Pros:

+good rendering
+beautiful environment
+conscientious work
+detailed work
+no bug at first sight
+great ideas for architecture
+map well thought
+the "wayfinding" : the option to follow a path or not

Cons:

-may be a little too short

Conclusion:

For me :

Very interesting map !
It was very nice to play on it.
Thanks !

Pros:

+long maps.
+all the details (a lot of details).
+different paths.
+a huge work.
+not boring because all the details are interesting.
+a great work of japanese architecture.
+cultural guidance.
+very beautiful maps.
+very beautiful objects in 3D (the foxes, "kitsune", are superb, and also the bells).
+a few extracts of Asian music.
+very few bugs.
+the cable car is very interresting.
+a lot of very good ideas.
+conscientious and meticulous work.

Cons:

-too many weapons and too many health kit so too easy.
-a few bugs.
-top-models japanese posters are not necessary.
-some lags (particularly in the city).

Conclusion:

For me :

A magnificent work. 
We would like to stay in each map to see all the details. 
We would also like to enter to all the houses! :o) 
I particularly appreciated the effort of the cultural informations. 
I really felt well in this campaign and I had fun.
It's a beautiful campaign !
There was also a nice poetic aspect (the temple, nature).
It would be interesting that zombies are dressed as the Japanese and 
that their eyes are slanted.

Don't change your way of creating.

Pros:

Really very well built
Lot of good ideas
The very large rooms (hangar, warehouse, tank, ...)
The size of the rooms is disconcerting, i like it ! it's a great sensation !
The factory and the laboratory are no frills, juste well built
Meticulous work
Just 3 maps but very effective and long
Undergrounds are awesome ! (glaucous, dark, bloody)
Some good gory ideas !
Ambient sounds are nice
The flying car is a fun idea ! I laugh a lot !
No bug !!!

Cons:

Cons ?! Hum ... no.

Conclusion:

For me :

I really liked your work ! Conscientious work. 
This campaign is very interresting and not boring. 

Just play it !!! 

Pros:

Same review, like the campaign "Silent Hill 1"

The world of Silent Hill is fully respected
The spirit of Silent Hill is fully respected
A lot of work. Conscientious work. Meticulous work. Very well built.
Not too easy 
Long maps
Not boring
The fog, like in Silent Hill
No frills
Puzzles
Alternative worlds are great !
The enemies of the game (Numb Body, Siam, Armless Man or Lying Figure, Double Head, ...)
L4D2

Cons:

Same review, like the campaign "Silent Hill 1"

not enough open doors
many bugs when the distances are large (the lengh of view)
bots are very stupid
not enough music of Silent Hill
not enough ambient noises of Silent Hill

Conclusion:

For me :

I love it !

Very good campaign ! very respectful. A big job. 
It is a campaign made ​​for fan of Silent Hill as "Silent Hill: Otherside of Life", I highly recommend these both campaigns.
Thank you Leafo, your work is a great pleasure !

Adding new models and new sounds for the specials of your campaign "Silent Hill : otherside of life", it would be great !

Pros:

The world of Silent Hill is fully respected
The spirit of Silent Hill is fully respected
A lot of work. Conscientious work. Meticulous work. Very well built.
Not too easy 
Long maps
Not boring
The fog, like in Silent Hill
No frills
Puzzles
Alternative worlds are great !
The enemies of the game (Numb Body, Siam, Armless Man or Lying Figure, Double Head, ...)

Cons:

not enough open doors, this is frustrating
many bugs when the distances are large (the lengh of view)
bots are very stupid
not enough music of Silent Hill
not enough ambient noises of Silent Hill

Conclusion:

For me :

Very good campaign ! very respectful. A big job. 
It is a campaign made ​​for fan of Silent Hill as "Silent Hill: Otherside of Life", I highly recommend these both campaigns.
Thank you Leafo, your work is a great pleasure !

Adding new models and new sounds for the specials of your campaign "Silent Hill : otherside of life", it would be great !

Pros:

+interesting theme.
+some original ideas.
+the beginning of the first map.
+the work done.
+the spawnings of the special zombie.
+big job too ...

Cons:

-lot of bugs.
-often boring.
-too easy because too many weapons and too many health kit, really too many !
-the theme is treated badly.
-almost no resemblance with Stargate.
-maps are repetitive.
-I fall through the grid of the elevator and i died. Very disappointed !
-not translated.
-too many words repeated every action done.
-speech too long.

Conclusion:

For me :

There was work but non-conscientious. Fortunately this is a beta version,
you must really improved this campaign. Despite the effort,
this campaign is often not very interesting.
FOR ME, it is not a Stargate fan campaign. In general, very disappointed ! But it is a big job ...

Courage for your work in improving ! :o) I am waiting for the final campaign ! :o)

(This is my opinion, thanks to respect it).

Pros:

+very good textures
+a big job
+very well built
+not boring
+a very nice visual
+I love the church and stone houses, well built
+mines are a very good idea
+many details
+some things to explore
+beautiful ambient light

Cons:

-too short ! maps and campaign.

Conclusion:

For me :
it was cool to play on it ! nothing else, just nice and fun ! thank you :o)

Pros:

+The atmosphere of silent hill (oppressive, dark, terrifying). 
+The spirit of silent hill (fear, anxiety, surprise). 
+The music of the game.
+Ambiant Sound.
+Game sounds.
+New models and new sounds for the specials : they are great !
+New models for bots.
+New models and sounds for weapons.
+Good textures.
+A lot of work. 
+Conscientious work. 
+Meticulous work.
+Very well built.
+Not too easy : There is no arrow every tow meters to indicate the way.
+Long maps !
+Maps "Lost", "Confusion" "Town of the silent Spirits", "Woodcreek" and "Dereliction" are really silent hill' spirit.
+Maps "Otherside" and "The Truth" are very good idea.
+Not boring at all !
+Random things (path, ...)
+The little stories are nice !

Cons:

-Bots are stupid !
-Map "Otherside" : bugs, bugs , bugs and bugs ... The changing textures have crashed several times the map. After 5 times, it's tiring.
-Map "The Truth" : It is very beautiful but very frustrating. Really too short !
-No end cinematic : after such a great campaign, it is very frustrating too. Too bad !
-Silent Hill' spirit has disappeared in the last two maps. Too bad !

Conclusion:

For me :
Very good campaign! Well built. I had a lot of fun to play on it.
I loved the atmosphere developed throughout the different maps. 
It is a great tribute to Silent Hill, as your other campaign "Silent Hill 1" !
Your work is conscientious and respectful of the game "Silent Hill". Thanks for that.