Pros:

-Unique Location
-Terrific Detail
-Great weapon placement
-Great Level Design
-Interesting campaign progression

Cons:

-Terrible Finale

Conclusion:

This map would have been absolutely perfect. But that finale is total garbage. It feels like college started and you didn't have the time to work on this campaign anymore. You can't even shine your flashlight on the big giant box in the middle of the end room. The color alterations were interesting but unnecessary. The cutscene at the end was just stupid. It really kills this campaign. Fix it and you'll get a well diserved 100. For now.. it's a 70 sorry. 

Pros:

-Unique
-Fun
-Creative Story
-Haunted Mansion with Disney World easter eggs
-Custom Sounds

Cons:

-TOO BRIGHT
-I didn't think map 4 was all that interesting
-Custom sounds still don't work in l4d2

Conclusion:

I love this campaign. Its one of my favorites. But I noticed something today. The Haunted Mansion is WAY too bright. It should be very very dark. There seems to be light emitting from..nothing. Make it darker, we have flashlights its ok. Currently this map is brighter than the actual disney ride.

Pros:

-Bowling Alley and Movie Theatre
-Custom Sounds/Voice
-Moving Train level ending
-Professional grade and solid gameplay
-Challenging
-Unique and epic finale

Cons:

-Bots would get stuck behind sometimes at ladders

Conclusion:

This map has got to be easily the best L4D custom campaign i have ever played. You had your own custom writing on the walls, your own voice overs, bowling alleys, movie theatres, holding cells, EVERYTHING! You even invented your own football team and made it a central theme throughout the final level. I loved it! 100% MUST HAVE level! I look forward to playing this on L4D2! You better not forget about it!

Pros:

-Custom Sounds
-Creative Levels
-Scary Objects pop out at you
-Long and Challenging finale
-Wedding Themed zombies inside the mansion

Cons:

-Too Much Ammo
-Fireplace missing Textures in map 2
-Bots fall to their death at the entrance to the haunted mansion (the deep well) 
-Custom Moon's reflection in water didn't work correctly
-Finale escape vehicle was kinda lame an uncreative. It also drives right into a rock wall at the end 0_0
-No intro cutscene 
-No events where you have to hold off and fight, constantly moving

Conclusion:

I think its a creative, fun map with terrific custom sound effects and even little ghost easter eggs hidden here and there. Some of the pictures in the mansion are kinda silly but it works cause the map is a little silly to begin with. Instead of using invisible walls, try blocking things off accordingly with furniture or something better than a thin rope.

It also feels REALLY similar to your Night Terror campaign.. which you need to FIX!!!!

Pros:

-Difficult
-Scary
-Unique
-Cool Finale
-Fake Saferoom lol

Cons:

-That it doesn't have higher ratings
-Endless special infected spawns
-No indication of where to go for the escape vehicle

Conclusion:

This map is difficult, dark and scary and i LOVE it. My only real complaint is at the finale after clearing out 2 hordes and tanks, there's no indication that the rescue vehicle is in a different area. I was waiting forever for some truck to show up. Its very confusing. But this gets a 100 from me because it needs to have higher ratings. 

Pros:

-Urban
-Custom Music at start?
-

Cons:

-Title in game play, its ugly
-BAD OPTIMIZATION
-Not detailed very well
-3 witches in a row

Conclusion:

To me it just feels like an empty boring version of No Mercy. Its a small city campaign with nothing really unique about it. I loved the collapsed building at the intro and the custom sounds here and there. But the lag just ruined it for me. There was no warning that there was a lot of witches so it was just random and idk.. it wasn't as polished as it could be. I gave it a 60 sorry man.

Pros:

-Variety in maps
-New Melee Weapons
-Better lighting
-Rain effects are awesome
-Haunted mansion still is my favorite

Cons:

-Custom Sounds are missing and ruin this campaign
-The Mines of Moria are very confusing to navigate, make use of lighting to show us where to go
-Lighting is a bit too bright in the Haunted Mansion, i remember it being a lot darker ont he actual ride

-Where's the green ghosts that sit next to you on the car? MAJOR disappointment lol

Conclusion:

Overall it's an absolutely amazing campaign. Very creative idea, the levels aren't very creative considering they're all copied from movies and attractions, but the fact that we can kill zombies in them is cool. 

Did valve confirm that they were going to put custom sounds back into the game? Or did they remove the custom sounds because of copyright issues? 

Pros:

-Rain Effects
-L4D2 Weapons
-Creative Survival Idea
-Simple Map=Great Gameplay

Cons:

-When launching the survival, the loud "Nooo!" screams are annoying. 
-No Counter for how much wood you have
-No sound effects for when you try build boards
-Random door breaking sounds whenever a new object is dropped (doesn't make sense)

Conclusion:

This map was awesome when i tried it in Left4Dead 1 and I'm glad it can be included with the l4d2 survival maps. I will be keeping this one because it is simple, creative, and loads of fun! But i would like the "Noo!" dialogue to be removed. 

Pros:

-Use of updated graphics was awesome

-I love the daytime effect as it makes it a map worth playing over again

-Very original ending with the balloon, always loved that

-Overall clean and polished campaign

Cons:

-No escape finale music for some reason (no mission complete music either) 

-Unnecessary light fixtures are on outside, have them off to help with FPS even more

-Have zombies spawn closer at finale as its way too easy

-shape the beaches at finale so they look more rounded. Looking from the top of the lighthouse, it looked like the island was perfectly square and looked bad. 

Conclusion:

I've always loved this campaign, i didn't play through all of this versoin,  i just tried the finale cause it looked like it was going to be good. And the graphics looked siiick i loved it. But i must've had some glitch, there was NO music after killing the 2nd tank in the finale and i had no music for the rest of the finale including credits. 
I agree with other posts, to make the finale even better, make clouds gradually start filling the sky throughout the campaign. In the finale, have it drizzle as your going up the mountain, and then have a huge epic storm when you start the finale. It would be a VERY impressive ending with the storm effects. 

Pros:

-Excellent Graphical Detail
-Snow/Ice looks pro
-Several places to try/experiment with
-Good weapon/item spread
-Great variety in locations
-Thank you for including Juke Box
-Solid FPS

Cons:

-No switch to start the horde, this makes it very hard to prepare which is one of the best parts of survival. 

Conclusion:

The detail looks terrific! I love this map and is by far my favorite survival map. Great FPS, especially with the amount of detail you put in. DOWNLOAD THIS MAP. This is a great map to play and has a very fair balance. I have never tried scavenge but I'm sure it would be loads of fun in this map. 

Maybe a campaign with this location in finale??? I think it would be number 1 easily. 

Pros:

-Excellent Level design
-I love house based survival maps
-Great Survival Starting switch :P
-Gory and Distrubing

Cons:

-FPS were really bad and made this map one I only tried once

Conclusion:

This map would be terrific if it was optimized better. My FPS suffered noticably and that always will turn me off to a map. Good design and I never saw Braindead but i trust that your attention to detail was spot on. 

Pros:

-Creative level design
-Escaping a burning building was a great idea

Cons:

-Custom tank skin isn't as good as it could be
-Custom Voice Over was BAD. Corny voice acting.
-Custom Level Completion music was cheesy
-Custom tank song was cool at first, but would not be disabled until i completely removed the campaign from my files

-Fire texture was bad
-No clear path given at the start of the campaign
-Finale was way too easy
-The building was exploding in chapter 5... but by the Finale I'm guessing the zombies downstairs managed to put the fire out?

Conclusion:

The customizations are credible for effort. But some things are better left undone and more concentration should have been on the map itself rather than the music and skins. I was not as satisfied playing this map as i was with other campaigns. 

Pros:

-Creepy Atmoshpere
-Challenging
-Good level design
-Solid FPS
-Short but packs a punch

Cons:

-Finale could have been better
-No Sound for rain in Finale
-No Storm special effects in finale

Conclusion:

A great, short, and creepy campaign. This map can be very difficult so be ready for that. The weapons are spread fairly and you better be careful entering EVERY door. 

I loved it and will keep this campaign. 

Pros:

-Crescendo events were enjoyable and exciting
-Fun building to explore
-Simple design with great gameplay capability

Cons:

-The design was simple but still lacked a lot of detail
-The streets of an apocalypse usually have a lot more detail, it looked way too clean
-the finale's FPS dropped horribly
-After killing 2nd tank in finale, you must activate a switch in the maintanance room which wasn't very clear
-Cresendo event in the large mall area of building was too difficult when you get to the stairwell. You NEED a melee weapon to get through it without getting incapped most of the time. This needs to be adjusted. 

Conclusion:

The campaign was short and felt a bit empty for it's immense size. The finale could have been great but the FPS suffered greatly. Its still playable, but its a noticable FPS decrease which I will always pick on haha.

Pros:

-Terrific level design
-Love the plane crash scene
-The finale was original and never done by any official l4d campaign
-Good use of the rain effect
-Original music in hospital adds a lot to the level
-I Love the dark levels, brings back the fear to players that this game needs to present

Cons:

-The Train in finale has no sound effects
-Bots are idiots in finale
-beginning of one of chapter 4 i believe, there's a huge open area with loads of cars and trucks... the FPS dropped big time at that part. Maybe reduce the amount of vehicles? Dark Carnival did it without sufferening framerate losses.

Conclusion:

The campaign is a must have and feels as complete as an official Valve designed map. Thank you for posting and I look forward to seeing another campaign from ya.

Pros:

-Funny and full of laughs for groups of friends
-The "?" boxes actually have secret goodies inside! Good and Bad
-Venus fly traps and koopa shells are present here and there

Cons:

-Felt like it was still in beta
-textures could have been better in some spots
-moving platforms weren't solid and easy to manuever on
-Points where if you go over a short drop, instead of dropping down, you hang from the ledge (some of the towers with spiral staircases)

Conclusion:

A fun map but not necessarily as good as it could have been. If you're looking to try a map for fun, this one will definetly make you laugh which was most likely the initial goal before. 

Try adding in a custom bowser skin for the tank.

Pros:

-Great attention to detail and decoration
-Excellent survival launch switch
-Immersive map that makes it a MUST HAVE for survival players

Cons:

-It wasn't released with L4D1 when the game was made at first
-It's still not on L4D2 :D

Conclusion:

This map was loads of fun. Plenty of different places to defend from, the kitchen, different theatre rooms, the lobby, bathrooms, etc. The custom posters and references to movies like "Night of the Living Dead" are a great addition. Ammo and supplies are places around the map in good locations.

Please consider making a L4D2 version. This would be a GREAT addition. 

Pros:

-Fortifying windows and doors is a great addition, stays true to what zombie games need to always include
-Simple map makes for a fun addition to my map collection
-FPS were flawless

Cons:

-Wood Collection isn't displayed
-didn't understand where the weapons were till the bots grabbed them already
-hard to find any more haha

Conclusion:

The map is a small enjoyable zombie survival map with the ability to break down furniture and use it to fortify your doors and windows. Plenty of ammo and probably easy to get Gold with a full human player team. Please get a version of this to L4D2 asap!