Pros:

- it's for l4d1
 - great poster :D
 - everything else

Cons:

 - waited so long for upload :p

Conclusion:

When it comes to retouching Markus is the king of l4d1
This campaign gives a fresh touch to l4d1 and gives everybody another great campaign in their addons!
Thx dude!

Pros:

 - L4D1
 - Very nice Dead island replica
 - Atmosphere
 - Interesting ideas at the finale
(not a standard one)
 - I love the way you used that not working water rise in the beginning of the sewer level
 - Love how you put boomer in the place of the fat guy in the sewer

Cons:

 - Pilot in the chopper is visible not attached to it
(Make a glass or something blocking the survivors to see it since you can't animate it like the chopper model is))
 - That rushing water looks like a block in the sewer
 (So maybe instead of making it go up and down make two brushes and toogle them on off)
 - The finale is weird....tho really awesome with the building going down and all,I think you should have made the survivors run to the first chopper and then when the building falls on the chopper make a canyon from the first chopper place to the second one!
In that way even players playing it first time will know what to do and where to stand!

Conclusion:

Since I always play l4d I played this map before I played Dead island,I started to play it lately and it's really amazing how you got everything right from it!I could maneuver in dead island maps cause I knew it from this one and it's a really nice replica!
And really nice ideas in the map too,but in some cases like the finale you still need to work on how to make those ideas work right in l4d!
Nice job non the less!  

Pros:

- lord of the rings
- nice helm deep replica
- music
- l4d1
- nice idea of events happening at medal wining

Cons:

- lagg
- no loading screen
- one screenshot?
- you didn't restore sound so there's no music to non mapper folk (restoring it took me 5 min)
- judging by the l4d2 version of the map this is 30 % complete

Conclusion:

Once again judging by the last update for it I would say you have abandon this map...which is a crying shame cause just look how well the l4d2 version is going...
You don't have to do it exactly how l4d2 version is...but seriously...not even a sound restore to it?
When you update the map I will upgrade my review,untill then if you don't care...I don't care....

Pros:

 - nice idea
 - l4d1
 - baricade
 - thunder

Cons:

 - you didn't fix the sound after the dlc update
 - few more alleys wouldn't hurt
 - bit laggy when the horde starts

Conclusion:

Nice job on the map,this is how valve would do it...plus you added some more stuff like the barricade around the map which is really cool!
I think you should update the map cause it's a shame for such a great map to be without sound!
As you update so will my review grow ;)
p.s.make a feature listening photo so I can nominate it for the front page!

Pros:

- this is a masterpiece
- like valve's maps(except for the weapons and kits)
- realistic
- good feel

Cons:

- none

Conclusion:

This has become one of my best campaigns ever since it came out!
It had something new (desert) , everything worked fine , fun to play , and it was for l4d1!
Great job Kev...keep em coming ;)

Pros:

 - l4d1
 - Love all the witch animation parts
 - Awesome boss
 - searching for signs randomly placed
 - silent hill stuff
 - twisted rooms

Cons:

 - Maybe a bit too easy (people can seperate and search for stuff with no problem-I would add more zombies to make things more interesting ;) )

Conclusion:

This is a great map to play with friends and enjoy killing the hard boss at the end!
I would so wanna see you do a whole campaign like you did this map :D

Pros:

- Love the models
- Everything is made in nice size to look real
- A lot of places to go to
- Nice lighting

Cons:

- I would really like you to make that vent shaft above the stairs reachable!
- needs more weapons scatered around the map

Conclusion:

This is an awesome map well worth the download!
It should be in everybodies most have list!
Keep up the good work man! ;)

Pros:

 - Frozen glass texture
 - Fireworks
 - Tree
 - Little quiet place fit for christmas
 - Nice way to start the horde
 - Good nav
 - for l4d1

Cons:

 - Not all rooms are reachable
 - maybe a little too small town

Conclusion:

This is a very standard map like the one valve would made if they made a Christmas map!
Everything is planned out to be possible in real life and that makes it very realistic.
And is also saying a lot about you as a mapper! ;)
It's a nice touch to my addons folder...this is a must have :)

Pros:

 - very original
 - fun
 - building stuff
 - technology 
 - nice balance with the time 

Cons:

 - crappy looking rocket
 - bots don't follow into the rocket

Conclusion:

This is not a standard gameplay and therefor it's very interesting and fun to play.
Loved the technology,building stuff and the fact you have to time everything you want to get...
Nice balance of time required for every item.
The only bad thing I found in the map was the rocket itself...
As soon as you make a better model I'll even give you a 100 review ;)

Pros:

- desert
- skybox
- l4d1
- fun

Cons:

- From one corner of the map I saw a rock nodraw thing
(didn't cut you down for this)
- could use more weapons around the map

Conclusion:

This is a fun map showing something you don't see everyday in l4d...
Nice open area,a bit easy yes but fun to play it with a nice skybox and the background...
Nice idea,very well executed!

Pros:

Love the whole idea...it's what would happen in real life.
Custom sounds
Gas
New way of gameplay
Rush finale

Cons:

You didn't made it for l4d1 too :(

Conclusion:

This is the most realistic custom campaign I ever played in l4d2(Including valves)
Nice idea and pro made!
I just wish you made it for l4d1 too...it would be a blast XD

Pros:

 - It's all made from l4d stuff so really small download for a huge map!
- It's a HUGE map
- Love the atmosfere of l4d1 in it

Cons:

- no arrows to point the way
- too many places to hide in the finale
(make breakable walls in some of the rooms)

Conclusion:

I really love what you're doing with the map...
It must have took you forever to build everything.
And even tho a lot of the stuff is from other maps I think it's pretty cool playing it in the way you organized it...
The only thing I don't like is the arrows,there are none....don't know which way to go...
I really belive this will be a awesome map once you fix all the little details in it!
I'm giving you 95 for all the work you put in it and for making it for l4d1,not just l4d2!
I'm sure you'll make it even better in the future!Keep up the good work ;)

Pros:

+ Great idea for the map!
+ Map is full of nice ideas never seen in l4d like the 
    armored car you can ride on!
+ Love the witch room,pretty sick!
+ light switches are nice touch
+ Environment is cool

Cons:

- bit laggy
- there are too many hordes
- disappearing guns and ammo
- You can see zombies spawn

Conclusion:

This is a very interesting map for me!Full of ideas and unique stuff,I can really see you worked on it hard trying to get exactly what you wanted!
However some of the stuff you put inside like light switches is nice but also make the game a bit laggy when overdoing it.
And everybody likes the horde but you must REALLY like them haha! ;)
My conclusion is source engine is too small for your big imagination and the things you want to create,this is a really nice map to play if you like killing a lot of zombies and seeing lots of cool stuff and since it is your 2 map I don't mind the few glitches here and there,I'm sure you'll fix them up through future updates!Thumbs up! :D

Pros:

- It's a great idea to combine bandicoot with l4d
- Music rules
- bosses nice
- great carrot health thing
- Love the way you build everything from brushes

Cons:

I really can't say anything bad about this map,I've been playing it since 1st map came out...it had a few glitches then but you seem to fix things when you find a way how.
So there's really no bad comments! :)

Conclusion:

If you like l4d and fun with it,this is the map for you!
Shooting zombies with that music and in the great world you created is just hillarious!
I for one can't wait for your new map or update!
GREAT JOB!