Pros:

Very well detailed 
Vintage posters
Dodge Charger

Cons:

This is a very minor complaint so no points taken off. Its just that with the Jimmy Gibbs zombie being in blue and white it makes things feel a bit weird when the colours don't match

Conclusion:

There is nothing wrong with this skin nice job

Pros:

Very Nice details no big surprise
Looks like something he would wear
No Glitches

Cons:

Nam vet bill t-shirt Vgu

Conclusion:

Very good skin just iron out the flaw and if I have done something wrong please inform me so I can update the review

Pros:

Silent hill feel
Can get very tense
Lack of supplies makeing me have to ration 

Cons:

The bots are awful the worst I have ever seen in a campaign where they actually work
The puzzles feel silly

Conclusion:

It is a great map but the flaws keep it down. The puzzles yes they were in the game but they were stupid and really hurt the pacing. other then that it's great
On a side note try adding the L4D1 music

Pros:

Unique
Voice at the start
Can be awesome if continued

Cons:

Transparent door
Jagged dunes
Short

Conclusion:

I liked it but this is an idea maybe instead of being based of dark tower maybe have the campaign about living in the desert. You'd have to gather water escape from the endless dunes. That would be sweet but as it stands its pretty good

Pros:

Still well designed
Looks good

Cons:

Ending was disapointing
no survivour dialouge
teaser didn't work (no points lost)

Conclusion:

I was really hyped up for the finale given how much time has been put behind it and all we got was a cutscene, not a bad cutscene but what I would have liked to see is the helicopter crashing and you have to make a last stand, you know you are goiing to die but wont go down that easily. overal a good campaign with a real anticlimatic ending

Pros:

Great new look
L4D1 music
Good use of dialouge
a nice behind the sceneces sort of feel

Cons:

The 2nd level is god damn brutal and I couldn't help but feel cheated especially with the ladder that knoced me back.

Conclusion:

Still a great campaign but the difficulty might need some work

Pros:

Looks great
Unique 
L4D1 characters
Well designed
No visual Glitches
feels like a Japanese Fallout

Cons:

some levels just drag on forever (3 panic events in a chapter) 
can be confusing 

Conclusion:

Given the fact that it's in beta I will not be to cruel. if you can fix these issues when it's done I will be happy. 
Good luck with the project!

Pros:

Love the Beard
Tatto 
Makes sense why he hates Jimmy Gibs
New look

Cons:

No real body wounds or really anything

Conclusion:

If the con was fixed you'd have an 101/100 right here but even then this is still your best nick skin

Pros:

Very well detailed 
Fits in the universe

Cons:

there is no crashed Helicopter model

Conclusion:

This is a great mod just needs to addres that complaint

Pros:

Realism
Textures
Colours 
Awesome

Cons:

The only problem it thinking of one

Conclusion:

Excellent work looking forward to your future skins.

Pros:

Black AK with golden Ammo belt looks awesome

Cons:

The Phong is awful some of the worst I've ever seen

Conclusion:

It's okay but not perfect needs work fix the phong and your good.

Pros:

Very well detailed 
looks great 
No  glitchs

Cons:

Why

Conclusion:

Another great mod will you give these kind of mods to the other weapons

Pros:

Dirt and mud I missed you
Custom Views
Looks good
I could understand if Zoey wore this

Cons:

Why on gods earth is there Con

Conclusion:

Awesome sauce makes zoey look even more awesome

Pros:

Very good looking
Fits the Character
Blood Details

Cons:

No real dirt or much blood or other injuries

Conclusion:

This is probably your weakest skin not bad, still good just not great. Take some notes from The Project Realism Bill by Jayesane.

Pros:

Lots of Nice details
Red Jacket makes her standout
Iron Maiden

Cons:

the First Person view looks a little off can't put my finger on it.

Conclusion:

Again very good just fix the FPS view

Pros:

Well made 
Lots of detail 
Custom rings

Cons:

If I were to nit pick. This is more Valves fault but with his hands being two tonned could you fix that. I found a fix for that a while ago.

Conclusion:

My favourite of your skins

Pros:

Lots of detail 
Name tag
Tie

Cons:

S-mart isn't in the L4D-verse

Conclusion:

very good top detail. If you were to fix that con I would maybe do the Pills here store or maybe make him look like an I.T guy not a grocery store worker.

Pros:

I love the dirty and brusied look
Alot of detail 

Cons:

None that I can see

Conclusion:

I would give an 100 of 100 but I now belive that there is no such thing as perfection. but this is pretty damn close.

Pros:

Fantastic Level Design
Looks great
The witchs in chapter 3 
the elevator in chapter
The tanks in chapter 2 
great weapon placement
Very cool ending cinimatic 
No glitchs 

Cons:

Lack of Dialouge 

Conclusion:

This is hands done one of the best maps out there and best of all no glitchs. If it there was more talking between the surviours It would have gotten a perfect score. 
But still great job if you did add some more dialouge no complaints from me.

Pros:

Very Detailed 
Great Pacing 
The L4D1 survivours 
like L4D1 the deleted scenes 

Cons:

The bots got stuck in the second level for a while then teleported

Conclusion:

A very well made campaign with nearly no glitchs to speak of. Can't wait to see your future projects.

Pros:

great art style 
unique crescendos 
a vision into what campaigns are capaple of
Depressing ending I like it 

Cons:

L4D is not a platformer 

Conclusion:

a fantasic work of minimilism 

Pros:

Perfect Pacing 
looks fantastic 
great use of crescendos
Great use of diolouge
That part with the hosue with the lack of ammo very clever pacing

Cons:

maybe a little to hard solo

Conclusion:

this is a beast of a campaign. Enough said can you give  me tips leaning from the best

Pros:

Brilliant moments 
looks great
very well balanced to many more to list

Cons:

Nick Got stuck outside the safe house 

Conclusion:

I could go on for hours about how good this but I can't but all I can say is that it is a brilliant masterpeice of modding and this duo should be tasked with making the next l4d2 campaign 

Pros:

cool music 
good level design 
awesome finale balloon  

Cons:

a weird graphic glitch where it goes red and blue and bodies just vanish 

Conclusion:

a well designed campaign that needs polish 

Pros:

damn scary 
great level design 
Ghosts 

Cons:

finale is to hard or to easy never in the middle 
Ai can get stuck on ladders

Conclusion:

a well made scare fest that should be taken as an example of a great level design if these problems were patched it would be awesome but as it stands its great