Pros:

Looks Pretty
Nice open areas to fight off infected
It has all the necessary requirements for the contest
I LOVE the color correction
Good Lighting
Good Environment 
Lots of weapons at the start
Custom Models

Cons:

Lagged (for me at least) to the point it's barely playable
I could not find ANY melee weapons whatsoever 
Little to no weapon spawn points
There were some doors (I elieve in the front were I could only see the Skybox texture
In both of the two rooms you can enter you can break the glass to get on the balcony and jump outside of the map
Bots got stuck.....A LOT
Missing Texture on the third floor balcony
Doors that are not supposed to be opened can be opened

Conclusion:

All in all the map looked to be very good with wide open areas for players to hold out, however the Cons overpower the Pros. Right now I'd give this map an 80 of 100. You say your going to fix a lot of the things in my cons and I may edit my review then.Hope to see this stuff fixed because it has a lot of potential in my opinion.

Pros:

Great Puzzles
Long Levels
Difficult Challenge 
Kept us Entertained 
Multiple Endings (Ive only played through 2 of them)

Cons:

Puzzles sometimes got to difficult
At times got repetitive 

Conclusion:

I have never played any of the Silent Hill games before but this campaign has inspired me to go out and buy at least one of them. Thank you for an awesome campaign that me and my friends cant seem to stop playing!

P.S Ive heard that theres more than just one Silent Hill Game, Will you be making the second one next?

Pros:

Very large level 
Many different places to go
Plenty of weapons,first aid kits,etc.
Custom fire texture was cool
Tank Skin was great and fit well with this map
A LOT of Witches

Cons:

The Tank skin appears in every other campaign
At times I got lost and went down the wrong path

Conclusion:

This Campaign is definitely the best finished Left 4 Dead 2 Campaign out there. No Joke! The feel of the campaign was great and I will defenitly play this one over and over again. Congrats on creating such a great Campaign hope you win the contest, after playing through this I think you deserve it.