Has/Had Promise..

Pros:
Map work above average
Pretty easy to figure out where to go
Ample supplies

Cons:
Bots start out stupid, but do ok later on.
Conclusion: Playable, enjoyable, good but not great. Not really recommended for single player.

So this is Spain.

Pros:
Excellent map work. (not crazy about the design, but then I've never been to Spain so what do I know)
I really like the day to night cycle.
Nice length of campaign (for me anyway.)
Lots of places to explore, but nothing to find. (not a big deal)
Supplies where needed.
Not a super horde fest. (which is a good thing)
Cons:
Your bots are a little stupid at the start, but get better as the game progresses. (I play single player mode.)
Spitter spray seems way too wide. There are places where I can see a lot of ground between me and the spray but I am still affected.
Conclusion:
This is a well done campaign. I commend the author/authors for their work. I recommend this campaign. The cons I listed are not a game killer, but they are enough to keep me from giving you five stars. I will gladly give you four stars for a very enjoyable campaign. Thank you.

I've played worse.

Pros: 
A nice long, long walk in the woods (personal preference)
Maps fairly well made. (There are a hell of a lot worse out there.)
Supplies and weapons above average.

Cons:
One safe room, as soon as you close the door. The next map starts, and of course you are attacked.
Zero direction. But maps are pretty linear.
Terrible bot nav. Either you don't know how or you never wanted anyone to play this campaign, single player. 
However, the bots can be pushed to pick up weapons/supplies.

Over all, I've played worse. But without improvement this one won't be played again.

Not One for the Single Player

It is plain to see that the author put a lot of work in this campaign. He is to be commended for his map work. I like long campaigns, I like DI. 
However, since I play single player. I can't give you the rating, you most likely think you deserve. To say your bots need a lot of work, truly would be an understatement.
With everything, (zombie farts) setting off hordes and hordes; tanks followed by spitters followed by chargers within a very few seconds of each other. The lack of medical 
supplies isn't really an issue, since the bots wouldn't pick them up anyway. I cannot help but feel you designed this campaign for players who use unlimited ammo.  
I still have to admire all the work you put in on this project.
Being unable to complete the campaign after five times on normal. I wouldn't recommend it for single play.

Dark Wood

Pros:
Massive Maps - personal preference
Very Well Made Maps - everybody's preference
No Lag - on my rig anyway
Lot of places to explore - main events do not just feed in infected after they are completed (leaving you time to explore.)
Long campaign - again a personal preference
Supplies - tight, but right
Finale - just right, considering I was really tired when I finally got there.

Cons:
Just my opinions - no points off.
How do I put this? Death recover places too far apart. It is a long way back to where you were when you die.
Timed event - I dislike timed events, but as I made it (after multiple deaths) I'll let that one slide.
Not enough guidance for some folks. I am not a big fan of game instructor, but after three days I had to use it to keep from hating this campaign.

Conclusion:
As I said in my comment - You are either going to love this campaign or rip it apart. It took days before I decided how much I like it.
If you can not tell that tons of work (damn good work I might add) went into this campaign. You might want to play some game beside L4D/2.
I recommend that when you play this game you take breaks when you finally get to a safe room because if you play like I do, you will truly be tired. (of course I am old, so getting tired is my thing.)

I highly commend the author(s) on a job very well done. I recommend this game.

Pros:

Well made maps

Some things to figure out

Original and a good deal like the movie (which I assume you were trying for)

Soundtrack

Cons:

Stat Scroll does not function properly - 1

Music on/Music off - shoot the disk, don't shoot the disk = Confusion - 1

*Some Nav tweaks needed: {no points off}
1-(early on one charger is so far through the elevator door, you feel like an ass if you don't go ahead and kill it)
2-(on the train Zoey walks through wall of train then runs beside the train until she gets run over)
3-(on the train Bill is halfway into the forward wall)

*Too light in the dinning room

*Grass up in air on the last run

*Too short (personal preference)

Conclusion:

I really like this campaign. I recommend it. It is going in my library to be played again.

It is confusing at the laser trap until you realize, that just like in the movie YOU can not save your comrades. Not to worry you get them back pretty quick.

The lighting is a little bright for my taste and the overall campaign seems too short, but I can't see how you would lengthen it without it becoming redundant.

I like that the author has been watching the boards and has helped folks that have been having problems. That shows concern and pride in their work. I like that. You are to be highly commended for your commitment to your project.

Pros:

Appears to be well thought out and a well created campaign.

Runs smooth, long campaign. (personal preference)

Places to explore.

No really bad seams or bushes in walls (little things that distract).

Supplies appropriate.

Finale expected, but well done.

Cons:

Minor nav problems and AI confusion.

Not much in the way of talk from the survivors, but that is not that big a deal.

Conclusion:

I do not think extreme gamers will consider it hard enough, but I found it enjoyable and that is why I play.

Normally, I do not like to give five stars unless it feels to me like an exceptional campaign. However, I can not find anything that I would consider  "Wrong" with this map. It is well put together (craft wise), well thought out (busy but not overwhelmed). It is going in my favorites library, so five stars it is. Thank  all of you, for your hard work on this campaign.

Damn good campaign.

I am a big fan of the previous version, but I really like the way you expanded the facility. Now it feels like a military complex. I like the increased gore and activity.

I agree with "grimlock78" about the resources, but please don't swing back to far the other way. I could not get to finale on expert with 3 bots without getting killed. (I didn't pick up the mg which I think made a difference.

I can not help but think changing the colors in the finale was a mistake.

But, it is still one of the best campaigns in my library. Damn good job!

I am giving you a 5, but I would take off a little, if I could but that would be because of my personal preferences from the other map. So five it is. Thanks again for your hard work.

Pros:

Fairly good map work

Innovative ideas and goals

Long campaign (personal preference)

Hordes enough for this average Bear

Decent finale

Cons:

Some map seams

Seems a little slow at the start.

Has gone CTD at the peak of action
(could have been my rig)

Conclusion:

I was much more impressed after completing this campaign. 

At the start if felt more like "half life" than LFD.

However, as it progressed it became very interesting.

Maybe not for the most extreme gamers, but still a damn good campaign.

Thank you.

I can't give you a 4.5 (due to star system) and I won't give you a 5, but still a high rating from me.

Pros:

Good texture work

Animation works well.

Drum.

One of the best AK's (imho)

Cons:

Not a great fan of the sound, but that is easily corrected. (personal preference, no points off.)

Conclusion:

Fixed a script for proper amount of rounds in the drum. Is now my weapon of choice.

Great work everyone.

Thanks again for your wonderful creations.

Pros:

Replaces pistols - gives endless ammo

Laser sight works

Still can carry rifle / shotgun / M-60

Interesting concept.

Cons:

Can only shoot single shot while incapped.
No points off

Can not use my favorite handgun.
No points off

Conclusion:

On those days when I don't want to play a straight through game, I'm bored and just want to kill something or a whole lot of some things this is what I use.

Grab your Mp 5 and your favorite shotgun and blow the crap out of some zombies.

I have read that military snipers can carry smgs as a back up. So why not you?

Not recommended by me for regular game play.

Pros:

Amazing Detail.

Great Texture.

Absolutely the best 45 out there.

Personal Favorite.

Cons:

No sound = No problem. 45's sound different to different people.

No script - even para-ordnace 45 does not hold 15 rds. - Hoping to change that.

Minor animation problems - Not enough to distract from the overall weapon.

Conclusion:

Great, great work - Thank you for all your hard work.

As I stated in my comment the Colt 45 is a personal favorite of mine.

MrFunreal and Crew have made my gaming experience most enjoyable with this weapon.

I gave you 5 stars, because there was no way in hell that I would give you 4 for this wonderful creation. Under the old rating system I might have taken off a little for minor animation difficulties but not now.

Please, continue to bring your wonderful creations to L4D2.

Pros:

Very good detail

Very good textures
 
Good sound
 
Animations are wonderful

Nice FPS and 3nd person view

Cons:

None that I can easily find

Conclusion:

My # 1 mag fed AK Skin.

The script addon was the finishing touch.

Thank you

Pros:

Great, Great Detail

Wonderful texture

It fits the bots

The flashlight is not in the way

The sound seems appropriate

Cons:

None that I can easily find

Conclusion:

I love realistic looking weapons (prefer WW2 or Viet Nam) but I would buy this weapon.
Great change up from the M-16.
As usual the Author(s) are to be commended. 
Great work, keep it up.

Pros:

Detail is excellent

Works well with a mod that allows Zoey to be on the l3d2 crew.

All animations work.

Great work.

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

This has been my Zoey & Rochelle since I came across this file in 12.

The only way I would change is if the author(s) made a shorts and t-shirt Zoey.

Pros:

Excellent detail and texture.

Works with all my other mods.

Very well done.

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

This is the DI/coach I knew in 64. (with the exception of being a dogface instead of a jar head)

My favorite coach skin.

Pros:

Excellent detail and texture.

Works with my other mods.

Very well done.

Cons:

None - even the rip works.

Conclusion:

In my time, the government gave me two sets of camo - Tiger Stripe and Woodland.

For I am Bill.

Pros:

It works well with my other mods.

Fixed the rip in the back.

Very well done.

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

In my time, the government gave me two sets of camo - Tiger Stripe & Woodland.

For I am Bill.

Pros:

This mod works with all my other mods.

The facial animations and first person arms seem to be right on.

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

For me this is the only (good ole boy) Ellis skin needed.

Pros:

Impressive amount of work

It works well with the rest of the team.

She holds the weapons I use correctly or better then stock.

Does not conflict with my other team mods.

Cons:

No holster  - the weapon just sticks to her hip. -1

Not Laura Croft - personal preference. no points off.

Conclusion:

I apologize for not being able to give you five stars, but 5 stars is perfection.  Under the old system I would have given you a 9.9, but the missing holster tasks me.

I can only guess at the amount of work you must have put in this project. Very well done.

I am amazed that she does not fall on her face and how does she run in those heels. ; }

Pros:

Excellent looking weapon / Project well done

Texture > wood grain and used look.

Animation > works well and much better than most.

Sound > beyond acceptable.

WW2 - Personal preference.

Cons:

Large file size - must need to be or it wouldn't be.

Magazine - could be darker, more metallic - again personal preference.

Conclusion:

With a lot of the weapons made today (in real life & fantasy) , looking like they came out of "Star Wars." It is refreshing to see some older models. On Zombie day, not everyone would be able to raid a gun store, but maybe their grandfather's closet.

This would be the crew (Authors) I would want to build me a Sturmgewehr Stg 44 

Pros:

Excellent Map Work

Everything Worked

Above Average AI Nav

Wonderful Detail

Cons:

Maybe not enough variety of weapons early on

AI did wander off a couple of times and died.

Conclusion:

I really like this campaign. It is just a go out and have yourself a great Zombie killing day. There were some places to explore. The leads worked great - (Don't ride the elevator if you need supplies) - liked that one.
I recommend this map. I'm going to try some more of this author's work. I rarely give 10s, actually never. Anything above an 8.5 is in my opinion high praise for a job well done. 

Pros:

Good Map Layout
Long Campaign - personal preference
Directional Arrows - If you look for them
Winter Atmosphere - Well done
Right Amount of Panic Events
Supplies Tight - But doable
Ladders useable for observation
Very good AI Nav

Cons:

Some map seams were rough

Weapon section  seemed limited

Details in some building seemed lacking

Conclusion:

This campaign turned out to be much more fun than I thought it would be when I started it. 
Map work was good but not great.
Not a campaign for extremist.
There was lots to explore.
The Bots worked very well. Some of the best AI nav of any of the custom maps I have.
I commend the Author(s) for this project and recommend this campaign.

Pros:

Excellent map work
Good details
Interesting events
Long maps
Supply points are tight, but doable.
Weather & Atmosphere
Tanks/Werewolf/Hound of the Baskervilles-Nice touch.

Cons:

No marsh areas on the moor (peat bogs)-No points off, just personal feeling.

Got lost in the catacombs

Conclusion:

I really like this campaign, one of my favorites. It has long maps and interesting events and details.
I highly commend the author(s) for their work on this project.
I recommend this campaign. It is one of the best that I have and look forward to playing it again, as there is still much to explore.

Pros:

-Excellent texture lay out, no seams or missing walls.

-Scenery was well done.

-Action from start to finish, but with breathing room for time to get your act back together.

-Very well thought out, bring common sense. It is complex.

Cons:

-Not enough heath after second village, had a restart due to just dying from old wounds. -2

-imoh, One direction marker is needed down in the generator room. -2

-Voice on the radio needs to be louder/clearer. -2

-It is a long map 2-3 hours, not a problem for me I am retired, others not so lucky.

Conclusion:

I did a comment after I first played this map. I did not like it. It seemed to have too many faults. After the last 4 hours and 19 minutes, 3 restarts, it is I who had the faults. The  AIs know when you have gone the wrong way, then they get stupid.

This is an excellent map for the thinker, one who can use some logic. My next line is a SPOILER> If you do not wish to know how to get the cable car to work read no farther.



Hint-when in the generator room, do not go back the way you came.