Pros:

WOW!  Killer dinos in UT3!

Cons:

I said wow.

Conclusion:

Amazing. Simply amazing.

Pros:

- Shield regen just like other games.
- Fully customizable values.
- Makes UT3 more challenging rather than easier, really.

Cons:

- I've found the default values to be too high for "satisfying" play.
- Doesn't come built into UT3!

Conclusion:

This is an awesome feature to have in UT3 to keep it interesting. :)

Pros:

Cool locale

Cons:

Nothing really

Conclusion:

For me, just a fun map using max number of bots.

Pros:

- Adds what should be in the game by default!
- ...Including effective single-player Vs.!!!

Cons:

- Some not in the menus (Tank Rush, Witch Hunt) unfortunately due to explained technical reasons (requiring cheats)
- Somehow working in short descriptions would rule (but probably not feasible)
--------------------
Vs. Co-Op:
- It likes to start before everyone is loaded in (worse on some maps) and you find bots or yourself dead already, or the round gets completely skipped.
- The all-bot team only knows buttons and doors, and even then not all the time (or takes them like 10 minutes to activate one), but luckily can switch teams to get them going and then switch back.
- Sometimes makes my server crash for some reason (not 100% sure but may be related to having switched teams and back, or sometimes having used SourceMod to kill specials).
--------------------
- This mod doesn't have a special permanent advert on the main page of L4Dmaps.com! :)

Conclusion:

OH.. HELL.. YEH! A+++

I would like to recommend -- if possible, of course -- that Vs. Co-Op be fixed to have an at least 1 minute (probably 2 would be better) delay before a bot tries to open the safe room door. This way it would hopefully avoid the premature starting before all human players are loaded in. Rating will be 100 for sure if that can be done!

Pros:

- LONG (yes, that's good to many!)
- Lots of zombies is darn-tootin true
- Great visual detail & lighting

Cons:

- Not really 3 hours
- Ammo is scarce but not as bad as previous version
- Health is very scarce to the point of frustration
- Updated lighting very unoptimized

Conclusion:

This campaign is hot. Long with lots of action. To folks who love the game, it never gets "boring" at all. In fact, part of the thrill is exploring through such long maps to see what's there (and hopefully running into tanks along the way -hehe).

Only gripe is please put at least more pills here and there, if not kits. The way it is now is like hardcore realism, when it shouldn't be for a co-op adventure. lol (Note: Better in most recent version)

Pros:

- Makes pipe bombs look yummy!
- Different sound is cool change
- Color adds fun I say

Cons:

- Doesn't really make for a more noticeable pickup (the pickup glow kind of washes out the color)
- As usual, haters gonna hate!

Conclusion:

Nice pipe bomb mod! More visually interesting than other skins I've tried, and the new sound is gravy.

Maybe a metallic-pink version next?

Alternative name suggestions:
"Breast Cancer Awareness Pipe Bomb"
"The Paula Creamer Fan Pipe Bomb"
;)

Pros:

- Miranda hotness!
- Face animations

Cons:

- Seems short in height or just overall small in size (probably just used to her in ME2)
- No jiggly-wigglys
- Looks whitewashed if use "Glowing Boomer Vomit" mod

Conclusion:

Nice model replacement that works without trouble. However if the "Glowing Boomer Vomit" mod is used, it affects the normal look of this model.

Now where's Jack?! :D

Pros:

Awesome

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Makes the [f-in] Jockey much easier to see! lol

Pros:

Simply awesome

Cons:

None (except for the posting controversy?)

Conclusion:

This SI mod is great. The Charger is easier to see, looks like it's farting fire, and makes a nice hit effect to boot.

Recommended in combination with the Joker Jockey for some better SI visibility.

(Try this with the "Fully Charged" mutation too! :D)

Pros:

- Level of detail is astounding
- Nearly non-stop action
- Lengthy maps for a 3/3
- Surprises
- That "special room" ;)

Cons:

- None really!!

Conclusion:

Spectacular campaign throughout. Great job!

Update: For some reason just having this addon active is causing my l4d2 to crash on exit no matter what campaign was played. Conflicts with others?

Pros:

- Long maps
- Nice details
- Good action

Cons:

- Badly needs optimization
- Trip to finale too long
- Very weak finale

Conclusion:

Overall, a good campaign with great potential.

Pros:

Completely awesome from start to finish

Cons:

NONE, baby

Conclusion:

This is one of the best campaigns I've ever experienced, plain and simple... And that's where the plain and simple ends! The maps are awesomely detailed and rich, have incredible graphics (omg the pool area), there's funny drawings (hehe tank), and there's plenty of action to be had. Plus the finale can be painful!  YEH!!  Excellent work.

Pros:

YEP!

Cons:

NOPE!

Conclusion:

Best looking mod ever for my favorite L4D weapon! hehe  Simply amazing detail. Great job!

Pros:

- Awesome music
- Good atmosphere
- Nice scenery
- Challenging in spots

Cons:

- Tougher finale, please! hehe
- Nothing else, it's designed as it is and I don't nit-pick*
- But, has performance issue


*Well, except for the "tragic" ending haha :)

Conclusion:

This campaign is great all-around, good job.  Can be challenging at times, the level of which is welcome in my book.  Just the finale could be a little more intense.

Previously:
Unfortunately, I have to cut the rating down because of the crash problem that seems worse now with the 7/24 update.  Add-ons that cause the game to either disappear, crash, or freeze (requiring ctrl-alt-del to call up task manager and nuke) are not cool.

Me and a friend did get the 7/23 version to work, where he hosted local and didn't crash, but I did and then just joined after the helicopter sequence. But with the 7/24 update, me and another friend gave up after the third attempt because we both couldn't avoid a crash no matter what we tried (local host or remote server).

Update:
7/31 version no longer crashes, but now has a performance issue on at least map 1.

[I will definitely raise the rating when the performance problem is eliminated!]

Pros:

» Refreshingly lengthy campaign
» Lots o' action
» Colorful balls (bowling) -LOL

Cons:

» Just single tank at end instead of a team (ha)

Conclusion:

Awesome update to a classic!

Pros:

» Absolutely pure fun mayhem!
» Constructing stuff is just cool

Cons:

» None! (now that it's all fixed up)

Conclusion:

Refreshingly enjoyable experience!  Very fun to play.  The bots may be "dumb" but that just adds to the challenge (especially having to nudge them into the rocket at the end, but it's doable).

Only thing that would make this map even cooler would be have constructing the stuff inside the building actually mean something (like being required for something to unlock, or required to continue the rocket stages, or whatever).  Or how about at random times the power to the research console goes out, and you have to go inside the building to restart a generator (that when started calls a nice horde or two tanks hehe).

Pros:

Nice big map
Lots of cars for tanks
l4d1 survivors!

Cons:

Easily exploitable, or, "Ain't Hard Enough" (ambulances)

Conclusion:

Well, it's a fun survival map. Especially with the l4d1 survivors.  But it's easily exploitable by camping in the ambulances.  If you can alter the tanks to somehow get in them (they just dance on top), would be awesome map then.

Pros:

AMAZING FUN!
Great mayhem
Cool danger areas
Neat item buying system
Long campaign for 4 maps
Impossible above Normal?

Cons:

Impossible above Normal! (lol)
Forget about it with bots (heh)

Conclusion:

This is one of the most fun campaigns ever!  You just have to try it to see, won't be disappointed at all.

Pros:

Lots of supplies
Fun for survival

Cons:

Campaign neat but sort of funky (and of course short)

Conclusion:

Lot of supplies everywhere make this an interesting survival run, so rating is mainly for that.

Pros:

- Tough as all hell (big hordes, double tanks)
- Ultimate challenge on Expert (And that's how we like it!)
- Nice graphics, colors, and light
- Great use of original props (ship, head, pods, etc.)
- Chompski! :-)

Cons:

- Tank can get trapped easily under the ship ramp
- Can fall off the elevator and get trapped underneath (yeh yeh, just stay away from the hole)
- Ultimate challenge on Expert (And that's how we like it!) LOL

Conclusion:

Fun map! Nice challenge, looks great. Maybe the finale is a little too open but it makes it scarier to me, you are in a big station afterall. Also I don't find the map too dark at all, maybe some need to adjust their gamma a bit? heh