Pros:

- Great map length
- Good environment
- Nostaglic - L4d1 feel (my preference)
- Challenging level

Cons:

- No med pack and guns on 4th map
- No clear directions for the panic events

Conclusion:

I just finished your map with my bunch of friends and I really felt that you had a great campaign! Although its a 6map campaign, the pacing you give the players feels good. Each map is not too long so it doesn't become too tiring. I really need to emphasis that the map length for this campaign is AWESOME. Good job!

Environment is pretty good with nostalgic feelings like we were back to L4D1 on certain map. The levels are not too easy and provides a good challenge to the players. We did it on advanced and it was enjoyable. 

On the 4th map, there were no med kits and no guns and ammo. Is this intentionally left out? It can be quite challenging as a lot of HP has been lost on the previous map. I understand that the med kits were strewn around later in the map, but it might be a little too challenging for other players and might turn them away from your great campaign. 

Also there were no clear directions for the panic events. Sometimes, we didn't know whether to camp it out or rush to off a device. I believe it could be way better if there were some hints. 

Lastly, I think this is a great campaign and we will definitely play it with my friends often! I always love map with great map length and which provides a fair challenge to the players. It just feels right and could easily be a Valve release. Its pretty hard to find good maps like this, please keep it up! 

Pros:

- Great sound recording for intro and finale
- Love the finale tower to the helipad
- Creative setting, winter! :D

Cons:

- Map too spacious, which lead to players easily getting lost
- Lack of directional arrow
- A lot of SI stuck on cars or other objects
- at the 3rd map I accidentally jumped into the water and couldn't get out anymore

Conclusion:

hey I just completed this campaign and came straight here to post my review. 

I will do my best to give you my honest feedback and hopefully you can do something to improve the overall experience. :) The map is pretty easy even on advance as the area is too big with buildings scattered all around and without any arrows, its pretty hard to navigate. I can see that your team have quite a lot of ideas and maybe I would suggest that you guys could split them up into alternate routes. (like I hate mountains). This would greatly increase the replayability o the map. 

A lot of SI are stuck on objects and I think we would need a lot more hints like where to run after the crescendo event. A good example would be the 3rd map, where after we open the gate we had to connect the bridge before running to the safe room. I got lost there and fell into the water. Maybe some sign or hint would be very helpful to guide the players to the safe room. 

Lastly, this is just my opinion, after we power up the generator maybe you could activate a horde and then let us run into the helipad tower. I think playing the entire finale on the helipad tower would add a lot of adrenaline rush and tension to the experience. Imagine fighting the tanks and SI on the tower? (Sorry, I am getting a little too excited) 
Also the tanks all spawned inside the tower where we are down below at the ice camp. Thus the tank got stuck and could only throw projectile at us. Very easy to pick the tank off.

Anyway, nice work on the snow element I think this campaign can be further refine and improve as I see the potential that a lot of players would be looking for original campaigns like this. Please keep up the good work and I look forward to your updates soon! :)

Pros:

- Great setting within the forest
- Nice rapids
- Nice trap with rewards (first aid kit)
- Nice speedboat idea to safe room

Cons:

- Speedboat section, if a tank spawn, that area is almost impossible to pass on expert. 
- Speedboat section, Charger charged into the speedboat and plummet a survivor while he or she is on top of the boat. (Different in altitude?)
- Finale can still be improved.

Conclusion:

Hey there, first and for most, I think your forest setting is a great as in its not too cluttered and offers some exploration. Like the little details like rapids just before the finale. Nice traps with the med kit reward. :)

The Speedboat is where some problems occurred. If the tank spawns during this segment its almost gg if the tank manages to get on the boat, which is pretty random. We cannot control the speed of the boat, we need to fight off the hordes and SIs and tank, and then the water is poisonous. Its just too much, maybe you could restrict the tank to spawn here or maybe just let either of which spawn and not both. (that's my suggestion) . Also you might wanna solve the glitch where the charger hit the boat and end up plummeting the survivor on top of it. 

Finale just some comments, I believe by now most of us would be doing the finale on the rooftops as the water below will slow us down wherever we run. When the tank comes, there would not be enough place to run and end up we will need to jump into the water. Once in the water, an expert tank will crush you. What I would suggest is that maybe you could have connecting wooden planks to other houses' rooftops so that there are more options to run about. (Take e.g. Hard Rain finale, rooftop) Great campaign, and my team would love to see the small changes if you still have the time to do it. :)

Pros:

Fantastic Setting
Nice Ambience
Good map length
Alternate routes which makes the game more fun!

Cons:

L4d2 survivors? 
A little dark

Conclusion:

All in all this is a fantastic campaign that is rare to come by. Great map length and i think the alternate route is a very good option for map makers who have many things they want to include. Like for e.g. there are maps that are excruciating long because the map makers had too much to throw in, one suggestion is that they could do alternate routes like this campaign so there is a HIGHER RE-PLAYABILITY value to it. My friends and I have completed it on Advanced and we would be doing it on expert soon! 

Its a great map that can be played on expert with good challenge difficulty just like the original campaign maps. One good thing to highlight is that the campaign has a very good balance of difficulty throughout the maps. We have been waiting for this campaign for L4D2 for a long time and it has finally made its transition. Great job and we look forward to more great campaigns in the future! Cheers!

Pros:

Nice setting
Nice map

Cons:

finale hard as hell
3rd map glitch

Conclusion:

I played the L4D ver and it was all too easy, but for l4d2 the finale is just too hard... I like the events, lightings, graphics and the fearful white explosive barrels. Maybe anyone can give me some tips on how to play the finale on expert? We tried countless times but after even we know the gas cans but the horde and SI will just kill us. 

I think its slightly diff from Dead Centre, where the gas tanks are thrown down and gathered later to fill up (well that was our strategy) . This finale requires us to throw it up. For the 3rd map, final area just before we reach the safe room, we need to go through this electric fence and I was left with 10hp. I was straight away incap once i entered the area. Is this a bug or is it supposed to be this way? If it was meant to be this way, which means we will definitely need to lose hp to cross this area? 

Pros:

nice and simple layout

Cons:

the safe room to the finale area is seems a bit too long
finale area need to be slightly bigger (explain below)
incap glitch

Conclusion:

To begin with, I would like to say that for custom maps I normally play on advance or expert mode with my group of die-hard l4d2 friends. The overall map is pretty pleasant to play with some small areas to explore. However, the finale map is slightly long to travel to if you happen to die in the finale and restart. For the finale, we tried on expert and try to run around the containers at the back where the ammo is. The entire finale area is a long stretch of road with only one entrance/exit. So when the 2 tanks spawned on after the 2nd horde, we were gg'ed. 

I tried running up the stairs but after we defeat the tank, the horde will prevent us from getting down to the rescue vehicle as their spawns are below. What might do is maybe create another path into and out of this finale and I believe it would be a great expert map! :) 
  

Pros:

Nice map layout
Good crescendo events
Nice finale 

Cons:

Too long 3rd map 
Some part of the maps can be very long and repetitive

Conclusion:

Hey this map is great for forest lovers~! The 3rd map is a little too long and some of the areas feel repetitive, meaning we run a long stretch fighting zombies that spawn from the sides. Maybe could give it some variety and maybe remove some areas. ( i understand that this might be a final ver already) 

Finale map was fun, details great! The space to run around is just big enough but not too big so it requires skill to dodge the tank. :)