Pros:

-Great design
-The weather effect in one of the maps made that part very intense
-The traps were subtle
-Finale was great!

Cons:

-The map didn't really feel like it was unique
-The part with the boat was really...weird lol
-Weather effect started getting annoying after a while

Conclusion:

I can say that I really enjoyed this map. The part with the boat was strange though. It just looked so weird lol. The bots practically just walked the whole way, so the boat wasn't even needed other than opening up the blockade to the saferoom. The weather effects made whatever map it was on pretty intense. But it just gets repeated and repeated that after a while, it's annoying rather than fun. The finale was actually really easy on this map. So I enjoyed that.

But it doesn't feel like this map is really unique or anything. I dunno every map I play they feel unique. But this one just felt kind of "ehh" in atmosphere, custom content, etc. But you still did a very good job with the design and plot.

Pros:

-I liked the setting
-2nd map was quite interesting

Cons:

-Nothing too major that I can think of to put as a con

Conclusion:

I think that this map was just alright. It wasn't mind-blowing awesome, but it wasn't terrible either. It was pretty difficult (and I was only playing on Normal!) But one small thing that bothered me was that I got really confused on what to to do during the crescendo event on map 2. I figured it out, but yeah. Not a bad map though.

Pros:

-Great nostalgia
-Well done designs and models
-I liked how the Piranha Plants can actually hurt you and you can hurt them back

Cons:

-Gets a bit on the boring side

Conclusion:

I'm a huge Mario dork, so I knew I had to get this map. I actually really enjoyed all the detail you put into it (the blocks that actually dropped stuff was an amazing idea). But it does get a bit boring after a while. But don't get me wrong, it's still a good map! I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Pros:

-Like one of the reviews said, it feels like a proper L4D campaign
-The details were really nice! Especially in the outskirts and the prison
-The rain effect was really nice
-Finale wasn't too hard but not too easy

Cons:

-It did feel a tad bit short

Conclusion:

This is one of the few custom made maps where I can honestly give it a 100. I was really impressed. Great job on this!

Pros:

-The poster is great!
-The setting was nice
-Details you put were really awesome!
-Each map isn't too long, but they're not too short

Cons:

-The crescendo event where you open the emergency door confused me at first because I thought you had to find a switch or something to shut it off...Don't really think this would be considered a con, but more of a "I was assuming when I shouldn't have"
-The finale confused me. Because the "get to the rescue vehicle!" music started playing, but the rescue vehicle wasn't even there yet. So I was running around and freaking out
-There were so many tanks on this map! Thank goodness I was only playing Normal haha

Conclusion:

I thought that you did a great job on this map. It's not confusing (well, the finale did get confusing for a bit) and it's easy to play through. The details and setting were really nice! I love how apocalyptic the highway setting was. Overall, a pretty nice map. I'd play it again for sure.

Pros:

-The apartments were wonderful
-I like the detail put into the stadium
-The prison was cool

Cons:

-It lacked something...Don't know what either...

Conclusion:

I enjoyed this map quite a bit. But it just felt like it was lacking something to make the map stick out. The apartments were amazing though, especially the "unfinished" part because I was honestly a little afraid of that. The atmosphere was great. The little details were really cool too. Not bad at all!

Pros:

-Mall setting was nice
-Pretty challenging and long
-The details you put into it are really nice
-The intro was awesome!
-I love Hank, he's a cool man
-I LOVED that tune that plays when you're near a Witch. It makes her so much creepier
-Your own custom music for pretty much everything was interesting to listen to

Cons:

-The doors and gate part were REALLY annoying because it progressed REALLY slow. I know it seems like a challenge, but it's more tedious and annoying than a challenge
-There were a TON of Chargers
-After killing the two Tanks on the rooftop, they just kept getting spawned! It was honestly annoying as well
-It was hard to hear the messages from the radio/TV/phone sometimes because of zombies...Saddening too because those messages were actually interesting

Conclusion:

I did like this campaign to an extent. I haven't played the other versions of this, so I can't comment on how this lives up to those. I did like the custom music and level designs. I really wanted to hear what the guy had to say on the TV at the end, it sounded so realistic...but the horde had to come out of nowhere and ruin that for me! But all in all, I enjoyed this campaign. It was worth the wait time of downloading.

Pros:

-I like the atmosphere
-Designs were great!
-The ending was AMAZING! (after reading your explanation)

Cons:

-Purple skies (but that seems more of an issue with my computer and its files and whatnot)
-A TON of Chargers and Jockeys

Conclusion:

I thought that this was a fun level. But it was horde after horde sometimes and it got kind of tedious and annoying. The finale was also really confusing...maybe you can shed some light on what happened? Because I got super confused.

EDIT: Read your explanation and was amazed. Finale was awesome.

Pros:

-I like the theme of how all areas are interconnected by dreams
-The haunted mansion area was pretty cool
-The elements you put into the Jungle level were amazing! Love the idea of traps
-I like the blue hue that appears every time you finish a level
-The stairs section that appears in map 3 is AMAZING! Wonderful detail!

Cons:

-The sound wasn't working (but I guess that had something to do with the Sacrifice DLC coming out)

Conclusion:

I enjoyed this map. I really like how it's like a dream sequence. That acting as a transition was a flawless idea. I think this map was awesome. Especially the third map. The detail in that one was mind-blowing.

Pros:

-The details you put into this level are AMAZING!
-There are so many small scary things that actually frightened me (and I won't post what they were since I want newcomers to discover 'em for themselves)

Cons:

-When the finale started, there were barely any zombies
-During the finale, the tank theme started playing and I could hear it...but there was no tank that appeared
-Getting to the boat got a little confusing because the graveyard is so dark

Conclusion:

Usually, Left 4 Dead 2 isn't considered a "scary" game. More of an "action-comedy" type game. But this map makes it truly scary! The details you put into this level blow my mind. There were moments were I wanted to quit because I honestly got a little too frightened (but I manned up). The Mansion is the best part about it! Although these levels are a bit too long (but it's understandable because it's 3 maps long) but maybe you could've split it up somehow...but this is still a wonderful map.