Pros:

- Great and high detail textures
- It's still bright red which makes it still easy to spot, unless many medkit skins

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

My favorite medkit textues.

Pros:

- L4D1 survivors fit really good
- Love the lighting and enviromnent
- Survivor dialogue is not absent
- Challenging, we actually used quite a few medkits
- Really lengthy for a 3 map campaign
- AI acts good

Cons:

- Skyboxes in maps 2 and 3 have missing textures
- The finale is really laggy (both survivors and infected have laggy movement, some sound delays from guns, laggy camera when getting hit by zombies while running etc)
- The hole in the bridge at the end is really confusing, made me and my friend think we had to jump for it, obviously we couldn't so we had to repeat the finale

Conclusion:

It's a good campaign, the enviromnent and lighting in it are gorgeous in my opinion.
On the gameplay side, really good spawns, also it's more challenging than other campaigns which makes it more fun.
Well... atleast until the finale. It was so laggy it was more annoying than fun. I don't know if it was just my problem, but could aswell list it here.

85/100

Pros:

- Great model and textures

Cons:

- The custom sounds are just too loud + the sound of falling shells is annoying

Conclusion:

Looks alot better than the original M16, makes me want to throw away my SPAS I always use and pick that up.

Though I removed the custom sounds myself because they were too much for my ears.

Pros:

- Great detail and level design
- I love the poster!
- Good difficulty
- Lengthy
- Good infected and weapon/item spawns, also uncommon infected spawns
- Survivor dialogue is present
- Alternate paths and lots of areas to explore that are not tied to the main path
- This campaign has the best placed mounted machine guns I ever saw
- The train station roof base was a great addition to the finale, and makes a good defense spot
- Liked the ending song

Cons:

- In map 3 during the barricade destroying event we had lots of lag from too many common infected spawning
- In map 3 bots can get stuck in the mounted machine gun placed at the barricade event
- No radio dialogue in the finale

Conclusion:

Since last time I played this campaign, I don't even remember when, it was really well improved, from new details added to the maps, to more events and fixes.

A great campaign. I think it will remain for a while in my top 3 for this game. I'll give it a 98/100
Played the survival maps too but couldn't find any cons and the pros are listed already from campaign mode.

98/100

Also, care to mention the ending song's name? :)

Pros:

- Great map design and detail
- Good difficulty, in both infected spawns and item placement
- Really fun gameplay
- No bugs
- No lack of survivor dialogue
- Some pretty clever events, like the boat one
- The custom content in the finale
- Glad we had daylight on the Stadium map this time

Cons:

- Wished the train ride would have been longer this time

Conclusion:

A map that was awesome and today is more awesome thanks to this port.
In the beggining of the finale I was like "Oh no, don't tell me the author made this into 'run for the chopper' finale", but by the end it turned out to be more fun that a normal one would be.
Also I loved the finger custom melee weapon and the football player tank. They were really great additions to the Stadium.

98/100

Pros:

- Great futuristic look and space theme, as always
- Custom bosses
- Fun (though a little annoying at the end)

Cons:

- Short
- Finale is too difficult

Conclusion:

Another cool space themed map with epic custom content.
Though this one was too short.

Also, the finale is insanely difficult with average players and impossible if there's a bot in the team.

82/100

Pros:

- Well detailed enviromnent
- Really challenging, had some hard times even on Normal
- Bugless
- Good spawns
- Van is no more buggy!! :D

Cons:

- Feels empty in some places
- 4th map is really short
- Bots have problems getting in the rescue vehicle (though who cares at the end?!)

Conclusion:

A well ported campaign, as always, great work, fmpfmp!
This and Suicide Blitz were my fav campaigns in L4D1, and now they both get ported to L4D2, it's like a fullfilled dream!
90/100

EDIT: As The REAL Ellis said, would love an Escape from Toronto 2 :D

Pros:

- Great detail, events, music
- Big map
- Really fun

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

Hell of a fun, epic custom events, LOTR music, what else do you need? Nothing!
I know I did a review to this before. Played it again because some friends wanted to, and well, had a lot of fun with them, so I updated the review and gave higher score. I guess it really matters who you're playing with afterall.

Also LOTR is my favorite movie! 
100/100 hands down, really.

EDIT: Wanted also to mention I can't wait for the 14 version!!

Pros:

- Great and well detailed map design
- Alternate paths
- Weapons and items are very well placed
- Survivor dialogue
- Had no NAV problems
- Awesome custom events
- Nice car animations
- Ice cream van alarm xD
- Scavenge finale in L4D1 was way better than I thought it will ever be
- Some areas reminded me of GTA 4 lol

Cons:

- Some parts, like the train tracks, where invisible walls block you from jumping down in the street, would be great to have the ability to hang from the edge or fall to death in the street. (not a major con)

Conclusion:

A great campaign for L4D1 (hopefully for L4D2 too soon? hehe).

I have to say this is 10 times better than what Valve would usually do, and MY FAVORITE campaign to date. Great job on this.

99/100

Pros:

- Detailed level design
- Challenging even on Normal
- Variety troughout the maps
- Weapons and item spawns were well thought
- Custom sounds and voice acting
- Sacrifice tank in finale (don't know why but I love that tank model)

Cons:

- Could use more types of melee weapons than only axe, pan and crowbar
- Could use a bit more items in first level
- There is a breakable prop in the back of the train we ride, once broken some texture-less pieces of stone came out of it. Also, as JMantis mentioned, no train sound during the ride.
- Ferry in 4th map can be started without all players being on it
- In finale, in the skybox you could only see the shape of the mountains, in L4D1 you could see the city, clouds etc.

Conclusion:

This campaign was very well ported!
Maybe this was even better than the L4D1 version.
Didn't really expect to see many L4D2 weapons and items, though I was wrong.

A great campaign, worthy of getting a 95 (or atleast from me).

Can't wait for Vienna Calling 2 ;)

Pros:

- Good placement of health items and weapons/ammo
- NAV was fairly good
- Pretty challenging
- Midnight Riders jukebox present in finale, though it didn't make much sense why they would be in that location, it was nice killing zombies to the song

Cons:

- No survivor dialogue
- Swamp layout everywhere, gets boring fast
- Got lost a few times
- Some weird lighting bugs in some places, mostly finale
- Felt empty in some places
- No tanks spawned on maps 2 and 3
- First maps lack in grenades
- Jockey and boomer spawns in 4th map were ridiculously overused
- Too many hordes
- Major FPS drops in finale when gate epxlodes, making it unplayable for most players, happily I could finish it with a 15 FPS from the normal 80+ I had in the rest of the campaign

Conclusion:

This campaign gave me the same feeling 2 Evil Eyes did, maybe because of the constant swamp layout. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, but it gets boring pretty fast having all maps like that. (and No, 2EE had nothing to do with the score I gave this)

Apart from that this needs some serious optimizations.
Sorry, but I can't say it was a pleasure to play this campaign.

60/100

Pros:

- Pretty detailed
- Original events and ideas, like the army flooding the town with toxin, and armored ambulance
- Good feeling knowing the army are still evacuating survivors from the city except us
- Air strike system in 3rd map is awesome
- Good voice acting
- Lots of great cutscenes

Cons:

- No witches
- In finale you can get lost, and with the toxin chasing you that's fatal
- Ellis got stuck in the couch in the last saferoom and the toxin killed him
- Bots always die in finale because they remain behind and the toxin gets them

Conclusion:

A great campaign that includes lots of original events and new gameplay styles.
Though I don't recommend it if you don't like being chased down by things. Nah just kidding, this is a must play.

92/100

Pros:

- One of the most detailed 
- Good balance of difficulty
- Items and weapons placements are very well thought
- Original L4D1 survivors
- Survivor dialogue still present from L4D1 version
- Original events
- Full of custom content
- Lots of alternate ways
- Looks like Virgil bought himself a plane

Cons:

- Bots refused to pick up items sometimes, mostly in 3rd and 5th map.
- Some FPS issues in the finale
- Gets a little boring after a single playtrough

Conclusion:

So I decided to edit my review after a 2nd playtrough. Doesn't really have much replay value, since some parts get boring when played again and again.

Still, this is a great campaign to play with your friends. Great gameplay and stunning details.
Anyone must play this map, atleast once.

Loved Portal: Prelude, and I loved this too, hopefully you'll make more projects in the future.

Pros:

- Good detail
- Had a The Sacrifice feeling
- Good NAV, had no problems with bots or infected acting weird
- Length
- Maps were fun
- Generator finale was epic

Cons:

- Still crashing half-way trough the first map
- Skybox still bugged for me
- Not a major con, but the Jimmy Gibbs car at the end looked clean like in the mall in Dead Center, shouldn't it be damaged/bloody since they drove over zombies with it?

Conclusion:

A great campaign, really loved the Sacrifice feeling of it, though we weren't able to finish 1st map (see cons.)
Version 2.0 wasn't really a difference from version 1, but still it was worth playing.

Still needs some things tweaked. I'll give it a 92.

Pros:

- Well detailed
- Item, ammo and weapon placements are very good
- Long. I like long.
- A LOT of survivor dialogue, which I really loved
- Lots of epic events, original or not, still very fun
- Lots to explore
- Saferooms replaced with vehicles
- Good NAV overall

Cons:

- FPS drops on first map mostly (from 60 to 20 FPS in some areas), and a bit on the other ones (from 60 to 30 - 40 FPS)
- Some Valve models seemed a bit too overused
- In 2nd map, before the truck escape, the bot refused to move into the base's courtyard and died
- Some invisible walls in the finale
- Survivors instantly fall to their death in the water of the finale from plenty of spots, without hanging from the edge

Conclusion:

This is a great campaign, a few bugs here and there, but it was really fun.
Though FPS issues must be fixed, quite annoying for those with a slower PC.

If this will ever be updated again I'd gladly download and play it again.

90/100

Pros:

- Pretty good detailed
- Good level design
- Variety from level to level
- Good placement of ammo and weapons
- Long maps
- Good NAV overall

Cons:

- No intro
- In the beggining of 4th map there are no medkits. Not even ammo
- In the small mall area with the crescendo event we got a little confused on how to get to the switch
- Finale a bit too difficult
- Skybox in finale is seriously bugged
- In 2 or 3 places bots refused to go up ladders
- Stats at the end of the campaign don't work. All were 0
- Some areas felt like they were copised from Valve campaigns

Conclusion:

Well we had fun with this map, but it needs some serious optimizations before it will look really good.

75/100

Pros:

- Well detailed
- Good length for 3 maps
- GHOSTS
- Awesome sounds
- The faces and self-closing doors in the mansion were really creepy
- Funny wall writings
- The fireplace texture was fixed
- Very good weapons/ammo/items placing
- One of the few, or even the only custom campaign I played and actually had more than 1 or 2 vomit jars in it.

Cons:

- The finale NAV is broken. We only sau like 2 - 3 common infected the whole way trough it.
- Apparently I'm not able to see the moon anymore since the update, though my friends can. I really liked that moon :(

Conclusion:

I did review this map before, just updated the review for version 1.1

An awesome campaign, but still I'd like to know why the finale NAV was broken. Is it the campaign's fault or it's some error I ran into? Oh, and the finale map loads it says in the console "Flow is broken".

Pros:

- Nice detail
- Night time in all maps adds a nice L4D1 feeling
- Lengthy for 4 maps
- Reminds me of The Passing and No Mercy
- Not hard but still not very easy, good balance of difficulty
- Ammo and weapons placement are well thought
- I loved the finale, very nice idea
- Didn't encounter any NAV problems at all

Cons:

- In the finale, if you look outside the building you only see a small flatgrass with 1 or 2 trees on it and you can see the map's borders
- A few parts seemed copied from Valve's campaigns

Conclusion:

A very well made campaign, good NAV, good detail, good gameplay, an awesome finale, what else would you want?
Although this is not perfect, I'll give it a 92/100.

Pros:

- Nicely detailed
- Challenging
- Lenghty
- Good placing of weapons, ammo and items
- Lots of witches
- Many crescendo events
- Knife and riot shield spawn
- The last 2 maps remind me of the Passing
- Nice finale + the l4d1 survivors

Cons:

- Nothing except some Nav problems

Conclusion:

A great campaign, one of the best.
Maps are longer than usual but very well made and enjoyable.

I love this campaign, and going to play it in the future too.

Pros:

- Fun
- Detailed
- Good placement of items
- Original crescendo on map 2
- Finale is in an open big area. Running for the switch to open the stairs door was pretty challenging with the tanks keep spawning.
-  M60 in the finale

Cons:

- In the finale both the tanks got stuck, I have no idea where, I searched for them around the map but they were nowhere to be found. And they wouldn't even die...
- 3 witches next to each other in the 1st map. Seriously? All the bots wasted the medkits because of them.
- Felt too short
- Could have been better if there was a double tank spawn in the finale
- Horde (sometimes tanks) blocked the exit in the finale
- Bots have a hard time getting in the helicopter

Conclusion:

A good campaign. Too tired to write a conclusion ._.

Pros:

- Detailed
- Challenging
- Lenghty
- Nice intro
- Very well done finale, and original too
- Gnome Chompski :D
- Nice crescendo events
- Very good placement of weapons, ammo and items
- Lots of fun

Cons:

- Had some fps issues in the finale
- A charger knocked me up on a truck from where I could get out of the map, don't remember where
- Hard for the survivors on Versus

Conclusion:

Very well done campaign.
Going to keep it and play it with my friends, they gonna love it. :)

Pros:

- Awesome finale, I liked the CEDA laptop
- Pwning zombies in a school :D
- Detailed
- Lenghty

Cons:

- Repetitive in some places
- First time we played 2nd level the red door that activates the alarm didn't open, and we had to kill ourselves
- In the 2nd level, after the alarm door my friend died instantly from something, maybe a bug, I didn't see...
- Empty in some places
- Saferoom is accessible during finale. I didn't use it ofc.

Conclusion:

We encountered some bugs during the 2nd level, but still we enjoyed this campaign.
Overall a great campaign. It's a must have.

Pros:

- Fun
- TF2 map and sounds
- Nice rescue vehicle
- Longer than other finales
- Bots act very good

Cons:

- A bit easy

Conclusion:

An almost perfect map.
I love it!
I'll keep this and play it with my friends :)

Pros:

- Finding barrels is fun
- Lenghty
- Challenging in some parts
- Custom rescue vehicle
- Original finale
- Open areas

Cons:

- No intro
- On 3rd map I spawned outside the map
- On 4th map, the items in the saferoom spawned under the table, and we were not able to get them
- On 4th map, the end saferoom is not same as the one in which you begin in 5th map
- 3rd and 4th maps look unfinished
- Lots of nav errors on 3rd and 4th maps
- Clicking all 3 triggers in the same time in the first map can be a pain in the ass
- Bridge in 2nd map has **** textures
- In the beggining of 3rd map zombies come out of the water (shouldn't it kill them?)
- Veri few melee weapons and pills/adrenaline
- The elevator on 5th map is a bit buggy

Conclusion:

Lots of bugs to get fixed. 3rd and 4th map not even playable in singleplayer as bots get stuck.
Overall is a great campaign (ignoring the bugs).

I'll look forward to playing newer versions when released.
I'll change my review accordingly.

Pros:

- Very creative
- Challenging
- Nice boss

Cons:

- With bots it's damn hard!!
- First time I played: a moving wall trap killed me and had to start from beggining.
- Second time I played: boss killed me and had to restart again. -.-

Conclusion:

Great map, but it's annoying to go back to the beggining because u died of some trap you didn't expect.
Boss is f*cking hard with bots.
How many health does he have anyway!? I wasted like 8 assault rifles on him before dying ._.

I'm not gonna try your Space Jockeys map until I get some friends to help.

Pros:

- Awesome design
- Very fun to explore
- Small survivors and zombies :)
- BIG

Cons:

- Can't go up the stairs..

Conclusion:

This map is a must have.
If there wasn't the issue about the stairs I would have gave it 100/100.
Played some of your bedroom maps in Rune, Unreal Tournament and Team Fortress 2 too. They're all as awesome as this one.

Pros:

- Nice campaign, looks exactly like in UT, but it looks a bit weird in L4D imo

Cons:

Can't think of any

Conclusion:

I still have UT installed on my PC, I was always playing it the last years.

Pros:

- Lots of fun
- Great replica of the real Helm's Deep from LOTR
- Very big
- Custom music :)
- The wall exploding around 4:30 on the timer was awesome, like in the movie, didn't expect it
- Lots of choices for strategy

Cons:

- The custom music + the tank music sounds bad..is there anyway to stop the tank music?

Conclusion:

Great map. Loved it as I'm a fan of Lord of The Rings.
I'll proudly give this map an 100/100.

Pros:

- Finding glyphs is fun
- Awesome boss
- Love those weird moments when the witch appears (it even scared me once)

Cons:

- Bots fail too much in this map

Conclusion:

A great map, and greatest boss I've seen in L4D. 
I totally recommend downloading this.

Pros:

- Greatly (is that a word?) made.
- Feels like one of Valve's official campaigns.
- Loved all those places I've been trough, mostly the train part and the stadium (finale).

Cons:

- The train part is a bit laggy.
- It didn't really feel so exciting, nothing special.

Conclusion:

Overall great map. I recommend it, it's a must play.
Had a lot of fun with it :)