Pros:

-funny boss
-forest looks nice
-the puzzles
-hard

Cons:

-TO HARD!!!
-glitchy parts

Conclusion:

a fun map but it's a little to hard for only 2 people and 2 bots ;D

Pros:

-funny models
-actualy everything :d

Cons:

-only 1 song >;3
-nothing els

Conclusion:

it isn't christmas yet, but i feel warm inside already ;D

Pros:

-the book that helps you
-music
-actualy everything :D

Cons:

-with the fix, i don't see any cons :)

Conclusion:

waw... so mutch fun

Pros:

-good idea
-final is fun

Cons:

-puzzles look the same
-to easy
-very short

Conclusion:

a good idea, well made
download map if you want to have fun with some friends :D

Pros:

-waw this was epic
-love this
-one of best maps i played in a while

Cons:

-nothing

Conclusion:

waw i don't have words for it :D

Pros:

-i love surf on tf2
-now it's on l4d2 ;D
-looks cool
-plays good

Cons:

-hard when you never played it on l4d2
-on the screenshot there is firework, never found it
-bots fail sometimes
-was short
-gets boring after a while

Conclusion:

need more surf maps on l4d(2)!!    ;D

Pros:

-Original
-building is fun 
-need teamwork to survive :)

Cons:

-small map
-can't choose what you build
-bots are useless
-we had to kill them because they didn't come in rocket...

Conclusion:

a very good map, i enjoyed it very much, i recommend it especially playing with friends

Pros:

-it looks just like in movie
-i love lord of the rings...
-HORSE!!
-the music from the movie
-...........

Cons:

-i can't get to the end :'( a bit to hard

Conclusion:

EPIC map 
best survival map in l4d2
-you need to make the skins of Orcs and Uruk-hai wariors for the zombies :)

Pros:

-the first capter is a good idee and the parachutes were pretty good hidden
-the chinees wall is super cool
-the ending with the ice was awesome concept and well made

Cons:

-endig with the ice was HARD!!!!

Conclusion:

de design was soooo good and it was super fun!! 
you deserved the first price :3

Pros:

-slomo is super fun 
-good map design
-the custom songs in jukebox are awesome  
-L4D1 Survivors

Cons:

-takes long time to get the slomo back

Conclusion:

i love this map!!! =D