Pros:

-Cool Setting
-Like the special features of the map(lights lighting out and tank chambers)
-Map had small and awesome maze
-Great atmosphere
-Very Challenging

Cons:

-Spawn Room was too small and all good weapons were stolen already before I could even get one
-Wall textures were lacking
-Map was too small in each category, especially the sharp turns
-Bots didn't react as smart as they did in other survival maps

Conclusion:

The map itself is ok, but needs more work. I feel this map had no creativity at all. I really liked the atmosphere and and how difficult it was to survive (example: weapons and supplies are scattered everywhere), but this map should not be in its "complete" state. I hope this map is updated and is better than I see it now. 
Overall, I think this map is good enough for a normal survival map, except it isn't normal LOL. ( cuz it's in space :D )

Pros:

-Nice Design
-Much better than the original skin

Cons:

-Contains pistol with laser sight (impossible in l4d)
-Easy to notice in realism mode

Conclusion:

The box art and the design were pretty well designed. For the cons, the pistol with laser sight does not bother me much but what did is the fact that it was too easy for me to notice in realism games, gave me advantages (especially in realism vs) which could make the game for me and my team less challenging. Overall, great design. Respect your artwork and hope for more. :)

Pros:

-Fixes Content
-Experiencing no missing content so far in add-on maps

Cons:

-None for once

Conclusion:

This is such a great help, it really enhances my map-playing experience making maps look awesome along with their theme instead of seeing checkerboards in the sky, really love it!

Best supporting mod so far!

Pros:

-Nice Design of the map
-Cool Interface and Camping Spot
-Mixed Selections of Uncommon Infected
-MG Turrent is proven VERY useful for once
-Cycles of weather
-Fun to play in coop

Cons:

-Map was too small
-All infected come from one spawn point, not interesting
-Special Infected are easy to spot and kill
-Can get boring quickly (especially in single player)

Conclusion:

I kind of liked the survival map. I read the description and I understand this is your first map so let me explain the details of how your map turned out to me ShadowOasis. The design of the map is pretty great, especially the camping spot. The MG Turrent was also useful for once, especially against the whole horde, I did not get attacked from behind like in other survival maps. The uncommon infected were also a real challenge, especially since they have special abilities and sense. Although, the map did have a few problems. First, I would like to repeat the design and pattern of the map is pretty good except for the entire fact it is pretty small. Due to this con, it leads to the next that all infected come from one spawn point, which is the huge window above. I easily used the MG to kill all the zombies before they could land on the surface of the room. Maybe, you could have added holes in the walls or in the roof. Though, you did this on purpose and it is pretty fun for a change of zombie position. Although, for a beginner, you are pretty good at this map and the cons cannot beat the pros for this time. I recommend this map for others to try out and play, even though it will get boring quickly, it's worth trying out.

Pros:

-Nice mixing of videos
-Epic Music (I like how it blends in)

Cons:

-Maybe a bit too long, especially if you plan on watching the whole thing

Conclusion:

I really loved this mod, it is one I will be keeping, I wish I found this sooner. It was very easy to install, just make sure you put it in media folder and replace it with current intro, don't put it into the addons folder (just a tip of advice to everybody). Although, I do wish you removed some scenes from the video, such as Bill preparing his molotov, just makes me emotional man, knowing what happens afterwards :(

Oh well, doesn't  really matter much with the cons, I recommend this intro to replace the current one. The original intro is too outdated, especially since maps for l4d1 brought to l4d2 and special l4d2 events such as The Passing and The Sacrifice :(

Awesome Job, love it and will stick with this intro from now on :)

Pros:

-Looks Better
-Very Amazing Alternative to Tongue

Cons:

-Can fix the sound a little bit

Conclusion:

I really love this mod. It is amazing and very easy to use. It also works online as well. I kind of hate how that disgusting,smelly tongue around my survivor but the chains just look sick and awesome. The sound was cool at first but it can become noisy, especially with the sound. I love this mod and I want more like these. Great Job!

Pros:

- Very detailed and proficient loading screen 
- Suspenseful setting and background
-Great detail and clear routes
-Loved the creepy wolf sounds in the background 
-Zombie-Like Atmosphere
-Few shocks/ surprises 
- Lighting is simple and perfect
-Balanced zombie spawning
-Love the change in weather
- Like the added background music
- A lot of helpful map walkthrough guides
- Awesome tanks in dog skin
-References/Easter Eggs
-Cool Ending. Not bad

Cons:

-Map can sometimes get too big to the point where you can get lost easily
-Some events of the map are a little confusing to understand (scenario 1)
- Scenario events kind of share the same idea of the original maps

Conclusion:

I really loved playing this map. Overall, this is a must have map. My review and the others just prove how well made this map is. I recommend this to anyone who likes to play fun campaigns. I believe the map is great now and does not need further improvement :)

Pros:

-Great introduction to the campaign once started
-Very surprising sequences 
-Cool Earthquakes which cause dynamic changes to the map
-Nice helicopter support
-Looting Ability
-Awesome map in co-op mode 

Cons:

- Zombie spawning can be unbalanced at some parts
- You must restart from VERY BEGINNING if you die. I wish you split the map into parts. 
-Experienced a few bugs and confusion
-The unexpected traps were not necessary and made me start at the beginning again!
- Bots die very easily in solo

Conclusion:

I'll be honest here. I did not really like this map at all. I mean the idea is cool and all but first of all, the entire map is just highways with traps and looting. It was exciting and cool, especially with all the traps and surprising scenarios but starting at the very beginning was such a bother that after 2 tries I deleted the map (you cannot blame me, I just made it to the finale area after half-hour and to just die and restart, not tolerable in my case). I hope this map is improved and split into different parts. As of now, I would NOT recommend this map to anybody. Although, great job with everything, I expect better in the future. Good Luck!

Pros:

Very well designed map
Very hard-spotted and amazing easter eggs/references
Well made safe houses 
Climate of the story
Very Funny wall jokes 
Some references to l4d1 and l4d2 characters
Great character dialog throughout the map

Cons:

Map gets darker if at high level at any time. Needs more shadowing and better dynamic lighting
Supplies can be rare at some parts of the campaign 
A few crashes I encountered (Note to DannBo: Must be fixed)
Map can get boring and ghetto at some parts
Although the finale was cool, it is too mediocre and not much excitement came out of me

Conclusion:

This campaign is pretty cool and balanced. The characters have great dialog, also being very funny at some parts. I also love the design of the city and also the view of buildings and cars. The easter eggs and references were also exciting and felt awarding to find. It encouraged me to find even more. This was very challenging and fun. Although, the map itself, aside from the references and easters eggs, did not bring much excitement to me and seemed very mediocre, especially for the finale. It would be great if you could come up with your own idea and creation of a finale rather than take an idea and customize it off of other l4d maps. For recommendations, I do not know. Due to the pros and cons, it's hard to decide if others should play this. I just hope further improvement is implemented into either this map or future maps. Good Luck!

Pros:

Very Nice design of the map's structure
Great Levels
Fun to play (especially in versus mode against others)
A lot of creativity and hard work along with detail
Great scenarios 

Cons:

Zombie spawning is currently unbalanced
Mediocre Finale. I was expecting it to be more exciting
A lot of bugs were spotted

Conclusion:

This map is just so spontaneous. I really enjoyed playing the map. Even though I encountered all cons in physical and mental action, this map is amazing. First, the city and landmarks within the urban area are well designed. Second, the scenarios were just purifying. Although, I did spot a few bugs and the zombie spawning was a bit too much, this map is a must-download-and-play for everyone who has the chance to. I love the map and look to see more improvement in the future. Good Luck!

Pros:

Dark Environment
Disadvantages making the campaign of this map more challenging. 
Better weapon spawns

Cons:

Loading Screen is the same as the original
Some maps were too similar to the original
Not many changes
Not much supplies for survival

Conclusion:

Overall, the map was a great idea. I also liked how you made the witch sit down like she does at night time. Although, the map did get very boring around chapter 3 as it was too close to the original. It would have been better if you put more creativity into some different changes. I wish to see more creativity from you in the future. Good Luck!

Pros:

Great Design and Architecture of the map
Challenging Survival requiring concentration and movement of your character
Panels on the walls and those small bears, all containing special items/objects

Cons:

Movement of the map was lacking. The movement just went up and down the map.
Sometimes I would die for no reason even though I did not get attacked by the moving wall or any other source of outcome damage
Map got boring rather very quickly

Conclusion:

I like your design of the map and how you worked on it. Although, the problem is that you focus to much on creativity and map layers. The movement of the map going up and down repeatedly made the map a little fun for the first few tries of dying, but then got boring and deleted quickly. As of that, I still believe this is a map worth entering into movement contest. Richy221, all you need is better concentration and outcome of a map. Although, great job and I look forward to playing more maps that you may already have or will have in the nearby future. But sadly, I still think this map will need more improvement to begin with. Good Luck.

Pros:

Great Storyline

Tough and Challenging Combat

A lot of Secret Easter Eggs

Cons:

Too many Witches

Was a little buggy for me

Conclusion:

This map was awesome for me no matter what. The cons did ruin the fun just a little with the freezes and bugs. But no doubt, this awesome map is recommended for other players and I hope to see more in the future :)