Pros:

-The customization is done perfectly. 
-It is more immersive than I thought it would be. The atmosphere is spot on. You feel like you are playin Minecraft more than l4d. 
-I won't spoil it but there are some unexpected surprises. 
-Good map layout (Although your brain does get a little confused as to which game you are playing so you have to understand how the layout fits in the Minecraft world and not l4d. But that's not a con. It just adds to the immersion).

Cons:

- PLEASE PEOPLE: Not knowing how to deselect the addon button so this doesn't mess with other campaigns is not a con.
-The only con I can think of is that the second to last stage is kind of tricky to navigate. Because of the "objective" of the stage, a lot of the hallways look the same and you can find yourself getting lost despite the arrow signs. Perhaps if the stage had more landmarks, it would be easier to get our bearings (just a suggestion).

Conclusion:

This campaign is a celebration of both L4D and Mnecraft. Funny how I learned about Deathcraft just when I was complaining about a lack of custom content for l4d. The core essences of both games are here and it plays great. I had a lot of fun and I want to thank the guys who put this together for their hard work.  

Pros:

-Top quality map from the moment you see the load screen to the moment you see the end stats.
-No other map has given the feeling of a very detailed zombie apacolypse.
-This map feels like a campaign from L4D3!
-Good challenge but not too hard and tons of fun.
-Play this with friends.(not saying that the bots are useless)

Cons:

-It is baffling that a campaign of this quality does not have an intro cutsceen. You NEED an intro for this one. 
-Minor nav issues.

Conclusion:

What I love about this campaign is how the spanish ppl of Barcelona handled the zombies before they got overrun. Certain locations and messages make us feel that this is a true apacolypse. I won't go into detail because I don't want to spoil anything. While there was a couple of spots that had the bots stuck in place, the biggest problem is the lack of an intro. The intro sets the setting and mood of your map. The mood and setting are superb but you just throw the players into it. Because of the custom "stuff" you have in the intro room, the intro cutsceen begs for some custom voices. Same goes for the finale. But in the end, this is a must download. Once again, superb work. Thank you all for your time and effort. One of the best maps ever made.

Pros:

-Good layout
-Graphically great from start to finish.
-No nav problems
-Not too easy and not too difficult.

Cons:

-Too short (See conclusion).
-Maps 2 and 3 lacked the beautiful China setting that the first map set up.

Conclusion:

Although the campaign was too short I understand the contest had a time limit. Here's hoping that you add a map or two when the contest is over. But my biggest problem was the lack of China feel. The first map was beautifully done and set a standard that the rest of the campaign didn't really reach. In the first map Francis asks Louis how to say something in Japanese. We see red chinese lights, the buildings had the chinese architecture, and other things. Aside from some chinese letters maps 2 and 3 lacked the things that made map 1 so great. How about adding a custom chinese voice when you activate the radio in the finale? I saw some asian billboards in distant buildings. How about placing them closer so we can see them better. During the train ride (which should be attacked by zombies, by the way) show us some chinese posters and maybe a statue. This is still a very good map and I thank you for the hard work.   

Pros:

-This is a very fun and entertaining map.
-Very detailed China setting
-A very strong competitor for the China contest.
-No nav problems
-Custom sounds add to the China feeling.
-New and fun finale. (very creative)

Cons:

-Too short.
-With the second map having multiple paths, and the great wall being so big, it can be a little confusing as to where to go. Please add a few more arrows in strategic spots.
-The end of the first map (Not really a con but it was a bummer for me). See conclusion.

Conclusion:

 The first map ends just short of where the fun begins. Have the player actually jump out and free fall for a few seconds before the level ends. When I was playing I was so hyped that I was going to jump out. But then the level ended when I opened the door. The biggest problem with this map is that it is too short. There is plenty of potential for a new map or two between the first and second levels. Maybe the players land in a temple area that they have to pass through to get to the great wall. Just a suggestion. You've proven that you are a creative creator so it's up to you. I'm just saying that this campaign was so much fun and so well done that it was over way too fast. I wanted to enjoy it a little more. That aside, this would be my pick for the China contest winner. Thx for your work. Please add more. 

Pros:

-A top quality map for L4D1 makes it's way to L4D2.
-The new areas and custom stuff are just as well done as the rest of the campaign.
-Uses survivors speech files not used in official maps.
-Every other pro is better off experienced rather than mentioned here.

Cons:

(These cons may or may not be my PC acting up)

-LONG load times between maps.
-Some framerate issues throughout the intense parts of the maps.

Conclusion:

Like I said, the cons may just be my PC being slow but I felt I had to mention it anyway just in case more ppl are experienceing this. Besides that though, this campaign is near perfect. The custom stuff is expertly done. There is so much profssionalism in this campaign that it does not feel like a user made map at all. I don't want to spoil anything so I will just say download it. It was one of the best in L4D1 and, with new areas and events, it is one of the best here. 

Pros:

-Excellent use of panic events.
-Natural progression from location to location.
-Detailed and varied maps.
-Great use of movable objects.
-The hero part is cool.
-Lots of fun.

Cons:

-Although there were no real nav issues, I did notice that the bots took a while to get onto the movable objects. But they always got on.
-A little easy because of it being L4D1. It's easy to camp and take advantage of choke points. This map begs to be ported over to L4D2. 
-This map needs custom voices. It was awkward for there not to be any kind of voice in the movable object in map 1.

Conclusion:

This was a great map. But I think it would be even better in L4D2. The special infected in L4D2 will bring a good challenge and make this map more thrilling. Please put voices for the movable objects. It really is strange without them. Great map. Thank you for your hard work.

Pros:

-Great map detail.
-Excellent use of lighting. 
-No noteworhty nav isseues.
-The change in scenery gives a good feeling of the survivors' adventure.
-Nice finale.

Cons:

-Map 3 crashed when I was at the wooden staircase.
-Map 1 was too long. Break it up into two maps that way we get a traditional 5 map campaign.
-Finale needed some direction. "Activate the power", "Wait for the hatch to open".

Conclusion:

What I loved about this campaign is that it feels like the survivors are just going from place to place trying to survive. In other campaigns they have a goal like getting to tthe hospital. In this one, they just happened to find the escape vehicle by accident. You said you put hundreds of hours into this campaign and it shows. The whole thing is very detailed and very well done. Just fix the map 3 crash bug and it will be one of the best maps for l4d2. One question though; for the title, don't you mean "Ascension"?

Pros:

-One of, if not, THE most detailed maps available.
-Custom sound, music, textures and props are expertly implemented to give a very creepy and tense atmosphere.
-Unique crescendo events are tense and really emphasis the need for teamwork.
-The "guidance" system in the mall stages is a necessary element that was done cleverly.
-No need to rebuild that stupid audio cache.
-The list really does go on........

Cons:

-If I had to pick a con I would say that the finale might be a little easy. But I do not expect, nor do I want, a fix to this issue.

Conclusion:

I remember playing DBD when it was first released and I remember how frustrating it was to play. Waiting 15 minutes to rebuild the audio cache just to play a map that was buggy and had frustrating crescendo events was not fun at all. But all the respect in the world goes to Darth Brush and his team for "feeling the wrath of the internet" and saddling up anyway to finish the campaign they spent so much time and effort making. DBD is the defenition of custom content and must be downloaded. Thank you guys so much. I really do feel sorry for the XBOX owners of this game. 

Pros:

-Very detailed.
-Clean nav mesh.
-Tint was well done without being distracting. It also added to the atmosphere.
-Custom creativity, especially in the finale.
-Good idead giving the survivors the bare bones. And even better idea giving us tier 2 weapons early on. 
-Makes the players explore for supplies.

Cons:

-Finale level was too long for a finale. Why not make this a 5 map campaing and have the fifth level the finale?
-Just a seuggestion more than a con but maybe you should remove one or two color changing effects in the finale. Or perhaps don't let them change so frequently.

Conclusion:

What made this a great campaign is the fact the it doesn't follow the rules of a L4D campaign. Survivors start out with nothing and have to find the rest. This makes cooperation vital since the whole team is vulnerable. It also makes you feel like a bad ass when you do find the auto shoty and mop the floor with the horde. Nothing against Bindal's opinion but the best campaigns are the ones that break the rules and gives the players something fresh and challenging. Like I said, the only gripe was the length of the finale. But a must download. Very memorable campaign. Thank you for your work.

Pros:

-Nicely detailed.
-Clean nav mesh.
-Good layout
-Nice finale.
-Lots of fun
-Loved the finale. I thought it was gonna be easy because of the close proximity to the supplies and the elevated position. But the survivors are very vulnerable.

Cons:

-It's not clear where to go or what to do during the gauntlet events of maps 1 and 2. In level 2 event, make the electric fence burst with electricity that way we KNOW it's dangerouse. As it is, you only see one or two sparks if you stare at it long enough.
-I was a man and didn't hide in the saferoom in the finale. Other ppl did though. To fix this, try and elevate the saferoom (if possible). That way the survivors have to drop onto the roof and once they leave the room they can't get back in.

Conclusion:

Very good map. It needs some tweaking. Maybe some more destruction and rubble, making the Gauntlet event goals a little more obvious and fixing the finale saferoom. But this is a lot of fun and worth the download.

Pros:

- Custom textures and sounds.
- Clean nav mesh.
- Pure fun.
- A great change from the more serious campaigns but it still keeps the zombie apocolypse theme.
- Ppl complained about it being short but I saw that as a plus. This was the perfect length for what the author wanted us to see and feel. 

Cons:

- I tried looking at the cons other ppl put in their reviews but I just don't agree with them and I can't think of any of my own.

Conclusion:

This campaign is more fun than the actual disnyland ride. Download it and enjoy it.

Pros:

- Very detailed.
- Perfect balance of challenge and fun.
- May be the best campaign made for L4D1.
- Great atmosphere.
- Multiple paths= replayability.
- Clean nav mesh

Cons:

- There was only one bug in the whole game. (see conclusion)
- Stage 3 may be a bit too long for some people.

Conclusion:

After the helicopter "stops" there is a log to the left of it (the log is also in front of the orange lamp). If the player touches that log he will be unable to move anymore. I could look around but I won't be able to walk or crouch or do anything else. Also the zombies don't see me and run right past. This is a bumber since this spot is so close to the safe house and if you get stuck you have to start the stage all over again. This is the only flaw. The rest of the campaign is, for lack of a better word, perfect.

Pros:

-Excellent layout. Even though most of the campaign takes place in the same building, no two floors are the same. 
-Exciting gauntlet events with multiple paths. 
-The vista! I actually stopped to look out the window and see the destroyed city while ignoring my team who was getting horde rushed. 
-Great finale. No room is completely safe. Glass windows and open elevator shafts are a real threat. The helipad lights mission brings something new to the finale table. I hope other map makers are paying attention.
-3 maps is the perfect number for a campaign that is in one building. 5 maps would have been too long. Good call!
-Loads of fun. The most important thing.

Cons:

-In the third map, Bot Rochelle fell to her death when trying to climb the ladder by the helipad. It was funny as hell but presented a problem. If you hang around that ladder with bots on your team, chances are they will slip and fall. Getting past that ladder as quickly as possible eliminates this problem.  

Conclusion:

A great campaign overall. Smart and original use of gauntlet events and the finale. I hope to see more ideas like these from other map makers. 

Pros:

- Fire and ice is a great theme for a campaign and is done well here.
- Skillful nav mesh. The bots had the AI of L4D1. I made more mistakes than them.
- Everything works well. No bugs. No glitches. No bots getting stuck.
- Setting, custom sounds, voice work and custom textures make this a unique campaign.

Cons:

- Lack of crescendo events. There was only that one gauntlet event plus the finale.

Conclusion:

This is the first true campaign for L4D2. Just like Death Aboard in L4D1, Freezer Burn shows what custom content can deliver to L4D2 when it is done with skill and care. Job well done. Thank you for your hard work. A must play.