Pros:

Beautiful map!
Very well constructed
Perfect level design
great number of zombies, witches, hoards, etc..
All in all..excellent!

Cons:

Map crashed on us at the shuffle board on the bridge. Both of us went to the desktop. 

Conclusion:

I would add a few more hoarding events during the finale. It felt a bit easy and not rushed. Overall, this map will stay in my rotation, and it's well worth the praise! :)

Pros:

Excellent recreation of the theme park!
Flowed nicely and the rides were fun.
good choice of weapons
ending was great also, nice spin on the gas tank gathering objective

Cons:

not enough throwables - had to wait until map 3 to get any
no swords or machetes..
not enough tanks 
not enough hordes

Conclusion:

What I would do to make this map a lot more intense is to add horde panic events in the first two - three levels and any other areas that are open. It wasn't really a challenge fight wise during the first 3, and I felt that it should have been more fierce throughout the map. Adding throwables and perhaps a tank near the ending of each map would make it much more enjoyable. You had enough witches (perhaps maybe add one or two more) and boomers, jockies and the whatnots. Over all, an outstanding map that I would love to see fully perfected. Great job!

Pros:

Extra long maps
Nice and adventurous
Some areas were challenging to figure out like the room with the vent (had to climb up) and the other area navigating over the ceiling pipes to get to the room
Ending was great and funny with the car..

Cons:

Needs a tank on level 1
Maybe put a few arrows here and there. I believed I was doing the right thing with the alarm (not really going in that direction) and found 1 arrow to confirm.
Ending should have had a better fight with the tanks.

Conclusion:

My suggestions to make this a perfect campaign. Put two more day time - outside levels in front of the 3, so the players decent into the building and then out again. Put a tank on level 1. Draw a few more arrows. Everything else was pretty darn good. Loved the map. My wife and I played it in about 43 minutes.  I will definitely keep this in my rotation. Awesome map!

Pros:

Good maps / level design
nice maze map
plenty of hordes
plenty of tanks

Cons:

not enough throwables
not enough ammo
couldn't find out where the rescue is and died.
Wish it would have been 4 maps instead of 3

Conclusion:

The map maze is irritating as heck. Stone ladders should be more defined. I will say, I had to back track through the maze and turned on the generator and then I was able to see the last area where I was missing by the stone ladder. Perhaps, author would put arrows in areas that are hard to see because it's PITCH BLACK!! :)  Also, when the rescue arrived, endless hordes and NO HEALTH anywhere in that building. No ammo either. Man, give us supplies! Couldn't find out how and where the rescue is.. We all died trying to find it in the endless hordes. I'm deleting this map in my rotation until it's fixed. great potential, but not up to complete par just yet.

Pros:

Cool maps, layouts, over all pretty fun

Cons:

Crashes right out of the gate on level (2?). Right when you get to the ambulance..right to the desktop.

Conclusion:

Would be great if you fixed it. Maybe add a few more maps. We were having fun playing it until the crashes. I tried it twice and same time - crashes.

Pros:

Cool layout/ nice idea with the puzzles

Cons:

Horrible AI. Played with another player and 2 bots, couldn't get through the maps. 

Conclusion:

OK. But would have rated higher for effort if it was actually playable with less than 4 people.

Pros:

Fun campaign
lots of zombies, witches, boomers, etc
Tanks were plenty..
geometry  was great and freshness to the game with the ending

Cons:

not enough throwables - change them up atleast
Not enough melees
Puzzle on 3 was annoying
Weird graphics glitch on the launch pad, not showing properly as you run towards it..

Conclusion:

Game was solid and fun, but please remove the puzzle. I felt that it was out of the ordinary, too complex to figure out (mainly because I couldn't figure out how many numbers it required), but it ruined the flow the levels. This campaign feels like one of those run n gun, relentless zombie attacking - fun maps..til that part showed up. I messed around with it for 5 minutes or so and eventually restarted it to the next level. Just felt that if it wasn't in there this campaign would be in the high 9s..

Pros:

Very original and fun. I thought it was great throughout. Good layouts, graphics, thought were all good. 

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

Nice work. 

Pros:

Easily navigate
lengthy maps
layout is great

Cons:

NO MELEES! WTF. Seriously dude, put some melees, crowbars or a machete or even a crappy axe!
Way too many arrows pointing the direction..Fun thing about l4d2 maps is the figuring out part. A few here or there in obvious places but they are every 10 feet it seems. 
Not enough health in the rooms. You should put health in the end of each map. Not enough health pickups. 
Way too many EMPTY rooms. I can't count the times I walked into an abandoned building to find nothing. Hello! Put something in there.
Made it all the way to the end, and had to sacrifice my partner so I could make it around the end to the big door only to find that I had no where to go and a tank killed my limping self. No weapons or ammo or health while waiting for the rescue. LAME. Waiting between the time of the two tanks is forever. No way to get out of the bottom of the pit, but I know, just don't fall into it. No point of having just gas! Why just gas tanks? Put throwables all over the place if you are going to make us wait so long.

Conclusion:

I guess i'm angry after finishing this map - playing it twice and getting to the main rescue only to get killed by the tank because it wouldn't rescue me. The layout is great, just not enough though in survivability. I think if you added all of these things and made certain areas better and not so bland, visually, it would get an 8 to a 10. But as it sits now, all I can give you is a 5 for effort. Please update this map, it really looked fun, but just p#ssed the hell out of me with the lack of supplies and glitching.

Pros:

Well balanced levels
Lighting was great
Was able to figure out the maps easily with the arrows.. 
Plenty of hordes and tanks and witches

Cons:

Not enough throwables in certain areas
Not enough health / pills in areas
Not enough Melee weapons.
Top of roof platform mover didn't light up to take us from one building to the next, accidentally hit it and left my partner behind.. (woops!)
Area where you jump across the building was glitchy for the bots. Possibly put an arrow there to let us know that it's meant to be jumped? 

Conclusion:

All in all, the campaign was great and well worthy of a 9. Honestly, I would give it a 10 if it wasn't for the lack of health and melees. We really needed health in certain areas because the maps are extremely long (which I like) but not enough health. The level where need to jump should have been more clearly designed so that we knew for sure we had to jump there. But even though we fell down to the second level, it wasn't a problem finding the way back up through the hole. I really love campaigns like this, well thought out, and well planned. I can't remember where I noticed the bleed through on the map - I want to say the level where you start out and you have to navigate through and around those large trailers, but I could be mistaken. I only played it once through last night. The campaign took us about 50 minutes to complete, which was perfect. I hope you continue to make more improvements on this map and definitely, keep making them, you sure have the talent!! :) 

Pros:

No glitches
Plenty of witches, hordes, tanks

Cons:

not enough weapons. Boring with the pistols
Plain
boring.

Conclusion:

I first want to say that I didn't read the book. Second, I don't think a map should be boring if steven king's book was this boring. Just saying. Maps are huge, which is good in my book, but they are just open and wide, and boring. The only levels that I enjoyed were the last 2-3 - where you had to follow the river - up the mountain and towards the end. Obviously, no finale, last map, just sat there in that room after climbing ALL THAT WAY to the top for nothing. I'm only reviewing this based on as a player - playing a map, not a fan of the book. Like I said, it only got interesting towards the end, that part, I DID like. Overall, meh.

Pros:

AWESOME!
Great follow up to the first QE!!
Everything is perfectly laid out :)

Cons:

NONE.

Conclusion:

There is only one small glitch, but when we went down the elevator to level 3, there wasn't a can in place so we could trigger the locked gate across the pathway filled with water to get out of that room. We restarted the map and the can was sitting in front of the gated door. Don't know if it's a glitch on our end, but I'm not counting it in my review. Played great with 1 other player! :)

Pros:

Fast paced.
well designed levels
plenty of zombies, lots of spitters
decent enough witches
good finale!

Cons:

map crashes game during second map load - able to restart at chapter two and play through
weapons floating at the beginning of the third map - 
maybe 1 or 2 more tanks during the other levels.

Conclusion:

All in all, a pretty fun map to play. I will definitely keep this in rotation and play it again. I hope the author continues to debug this map and tweak it a bit more. It's really a fun map to play. :)

Pros:

Loved the maze aspects, was able to follow all of them through with help of the arrows and obvious paths
Ending was pretty good, especially when the helicopter pulled up and more tanks appeared making you hussle to the helicopter.
Nice amounts of witches, boomers and spitters, etc.
Hoards were plenty..
Car triggers were at the right amount considering it was a map maze.
Each level felt long enough but not too long..perfect. 
Laid out very well in design.

Cons:

Definitely not enough Melees
Definitely not enough throwables
Map needs more levels :) (5 would be perfect)

Conclusion:

My only complaint was listed above in the Cons. I've never been to Spain, but I definitely didn't feel like I was in Spain. lol. But, the atmosphere and lighting were good. City design was also very good. Felt bland at times (lacking more detail posters, etc) but over all, a very fine map, indeed and would definitely play this one again. Any chance you could make 2 more levels? Also, the arrival of the helicopter was a bit slow and unrealistic in it's slow moving speed. But, didn't really bother me, just an observation.

Excellent map!

Pros:

Loved the puzzle aspect.
Finale was good
Had fun playing it. Great with 2 humans and 2 bots..

Cons:

Too short. Wanted more levels, actually! ha.

Conclusion:

Over all, pretty fun map. I do enjoy these puzzle maps and everything was laid out correctly and didn't notice any glitches. Even though we were able to get through some traps, the bots just kept up with us. I only wished this map had 2 more levels, but all in all, definitely fun and definitely worth playing again. Up there with questionable ethics. nicely done!

Pros:

Well designed levels
plenty of zombies!!
love the tricky areas with the cars and witches
All and all, pretty darn fun! 

Cons:

None!

Conclusion:

You should keep making more maps like this one! I had a great time playing this with my wife and a lot of campaigns should contain atleast 5-6 levels..