One of the bests

Loved the finale
It was a surprise because its not in the screenshots!
Loved it though this campaign is great!

Decent but had some issues

Pros:
Maps look very good
Survivor Dialogue is a plus
Good weapon balance

Cons:
Lag spikes across every map in the campaign
Maps felt really congested, really strange but every map feels like I'm forced against the wall at all times
Didn't really like the finale too much. Just a giant tube that forces you in the corners of it, so SI can storm you. Very cheap level design in my opinion
Direction can use some work too and a lot of mappers fail at this (Use more lighting to lead the player to where they need to go). Despite every map feeling very compact, I was lost quiet a few times (Map 3 and 4 I think)
The main issue though is defiantly the lag spikes and the optimization. Despite all the good looks this map has, it doesn't really run that well. I would recommend working on optimization for future updates because that was my main issue.

Not a bad campaign though, just need some tweeks then I will edit the review.

Amazing

Great level design
Great lighting
Really loved the maps and the ideas of the overall campaign
Played like 4 times in the past few months and it was a blast!!
If you haven't played it you are missing out!

One of the best newer campaigns I've played

Call me a nerd but I really love the synth wave design of these maps! Huge music nerd so this is right down my alley for me! Super original idea and cool asethic! One of my new favorites for sure!!

Not really that good

Pros: Cool ideas, definitely is made by someone who has passion for the game. But needs a lot of work in order to be an actual campaign. Its a good beta, or maybe a draft for a future campaign though!
Kraken idea is cool, definitely see some space jockey campaign inspiration

Cons:
Very crude level design. Maps are overly blocky, bland and I can tell models are simply copyed and pasted in big giant blocky rooms
I'm not sure what the environments are supposed to be because they are really dont' look that good
Color Correction doesn't really look that good, it looks overly blue and I'm not sure why.
Tank spawns in the beginning of map 1 when you have only pistols that never happens in any official l4d campaign and thats bad balance
Saferooms don't have proper supplies sometimes and they look super bland. Why not add dead bodies and graffiti on the wall how they lost the kraken thing or something. There is like zero world building to this campaign, its literally just empty dark giant room to empty dark giant room.
Lighting is very crude as well, at some points it looks okay or decent but other areas it looks super jank, super bland.
Map 2, the slippery cave or whatever its supposed to be, it feels like I'm underwater, but the zombies run around it like its nothing. It literally is a pain in the ass to walk and manueve in there but yet zombies act like normal. Its pretty annoying and doesn't really look like a cave tbh.
I thought about it and really there is no point to map 1 and 2 to this campaign. They don't really add anything to this campaign, they are very bland and boring/poorly designed. I think the map would have been better if it was just the Kraken idea and you just worked around that. Because thats really the only reason to play this campaign in my opinion. I'm not going back to play map 1 and 2.

Hopefully I don't break your heart or anything. I wanted the cons to be as detailed as possible and straight to the point as possible. Wasn't a huge fan of this one, but you got heart and that will take you a long way! Play around with the idea maybe down the road and I think you can make a more polished version! Work on the basics first and then combine that with your passion and I'm you can be capable of better!

Lovely

Just lovely, great detail everywhere, the Portal easter Egg. This is one of my favorites for sure!

Amazing Map, Underrated for sure

First off, as others have said. The finale is quiet amazingly designed, the flowing river placed in the middle of the map allows Tanks to shake off molotov flames, which makes it more difficult for survivors but a little difficulty is not bad, a lot of times once a tank is set on fire they pretty much have to attack the survivors but with the water there, it adds a layer of difficulty to the map. Love that the higher you go in the lighthouse, the more dangerous it gets for the survivors. Its a mad dash, to exit when the tank spawns because fighting it in there is HARD for sure. The balcony of the lighthouse is dangerous too, one of my buddies got death-charged off the top, there is a lot of risk-reward in the finale. Its definitely not a bland map, it really sticks out as the best map in the campaign. The rest of campaign is really well made too, but I wanted to just talk about how brilliant of a finale you created, WELL DONE!