Pros:

-epic atmosphere, maps are just great
-custom skins, models
-awesome loading screen
-awesome secret
-Grasper?
-there is to much pros

Cons:

-nav troubles, bots can stuck sometimes
-no intro
-lack of ammo, tier 2 weps
-2nd map, falling cars in the metro smashed all of us
-custom common infected, shadow is messed up, it's just black square

Conclusion:

95

Pros:

-Great detailing
-Custom music and stuff
-The great wall is very realistic

Cons:

-I've spent half an hour on 1st map on searching
-I died 3 times on finale, to hard, but it's new xD
-Bots can stuck easily in ice

Conclusion:

Congrats on winning 1st prize. But I can't say, that your entry is better then mine. Just my opinion ;)

Pros:

-maps are cool
-custom music
-fog

Cons:

-bugs with keys
-lack of health packs
-where should I go?

Conclusion:

I've been playing for 2 hours. 1st map is fine. 2nd map, 1st try. All bots are died 3 times by falling from ladders/stucking/drowning in water. I stuck with no keys after 2nd ghost. After half an hour I found a key where spider in the beginning and what do you think? I've got a key but door is not opening! 2nd try. Now I figured out that if you are going to the safe room you are loosing all of your keys. (wtf?) 3rd try. Okay, let's do this, now I know what to do. Taking 1st key near spider, then second after killing tank. But wait, what the hell, I've got only one key instead of two! I have not finished this.

Pros:

-very detailed

Cons:

-fps drop (5-20) because map is not optimized
-crashed once
-I broke the radio but sound still plays
-special infected can stuck in some places

Conclusion:

unplayable because of fps drop, but still it's very well made.

Pros:

Long maps

Cons:

Water is everywhere D:
Sky texture is buggy.
5th map. There was no medkits/ammo at the start (my team was red and empty after crescendo at 4th map), so we made 5th map only ftom 5th try, quite hard.
Final map is maybe to little.

Conclusion:

69

Pros:

-----------------
-----------------
Awesome story

Cons:

--------------------
--------------------
no combines (corpses etc)

Conclusion:

------------------
------------------
Cool campaign

Pros:

Beautiful atmosphere.
boat
breaking floor
bridge
tunnel

Cons:

2nd map, there was 2 withces in each other. Double hedshot :D

4th map, I've spawned outside of the safe room. Also look at the ground near safe room door (at the begining).

Conclusion:

Why is it calling 2 evil eyes?
great work

Pros:

Beautyfull beach, waterfall.
Very realistic atmosphere.

Cons:

If flashlight is on, water is buggy.
1st map even not finished.

Conclusion:

Keep up great work!

Pros:

Perfect recreation of this house.

Cons:

Some pink reflections in cellar. 

Conclusion:

Cool map. I wanted to meet some scaring secrets or something :p
Awesome movie :)

Pros:

4th map is awesome! Custom music is cool.

Cons:

Vely low fps on some maps, you could optimize LOS, by using areaportals, func_lod and others. Strange final, to long, maybe to dangerous coz you can die easily when tank. Escape vehicle is LOL. How could it fly without someone. If addon is installed, all standart music on other campaigns not work. That car with alarm on 4th map looks creative but...

Conclusion:

Well, to many cons. But it is playable.