Pros:

- First map shows beautiful, expansive city. Impressive to look at. Really pretty.

- Balanced difficulty.

- Not too short, not too long/complex.

- Custom textures.

- Definite sleek 'futuristic' feel (although, I highly doubt many cities will look anywhere like that within six years).

Cons:

- Other custom content caused people to either crash, or appear as invisible.

- Last two maps don't really show much of a city, just running in and out of buildings / rooms.

- Events are... illogical; Not a single lift or elevator move that slowly. Anywhere. Ever.

- Lack of finale entirely. Anti climatic / dull.

- Credits glitch out and show 0 straight down for everything.

Conclusion:

Casual, quick campaign. Not overly easy or difficult. But kind of plain and I'm finding there little else to say about it.

Pros:

- Long, without being tedious.

- Good pacing.

- Unique (doesn't feel similar to other official or custom campaigns out there).

- Lots of witches, which made the sense of urgency/danger more imminent.

- Horde from various sides/angles instead of just one direction.

- Mazes were a nice touch, without ever being too confusing or frustrating.

- Multiple events.

Cons:

- We didn't really find any of the gnomes, so we still don't know what they were supposed to do.

- Boat kind of glitchy, almost made me fall right off (however, I've noticed this to be the same in any CUSTOM campaign that has any sort of moving vehicle).

- Lagged whenever there were explosions or too much fire.

- Scenery was somewhat repetitive ("Oh look, another corn field... or is it the same one?")

Conclusion:

It could use some polish, but overall it was a very well-made map, lasted a while to play, and never felt overly excessive or frustrating to play.

Pros:

- Well ported.

- Creepy.

- It isn't too jarring that it takes away from the game's feel.

- A bit of nostalgia every time I hear it.

Cons:

- None.

Conclusion:

Fits the sense of death. Creepy. It's ported well so it doesn't take away from the atmosphere of the gameplay.

Pros:

- Amazing rendition, ported very seamlessly.

- Good length. (Approx. 1 hour)

Cons:

- Found a glitch (or rather, an unfortunate discovery) that jumping into the water tower instead of walking into it caused instant death (as it was too far a drop and downed a person, at which point they immediately drowned) -- it originally looked as though he had simply disappeared until we realized what had happened. (Not deducting points for that, though).

Conclusion:

It was very fun -- especially working our way up, around and through buildings constantly which gave the feeling of it being less linear than some maps.

Pros:

- Perfect replica of Vampires: The Masquerade map!

- Nostalgic.

- Spooky atmosphere.

- HD custom textures.

Cons:

- A little glitchy at the 'white out' transitions.

- No way to skip ending/credits.

Conclusion:

We were so excited when we loaded into this map that two of us ran around the whole place going "Oh, remember how this happens..." and getting nostalgic over remembering all of the Vampire: The Masquerade game plot. Two of our players when running this map had never played the game, so they found it a little confusing. So, if you've never play Vampire: The Masquerade, try to think outside the box -- and if you have, enjoy the short stroll down memory lane! :D

Pros:

- Lengthy without being tedious.

- Good homage to the 007 game (had a few times where I said "Hey, I know where we are now!")

- Dynamic combat

- Good plot/story line

Cons:

- Buggy: multiple times we were unable to progress through the levels due to some bug or another affecting the necessary checkpoints / activate items necessary to progress (ie clicked what we needed to, but wouldnt open up the path and kept telling us we needed to complete the step we had just finished)

- Had to restart twice due to afore mentioned bugs

Conclusion:

Honestly, with the buggy-ness affecting level progression, I would never call this 'finished' and consider it to still require more testing and fixes.

Pros:

- Nice unique ideas and surprises

- Challenging puzzles necessary for level progression (for those who like them)

- Each map is in a completely different area

- Challenging events

- Lots of ammo, kits, grenades, guns...

Cons:

- Too. Damn. Long. It was tedious and started to really annoy us.

- Maps are unnecessarily long and complex.

- TOO many kits and grenades

- Do NOT play with AIs -- don't even bother, they will get killed non stop.

- Some areas not well marked out (ie a couple instant death areas that looked like it was the way to go).

- Some steam blockades caused instant death.

- Textures were dull and repetitive; felt stale after the first couple maps.

- Logistics: I don't care how strong an air vent fan is, it cannot push four people down and around corners in 60 ft or so of piping.

- Textures: some textures and elements seemed very out of place, inconsistent. It reminded us we were playing a mod and not official valve content.

Conclusion:

Overall, the unique aspects made this entertaining (especially the moving cart, it was hilarious to watch the zombies and even a witch get bulldozed and instantly killed on impact). I like puzzles to some extent, however the puzzles and map lengths were unnecessarily long and arduous, it took away from being able to enjoy the game. Would work better in a horror-based survival game as opposed to a FPS.

Pros:

- Creepy.
- Lengthy.
- Good layout.
- Custom content.
- Good difficulty level.
- The Moon. 'Nuff said.

Cons:

- The ending run is fairly difficult.
- AIs don't work very well (ie they walked off a cliff once).

Conclusion:

Loved this campaign, was very fun, though the difficulty was rather amped up with the AIs being overly dumb. Still, totally worth the play through.

Pros:

- Good layout.
- Lengthy without being tedious.
- Interesting plot/context.

Cons:

- Limited supplies at start.
- Could use more health kits / ammo.
- A bit 'dull' appearance; could be more interesting.

Conclusion:

I generally dislike rating desert type campaigns because I tend to rarely like them; but this one was fairly entertaining. It felt a little scarce sometimes in relation to kits and ammo, but that was woven into the 'plot' concept.

Pros:

- Good layout; not too confusing or complex.
- Very 'mysterious'
- Contains custom content

Cons:

- Too long, felt tedious
- AIs exceptionally bad
- Floating kits/ammo
- Finale was dull
- Most textures and background were dull/blank, wasn't very interesting to look at
- Didn't have the same feel as official L4D campaigns
- Finale felt kind of like a let down

Conclusion:

It was playable, but not really my favorite campaign. It was a pick by one of our other players/testers, and not really my style (ie ruins, desert type). That's not to say it was bad in any way -- I just think it could be better.

Pros:

- Expansive without being tedious.
- Good length.
- Good layout.
- Comprehensive 'plot'.
- Polished.
- Good amount of supplies/guns/ammo/etc.

Cons:

- Expected there to be more darkened and underground areas.

Conclusion:

Very fun play through. We didn't run into any of the glitches other people have mentioned. Very polished, well designed; feels finished and like an official L4D2 campaign.

Pros:

- Good length.
- Good map layout.
- Expansive without being tedious.
- Good difficulty/spawn scaling.
- Nice custom textures, make it feel more realistic.

Cons:

- Finale is overly difficult; non-stop tank spawns.

Conclusion:

It was a fun play through, lasted just over an hour. Unfortunately, I was the only one to survive as the constant tank spawn took out my allies. Didn't feel overly difficult though.

Pros:

- Good layout.
- Unique textures make for a good map design.
- Good length.
- Difficulty/spawning scales well.
- Good amount of guns/ammo/grenades.
- Approx. 1 hr gameplay time.

Cons:

- Found a strange error in the finale where zombies would just push players across the roofs without actually hitting them; a swarm pushing you off a roof was almost more annoying than a swarm beating you to death. :\
- Could have used a few more grenades, but not necessary.

Conclusion:

A very fun play through, lasted just under an hour. Can't find any real glitches/bugs, so a clean make.

Pros:

- Texture perfectly replaces pill bottle.

- Sounds amazing with "Soda Can 'Deploy' Sound" by TheEstevan32.

Cons:

- None.

Conclusion:

Worth the download; I recommend also downloading the Soda Can Deploy Sound to really complete the 'experience' of drinking soda.

Pros:

- Perfect rip; runs and sounds smooth.
- I no longer skip the ending credits because I'm too busy singing along.

Cons:

- The cake is a lie.

Conclusion:

Worth getting for any Portal fan ( and even if you're not!)

Pros:

- Beautiful and realistic looks / textures / map / layout.
- Expansive without being tedious.
- Layout: many different paths to take, without being confusing.

Cons:

- Makes me want to visit Japan; unfortunately I can't afford to do so. :(

Conclusion:

A very fun campaign, very beautiful, and true/realistic of Japan itself -- almost felt like I was really there.

Pros:

- Very creepy.
- Doesn't conflict with any other sound mods (that I've tried).
- I forget it's even a mod because it blends so well.

Cons:

- None.

Conclusion:

Definitely worth the download. :)

Pros:

- Feels more 'realistic'.
- Blends so well that I forget it's a mod.
- Haven't found anything conflicting with it.

Cons:

- None.

Conclusion:

Definitely worth the download.

Pros:

- I feel it looks better than the original, just because the glow effect adds a little 'mystery' to it
- Blends in so well I forget it's a mod and not the vanilla texture

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

Worth the download. :)

Pros:

- Perfect; makes me forget it used to be a pill bottle.

Cons:

- None.

Conclusion:

If you have any kind of can/drink skin for pills, this is definitely worth it. :)

Pros:

- So effective that I don't even notice it
(as opposed to before when I heard her laugh and felt my ears bleed)

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

Thank you.

Pros:

- Works: bots have improved AIs
- Bots now effectively use melee weapons
- Bots favor healing allies over themselves
- Respond faster to aiding allies
- Bots will close safe room doors (sometimes)
- Bots will split up if players split up, effectively assuring no one is left alone

Cons:

- Bots sometimes prioritize healing or aiding allies instead of closing doors, or attacking zombies (meaning, they may try to revive you without first killing the zombies kicking you -- effectively making it so it's impossible to actually revive you)

- Can't be used when playing custom campaigns, or else other players are unable to actually join your game (they get perpetually stuck on the loading screen at 0% loaded)

Conclusion:

Improved? Very.
As smart as a player? No. But I don't expect their AIs to ever be that advanced.
All around, worth using.

Pros:

- Brighter
- Wider area
- Feels so natural, I forget that I have a mod on

Cons:

- Not sure how I feel about the blue tint, tbh

Conclusion:

Overall, much better than the default flashlight, and I feel it almost necessary to have this mod on when I play now.

Pros:

- Ripped straight from OoT
- Nostalgic
- Makes death seem more calming and tragic

Cons:

- Feels a bit out of place due to game's music/sounds (the switch to slower music is somewhat jarring)

Conclusion:

There's not much you can do to get rid of the jarring effect in going from normal music to Zelda's lullaby on death. But overall, it's an awesome mod and it makes me feel nostalgic whenever I hear it (almost makes me want to get myself killed XD).

Pros:

- Very well detailed map
- Complex without being confusing
- Good amount of supplies / guns / ammo
- Good length (approx. 2 hrs)
- Plays like Valve created levels
- Loved the couple 'wtf' moments

Cons:

- (SPOILER) In the hallway with 4 or 5 witches, if the witches get startled and attack they become invisible when they reach their target (tested this without any other custom content turned on)

Conclusion:

Loved this map, and loved the (SPOILERS) fake safehouse and hallway of witches, they made me laugh. Ran into only one glitch with a witch that became invisible, though thankfully the AI just killed it while we laughed/wondered wtf. Highly recommend this to others.

Pros:

- Looks great
- True to FFX-2 style
- Moves naturally
- Works in both official and custom maps, as well as in co-op mode
- Replaces model, name and GUI

Cons:

- Rochelle's voice is a bit off-putting

Conclusion:

Love this! I would only love it more if Rochelle's voice didn't clash so much with it.

Pros:

- Authentic setting
- Well laid out
- Complex map without being confusing
- Plenty of supplies + weapons
- Stays true to L4D style

Cons:

- In some areas with boundaries, character models glitch out when too close to the edge (I got stuck inside another character for a minute)

Conclusion:

Well made, well-laid out, fun to play
Although the "Evil is growing stronger" message confused us.

Pros:

- Final Fantasy Victory Fanfare is always awesome. Period.

Cons:

None that I've found.

Conclusion:

This made me supremely happy to find.

Pros:

- Very well implemented.

- Doesn't conflict with any other mods, that I've used.

- Makes for a much creepier atmosphere.

- Definitely better than the original.

Cons:

- None.

Conclusion:

The SFX transferred over perfectly. I paired this with the FEAR Alma skin mod (replaces witches' appearance with hag form of Alma from FEAR) and found they mixed perfectly, and really made the witch seem something to be afraid of.

Pros:

- Works perfectly.

- Perfect resemblance of Alma from F.E.A.R.

- Terrifying to see run at you.

Cons:

- Confirmed 'invisible' glitch with No Mercy map.

Conclusion:

I really don't know what else to say; it actually makes the witch seem frightening to me (instead of before, where it more just felt like bad luck if a witch was startled) and something I want to avoid. I put it with the Weeping Witch SFX mod to increase the mood. Didn't even bother me that it won't work for the No Mercy map (although that would be really cool if a fix comes out).

Pros:

- Felt like real minecraft. With guns.

- A good length to thoroughly enjoy it, with many locations.

- The weapons looked awesome, some minecraft tools and materials were even integrated.

- The redstone looked badass. (Seriously, why doesn't redstone really look like that?)

- Kept me interested and invested the whole way through.

- The chicken made me laugh.

- The Enderdragon battle easter egg was awesome to find.

Cons:

- Weather conditions are difficult to see through.

- AI programming: if a player falls in lava, the AIs immediately jump to their death to try to 'revive' that player.

- Why write 'don't go too deep in the water' and not actually integrate something IN the water?

- The last map was scaled much more difficult than it needed to be (ie. playing through on Normal, it spawned four Tanks... All at once.)

- Ending was a letdown.

Conclusion:

Amazing mod, you really get invested playing and forget the distinction between Minecraft and L4D2. I don't want to go back to normal Minecraft!

However, the end was very anti-climatic; I felt there should have been some sort of conclusion, or boss battle as (SPOILER) 'Steve' kept appearing and staring at us with glowing eyes before disappearing again, in a F.E.A.R. sort of way - but there was never any explanation as to why or what happened to him. :/