Thankful but Terrible

Map 4 and 5 just made me out of patience.
Terribly confusing.

LIKE!

This is super creepy and epic! I really hope there would be a multi-maps campaign for this!

Pros:

Everything looks good.
The effect is great.
The background music.
All the customised stuff including skins and weapons.
Not so confusing (enjoy the L4D style rather than investigation)

Cons:

No signs or notice in some places.
Lack of ammo
The last map is a bit... well, funny?

Conclusion:

I would just say, fantastic and perfect. And it is sad to hear that you will not be creating anymore about SH.

Pros:

- Customised items and bosses (Really funny and creative)
- Atmosphere 
- Full of different elements, say, RPG

Cons:

- Difficult (not reasonable somehow)
- Some places are biased towards SI in which players may easily get killed
- Lack of clues

Conclusion:

The best I have played. Though some stages like map 3 are kinda difficult to get through even in normal mode. I used 2 hours to complete the whole campaign with three players. This is a bit long for me and I would consider it a bit excessive to some players (Anyway it could be only my problem lol). Anyways, I rate it 10 cos this is the most interesting creative and funny and exciting campaign I have ever played.

Pros:

- A very challengeable and creative map which requires navigation and cooperation
- Nice transportation
- Good atmosphere

Cons:

-Too challengeable: Following maps 1 to 6, you just feel exhausted. And the most annoying and frustrating thing is the finale. 
-Single person is virtually impossible
-Some glitched sites which make you trapped
-Inadequate supply

Conclusion:

A lot of hard works and patience has been put into this campaign. This indeed is very good. Cooperation is compulsory. Some ideas are interesting, for eg the gas which burns you and while walking on the mid way under the tunnel you will get hurt cos of the high voltage?. However, this is also too harsh for some players. The finale is extremely frustrating and annoying somehow. The length is too long. Playing with dumb bots for victory is just not possible. Overall, good work.

Pros:

- Without light you can't survive underground
- Spitter becomes the most annoying
- Well designed paths, objects 
- sopranos underground are somewhat frigtening
- Challenging even in normal mode
- Perfect length for this campaign

Cons:

- just couldnt run through the bridge rails after pushing the button... (or do I have to wait for more?)
- The space available in the train for escape is a bit too small

Conclusion:

Well made campaigns.

Pros:

- Fantastic, Epic, Spectacular, Amazing...
- Big map with several defence points
- Enough supply
- Help from Bill's team
- Dead player's teleport
- and more and more

Cons:

- A bit laggy, but this is actually unavoidable :-)
- Tank the most annoying (this is not the cons actually)
- Not that much, to be honest.

Conclusion:

Too many advantages. This is an epic story. And it's comparable to a campaign.
The environment is just epic and spectacular. You have to move to another point for subsequent defence (although that means you must lose eventually). The supply of ammo... guns... are never inadequate. You also get help from Bill's team. This is important (though they are not helping anymore later on) in order to survive for long. The teleportation for dead players is also somewhat important. This map is full of good ideas. I rate it 10.

Pros:

- CREATIVE - the characters, the environment, the objects...
- The design of the labyrinth is great
- The background music is lovely
- Can explore for a very long time
- And more and more

Cons:

- I can create game only if I delete this addon

Conclusion:

Fantastic piece of work. Gives the game L4D2 a fresh look and theme. 10 for sure. The only thing that upsets me is after I restart the game when I try to create a room for others to play, they just can't get in. 

Pros:

- Great atmosphere, nicely placed objects and the design of the buildings
- Good opening and ending (especially the theme)
- Balance of horde spawning

Cons:

- Slight glitch inside the sewer e.g. The tank gets stuck between the rails
- Repetitive art works (Could see the same work over and over again)

Conclusion:

I like the cage for transportation to the airport. The entrance of the cage is really a trap. 
The environment, the atmosphere is great. It gives you a deep impression of the theme of this campaign. I also like the ending theme very much. The long neverending stairs are fantastic and quite epic. What I don't like is some art works just constantly show up over and over again. I also faced certain glitches during the game. Overall it's indeed a good campaign.

Pros:

- A new campaign giving you a fresh feeling
- Gnome
- Nice ending theme

Cons:

- Too late for the tanks to appear in the finale...
- Lack of hordes on some locations
- Confusion in some maps

Conclusion:

The atmosphere is very different from that I have felt in other official maps. In order to tell the story more completely, I think some improvement should be made to the opening. The ending theme is also nice. 
A balance of hordes should be made for some maps. It is too peaceful in some places. You see no hordes around but trees or grass only. 
Sometimes the map also confuses me. For example, I spend more than 5 minutes to seek the barrel on the roof. But this could just be my problem actually. I sometimes find it difficult to withstand the waves of horde in the finale even in normal mode. I would like to see the tank appears more quickly so that I can run to the helicopter as soon as possible.
A good campaign indeed.

Pros:

- Fresh design that is different from the official ones (but is also comparable to the official campaigns!), e.g. bowling, cinema, customised tank etc
- Difficulty is okay
- Creative ideas e.g. The vehicle leading to the safe room at map 4

Cons:

- Glitch in map 2 (when trying to run across the boat above the river, sometimes you may get stuck)
- Last tank in map 4 seems not threatening at all

Conclusion:

The design is great since it contains many elements different from the official maps, like the cinema and vehicle in map 4 fetching you to the safe house. The tank wearing customised clothes in the finale is also fantastic. Map 1-4 would not be too difficult to players who have already undergone all the official campaigns. Drawbacks are not much in this campaign. Only a very minor glitch in map 2 which I have experienced and the final tank in map 4 is somewhat funny because it does not threaten players at all. I'd absolutely recommend this.

Pros:

- Very challenging especially when playing individually
- Creative!
- Abundant factors which spend you 30 min at least

Cons:

- Bots are not intelligent enough
- Hordes keep spawning
- Weapons lacking

Conclusion:

A creative work consisting of many fresh ideas e.g. custom bosses, a big map involving multi-stages etc. One can experience a very special fight which cannot be found in official campaigns. However bots are not reliable and the neverending spawning of hordes sometimes cause frustration. Overall this map is great. I'd recommend it.