a perfect score because of some nitpicky details, mainly the difficulty of the finale.

And get this map uploaded to some servers in North America!

Pros:

-Different scenery

Cons:

-Not very original, looks like Death Aboard 2

Conclusion:

Great to hear that you've got an update. Not so great to see that you've purged my review.

Pros:

-Very unique and memorable setting
-Map flow is perfect
-Security windows on cafe = awesome idea
-Great for versus play
-Ammo/supplies scattered well
-AWESOME finale. I lol'd :)
-Easter eggs! Yay!

Cons:

-Gotta make it a bit easier to spawn for SI in the finale, particularly with the initial spawning in ghost mode when you press E. It can spawn you pretty far away/underground so you have to look for a way up and get behind the enemy
-Still could use a couple more witches
-put in some more obstacles or dumpsters in the stadium? It felt like it was too easy to go around the tanks. Or make it so you at least have to kill one?

Conclusion:

Great campaign. Definitely deserves to be featured, and totally deserving of such a high score.

Pros:

-Solid campaign
-Very polished environment
-Uses lots of unique textures
-Cool rescue vehicle
-Creepy mall security man, what a psycho!
-Neat crescendos
-LOVED the custom music!!

Cons:

-Can be a bit tough at times
-Really long
-I don't see it catching on in versus mode, it would probably take forever
-Finale felt too wide open, you could just snipe the tanks from across the map

Conclusion:

This is everything Dead Center wanted to be and more. Great job!

Pros:

-Loved the level design. Loved it, it was perfect. It's not always obvious where to go, but it doesn't take too much exploration, either.
-Alarm cars!
-The museum part was cool and different
-Nice finale
-Great variety of environments... I like the rain in the finale

Cons:

-Finale felt a little easy at times

Conclusion:

Very cool map. Satisfying campaign. I'd like to try it in versus... anyone know how it plays?

Pros:

-Fun and creepy map! I played it with 3 bots, but man, all it needs is to be combined with the "Last Man Standing" mutation and you've got yourself a horror!
-I love gauntlet finales
-Decor was great, very unique setting
-Loved the telephone, very nice touch
-In-game dialogue is cool

Cons:

-Looks like a strictly-coop map, despite supporting versus
-Felt like I went in a straight line the whole game

Conclusion:

Play this map! Play it alone the first time, and you may have nightmares ;)

Pros:

-Unique, fun setting. We should have more desert maps on L4D2!
-Great variety, nothing seemed repetitive/boring
-I felt like the difficulty was just right
-Finally, a custom map where versus games are enjoyable (and enough people have the map)!
-Perfect amount of ammo/weapons, good placement too
-Creative use of lighting in the desert scenes vs. inside

Cons:

-Ending was a bit strange, but I never did finish watching 2001: A Space Odyssey
-Didn't care for the changing colors so much at the end. You could do it as you touch the monolith, then change it back to normal, rather than keeping it all throughout the fight with the tank
-Early tank in finale, in the corridor=probably not supposed to happen?
-Story is unclear, why are we fighting tanks in this cavern and why can't we just be beamed up immediately?

Conclusion:

Was a great campaign, except for the weird finale. Very fun, even in versus.

Pros:

-Train crescendo was cool
-Unique finale
-Feels big/wide open, but you're still guided towards the end

Cons:

-Kinda long
-Too much constant horde, give it a rest sometimes!
-Lots of potential instakill  spots means it's probably not too fun on versus

Conclusion:

Good map, but donate a couple hours if you plan to do a campaign.

Pros:

-Lots of witches, yay! There should be more of them in all other maps!
-I liked the crescendo on the roof
-Item placement is good
-The sewer crescendo, man that's brutal!
-Small download size, even though it's a long campaign, so friends won't be deterred to download it!

Cons:

-Environment was kinda bland. Feels like a mix between Dead Center and The Parish. Think about adding some custom textures/models perhaps?
-Felt a bit repetitive... buildings, streets, buildings, streets. Lots of cars, though it could have used more alarm cars.
-Doesn't look very well-suited for versus play, but maybe it's shorter/has fewer deathcharges than I think
-A bit too many supplies, imo. On one map we had 4 health packs in the safe room and then found 2 right outside of it

Conclusion:

Really well designed map. The author does a great job of using Valve's original models and textures to create something new. The crescendos are great, and there are lots of witches :) However, it felt slightly bland and repetitive at times, and it was kind of long.

Just a side note: I ended up having to host it locally. Could you please check that the dedicated servers you've put this on are up to date?

Pros:

-Neat concept!
-Good beginning
-Rescue is cool
-Good amount of supplies
-Good map layout, not too many side rooms, but not too few either

Cons:

-Scenery in the middle gets repetitive
-tank spawned in the wall on top of the elevator on the finale, causing it to die instantly--this happened twice
-Seemed kind of easy. Could have used more common, as well as more SI, with the SI spawning in less predictable places

Conclusion:

Great game, definitely worth the download. I'd love to try it in versus!

Pros:

-Multiple paths, you really have to learn the map even with the guides turned on
-Unique setting
-Maps are polished, detailed... i especially liked the lodge
-Rewards for exploring the map: molotovs, health kits, etc
-Witches! Yay!

Cons:

-Lots of potential deathcharge spots
-Too many ammo piles, pills = too easy
-Finale has too much travel
-Beware of playing with bots

Conclusion:

I'm not a big fan of deatcharge-heavy games... coordination and skill on infected side is superior. I'd put in a few more railings in, have fewer places for infected to spawn in these areas. I'd also cut the finale in two. Have the lodge be its own map, but maybe add a few more things, and have the finale just be a "set up and camp" kind of deal, otherwise teams might die before they even get to trigger. Great job, though, on delivering a fun and detailed campaign. Where's it set, out of curiosity? :)

Pros:

pretty at the top
neat concept: the higher you go, the better supplies you get
snow is different, nice change of setting
nice lodge houses/chalet areas

Cons:

missing some foliage... trees would be nice to hide the tank/horde so it doesn't all die before it gets to you
missing a nice background, especially noticeable at the spawn area (which should give a good first impression)
you could also make it slower to climb some of the steep hills to make it more believable/difficult

Conclusion:

It was all right!