Pros:

No glitches.
Good bots.
Consistently orange.
Plenty of weapons, ammo, throwables, etc.

Cons:

Areas are too large.
Maps are too long.
Not very challenging.
Easy ending.
Nothing original.

Conclusion:

It's not a bad campaign as it is well made but there's not much here to replay since it's not much of a challenge.

The orange look gets old real quick.

If the maps were smaller and shorter it might be more fun.

Pros:

Unique.
Environments are well designed and realistic.
Paths are direct and don't even need arrows.
Perfect amount of ammo, weapons, HPs, meds, melee weapons, etc.
Perfect amount of common and special infected.
Challenging.
Just the right amount of events.
Custom car models.
Character dialogue.
5 maps that are just the right length.
No glitches or missing textures.
Scavenge ending that is tense and complex!

Cons:

Some custom models look clunky.
The building on the first map has a few too many open areas and needs some arrows.

Conclusion:

It's very original, has excellent direction, looks great and is fun and exciting to play.

One of my top 10 custom campaigns!

Pros:

Original environments and paths.
Short but not too short "shorty" campaign.
Good amount of healthpacks, meds, weapons and ammo.
Fair amount of infected and special infected.
Good amount of events.
No glitches.

Cons:

No silhouettes.
No AK47s.
No machetes, golf clubs or swords.
A few events have too many hordes, especially at the end.
Each map could be a tad bit longer. 

Conclusion:

A great shorty. It has plenty to shoot at, events up the ying-yang and looks and works great!

Nice job!

Pros:

Unique environments.
Credible designs of apartments, streets, pools and offices.
No serious glitches.
Scavenge/versus/survival modes.
Ammo, weapons, pills, melee and health packs are ll in abundant in all the right places.
Exciting.
Fun.
Clever.

Cons:

None other than the ending being a tad too easy.
Wind was removed from helipad. I liked it before.

Conclusion:

I preferred the prior with the wind push and the difficulty a tad stronger.  It's just a terrific campaign that can be played over and over.

Excellent!

Pros:

Picture perfect.
Exciting.
Sounds and music from the series.
Layout.
Events.
Challenging.
Cooperative effort.
Plenty of everything.
No glitches.
An actual ending!

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

The most perfect survival map.  Flawless.

Pros:

Gorgeous environment with realistic designs.
Elaborate paths and construct.
Detailed, colorful and filled with decor galore!
Great events with just the right amount of hordes.
Very good amount of special and common.
Great amount of ammo, weapons and melee weapons.
Great amount of kits and meds.
Great amount of throwables.
Fair amount of witches and tanks.
Few directional arrows are fine since it's very easy to navigate it through it all.
Scavenge end.
Exciting.
Challenging. 

Cons:

Bots get stuck in a few spots and don't go in cable cars.
Cable car glitch/misdirection.
End is a bit too short and easy.

Conclusion:

My vote for best campaign for 2012.
It boggles the mind that this level of detail and imagination was accomplished by a non-Valve professional.  
It's beautiful too look at, has little to no glitches, easy to navigate and is fun and exciting overall.
Brilliant stuff.

Pros:

Beautiful.
Original design.
Perfectly plotted.
Ample amount of weapons, meds, throwables and ammo.
Creative environmental disasters.
Ending is insane with all weapons, meds, throwables and melee weapons imaginable.

Cons:

One of the explosions looks odd with the helicopter being upside down when in the funnel.
Some lag in some events (single player).
The ending.  No escape sequence or anything but a white-out.

Conclusion:

Terrific single map campaign with some stunning visuals and events.  Excellent work!

Pros:

Bizarre.
Creative.
Complex.
Challenging.
Elaborate environments.
Original.
Excellent puzzles.
Ample weapons, meds and melee.
Ample infected of all kinds.

Cons:

Ricocheting grenades can be annoying.
Map 5 is too short.
Ending is easy and boring and doesn't lead to anything.

Conclusion:

Another brilliant Ethics campaign.  Filled with challenging puzzles, quirky environments and just enough of everything Left4Dead can through at you, it's a terrific campaign well worth the time and effort! 

Pros:

Creative.
Original.
Detailed.
Exciting.
Tense.
All-in-one map.
Pathing.
Plenty of survivor dialogue.
Ample amounts of everything.
Ample amounts of all infected types.

Cons:

Bots are vertically challenged.
No clear arrows at certain points.
Some areas have invisible walls.
Earthquake areas are far too shaky and take too long.
Ending is way too easy and quick.

Conclusion:

An excellent single map campaign that doesn't disappoint.  It has a few flaws but overall it proves that less is more.  Great work!

Pros:

Brilliant design.
Clever events.
Colorful environments.
Nostalgic.
Fun.
Exciting.
Challenging.  Especially the finale.
Plenty of everything everywhere.
Bots are smart.
No glitches (except on map 3).
CRASH BANDICOOT!

Cons:

Glitch on map 3.
First tent on map 2.  Player goes in and gets stuck.
Ending is easy.  After all the crazy amounts of special infected attacks the end is too simple and is anticlimactic.

Conclusion:

Terrific campaign that is so much fun and provides a great gaming experience with difficult attacks and events.  Excellent!

Pros:

Simple in terms of obstacles.
Clear paths.
No bugs or glitches.
Plenty of weapons, ammo, explosives, meds, etc.

Cons:

Boring environment.
Unimaginative. 
No events.
Short.
Easy.  There's nothing here that gives the player any challenge.
Bots are slow.

Conclusion:

There's really not much here.  It's a simple campaign that goes from A to B without any real challenge.  All three maps are of average length and the finale is way too easy and quick.  There aren't any issues with campaign in terms of bugs or glitches and the paths are clear without the need of arrows.  Unfortunately, there isn't anything here that sets it apart from other custom campaigns nor is it challenging or exciting.

Pros:

Architectural design is great.  Very creative and clean.
Paths are easy to navigate through.
No glitches.
Water effects are beautiful.
Very good amount of weapons and ammo placements.
Very good amount of healthpacks and meds.
Very good amount of incendiaries and melee weapons.
Perfect amount of hordes and specials.
Tanks and witches on all levels.

Cons:

No survivor dialogue.  Only reactionary dialogue.
No incendiaries on first map.
Bots don't follow well on first map and fall of ledge area repeatedly and die.
Ending is anticlimactic and easy.

Conclusion:

It's a great little gambit campaign with some excellent visuals and gameplay.  It's not terribly difficult or challenging but it is fun.

Pros:

Path is well plotted.
Nicely rendered.
Environments are credible in design and atmosphere.
Events.
Special and common infected are well placed and in good amounts.
Very good amount of weapons and ammo.
Very good amount of med kits and meds.
Very good amount of incendiaries and melee weapons.
Lighting.
Dialogue is funny.
Graffiti is clever.
Well optimized.

Cons:

Hordes can get out of hand on final map.
Not enough tanks.
Some areas look unoriginal and dull.  
Not enough events or traps or any variables that cause tension.
Finale is anti-climactic and way too easy.

Conclusion:

An excellent gambit campaign.  It's well made and fun to play with a lot tension in a great environment.  It's not terrible clever or original but it's a great play.  Nicely done!

Pros:

Original paths and levels.
Good amount of distance for each map.
Fair amount of hordes.
Most areas look realistic.
Clear direction.
Good amount of ammo and health packs and pills.
No glitches anywhere.

Cons:

Bland in terms of decor and environment.
No additional dialogue.
Final map is too open and easy to fight off hordes and tanks.
No M16s until the last map.  Unless I missed it.
Bots are a little slow coming to the rescue and sometimes don't move properly or follow.

Conclusion:

It's a good shorty and fun to play.  It doesn't exactly stand out but it's worth playing.

Pros:

Does exactly what it supposed to do: help kill witches.
Custom music track.
Needed weapons and incendiaries.

Cons:

Grammatical and spelling errors.
A little atmosphere would be nice.
Fire textures don't work.  Nothing shows up.

Conclusion:

A map for killing witches - pure and simple.  That is all...

Pros:

Army of Darkness castle design is very close to the film's design.
Various custom melee weapons.
Sound effects from film!
Necrinomicon portals!
Access to outside.
S-Mart!
Custom music.
Plenty of everything to grab and use!
Ashmobile for mauling down some Deadites!
Catapult.
The pit!

Cons:

Terrible poster.
Too many special infected and tanks pile on.
Outside area is bare.
Portal to jail is pointless and out of theme to Evil Dead films.

Conclusion:

One of the most unique and fun maps ever designed for the L4D series.  It's a blast!

Suggestions:  Evil Sheila; Evil Ash; Evil Little Ashes and more Deadite models aside from the two for common infected.
Maybe have the outside area have a panoramic image of the Deadite Army.
Custom skins for survivors with chainsaw hand!

Thanks so much you guys for this wonderful map!

COME GET SOME!

Pros:

Custom melee weapons!  Very cool and glitch-free!

Custom music.  Nice.  Wish there was crescendo music though.

Atmosphere.  dark, grimy, gritty and dangerous!

Custom dialogue.  Nutbags held up in shack - funny!

Level design is fluent and well paced.  Nothing is confusing or out of place.

Bots are alert and helpful.

Bonus adding that new map onto the beginning!  It's actually my favorite of the four.

Fair amount of ammo, weapons, meds, incendiaries, healthpacks and melee weapons.  

Cons:

No weapons in first map.

Not enough tier 2 weapons at times.

Horde on second map where the tank surprise is too large.  Too many too fast.

Special infected spawn too fast and one of the same after another.

No dialogue from survivors.

Conclusion:

Dark and crazy, it's a lot of fun and looks great!  Bonus for the custom melee weapons!

Pros:

Well designed.  The paths are clear for the most part and there are hardly any dead ends.

Great looking.  Very well rendered and designed areas.

Pacing is perfect for a shorty.  Each level is a fair length and doesn't get boring.

Looting.  Finding stuff in corpses is always fun.  Just wash your hands afterward.

Snipers.  It's always nice to have someone other than your fellow survivors shooting at you.  Plus - you get their weapons.

Creating mollies and refillable chainsaws.  Nice addition.

Custom music.  Nice touch.

Fair amount of hordes, specials and tanks.  Not too much - not too little.

Fair amount of health packs and meds.

Fair amount of weapons and ammo.

Fair amount of incendiaries and melee weapons.

Finale is creative and fun.  Tense too.

Cons:

In the buildings, a few directional arrows would help.  Just a few.

No warnings for snipers.  Maybe some dialogue saying "look out!" or something from the survivors to that effect.  The snipers also do too much damage to quickly.

Bots on third map are clueless.  They get stuck coming out of the sewer and don't help in finale.  They walk in circles and don't follow.

Some dialogue.  There isn't a lot of dialogue from the survivors so there are quiet spots here and there.

Conclusion:

Another great shorty, that isn't as short as other 3 map campaigns out there.

Very creative, clever and visually authentic.

Pros:

Challenging.
Some original designs.
Level design is paved well.
Good amount of health packs and meds.
Finale is wide and fun.

Cons:

Way too long.  Maps are so spread out that they get boring halfway through. 
Repetitive.  A lot of the areas look the same.
Lack of directional arrows.
No instructions displayed.
Too few weapons and ammo.
Unoriginal environments.  Almost seemed like each area looked like others from Valve and other custom maps.
Train cars looked like cardboard boxes.
Little decor.
Too many witches.  Still.
Bots are incredibly dumb.  They don't help much, they get stuck and they don't pick anything up.

Conclusion:

It's not very unique looking, dull visually, way too long and overall not much fun.

I couldn't wait for it to be over.

Pros:

Brilliant environment.  Everything looks distinct and exciting.
Best starting area ever designed.  Very original.
Level design is well configured and clear.
Original props and figures.
Original graffiti and artwork.
Decor is lush and dismal.
Fair amount of a weapons and incendiaries.
Fair amount of health packs and drugs.
Events are well though out and trigger fair amount of hordes.
Finale is a blast.

Cons:

Lack of ammo.
Bots are clueless at times.  I found them stuck in several spots and not to quick at picking up health packs and weapons.
No dialogue at all.  It would be nice to have any of the characters say something.
Too many special infected.  Three chargers spawned in a row in less than a minute.
No directional arrows.  Not incredibly confusing but it would help to have some help at times.
Too many explosive barrels at the end.
Finale is a bit easy once the tanks are killed.

Conclusion:

Quite possible one of the best campaigns I've ever seen.  Truly unique and tense.

With a few fixes this could easily be in the top ten of campaigns ever.

Pros:

Nice pacing throughout all maps.
Well designed environments.  Realistic and colorful.
Fair amount of weapons, ammo, health packs, pills/shots and incendiaries.
Train saferoom is very well rendered.
Panic events are fun and plausible.

Cons:

Finale is easy and small.  There's not much room to run around and with all the barriers it's easy to kill incoming hordes and tanks.  There's also too few special infected in that area.
Color correction on the red lanterns is needed.  It's almost neon red.

Conclusion:

Excellent contender in the contest.

It's fun, gritty, dangerous and creative.

Nicely done!

Pros:

Well paced.  The length of each map is perfect for a shorty.
Fair amount of healthpacks and pills/shots.
Nice country scenery.
Great Wall looks great.

Cons:

Map one looks very plain and unattractive.  Everything looks washed out and bereft of any decor.  Add some corpses, tents, graffiti, crates, cars, fires, signs, etc.
Map two is pretty but too open without any actual grit.  It's like a level from a Super Mario game.
Little to no indoor environments.  There's a few small booths and one or two rooms but everything else is outdoors.
Too few weapons and incendiaries.  There's maybe one spot with tier 2 weapons.  Not enough ammo piles either.
No arrows.  It's not confusing, but some areas do need direction since the first two maps are so wide.
Not enough tanks.
Finale is boring.  You run down the Great Wall killing everything in your path, one tank shows up and then you go into the helicopter.

Conclusion:

Not a very well-thought out campaign.  It's bland, dull and not much fun to play.

It is glitch free, but I did come across some invisible logs and issues with the skybox.

Pros:

Excellent level design.  It had a very authentic look and everything flowed from start to finish.
Level length.  Not too long - not too short.
Ammo / weapons / health packs - all in good supply.  Everything was placed in the perfect, logical spots.
Decor and environment was well designed and very well placed.
Events were fun and the finale is a blast.  A slippery, crazy blast.

Cons:

No dialogue after beginning.  Needs some yakkity-yak from survivors.
Not enough arrows.  Get's confusing at times.
Needs more pills/shots.
Needs more incendiaries.
Final map map needs more.  Normally, I dig these "shorties" but this was so much fun I could've gone for a longer third map.  It just seems like you run out fo the saferoom and into the finale.

Conclusion:

The best in the contest so far.  Looks great, plays great and is a ton of fun.

Glitch?  when I played this on local server it had me sliding on the ice all place.  When I played it on a dedicated server the sliding was removed.  Granted it was less frustrating, but it wasn't as challenging without the slip n' sliding.

Pros:

Excellent level design.
Original concepts and paths.
Lush and vivid.
Well paced throughout all five maps.
Clear and uncomplicated.
Well optimized.
Original music.
Original dialogue.
Original skins ESPECIALLY in the stadium!
No visible glitches anywhere.
Exciting.
Fun.

Cons:

Hordes are a bit much at times.
Bots don't always follow behind especially around corners and staircases.  They also don't pick up medkits outside of saferooms.
Special infected respawn too fast and twice in a row.
Needs more melee weapons here and there.

Conclusion:

Finally one of my favorite L4D campaigns is transferred over!

One of the best out there and well worth the hefty download!

Pros:

Original concept.
Exciting.
Intricate building system.
Bots have excellent aim and provide good support.

Cons:

Some items shouldn't take as long to create as other (IE: pill/medkit same time but one is greater than another).

Console gets cramped if more than one person is using it.

Bots get easily confused.

Bots don't pick up stronger weapons sometimes.

Map is poorly designed.  It's one floor and there isn't much to look at.

Why have the option to construct objects that don't hinder the infected like the information desk and the shelf units?

Ending is boring.  5 second clip for all that effort.  Nice moon though.

Conclusion:

It's a lot of fun for a time, then it's just a matter of "OK everyone cover me while I build the rocket!" and then it's over.

I'd suggest removing the information desk and shelf units, moving the turrets NEAR the console (maybe at the warehouse entrance?), fixing the creation times for some items, adding some extras here and there visually and sprucing up that ending so I'm not disappointed after doing all that work!

Nice work.

Pros:

Very unique.
Complex.
Visually compelling.
Clever.
Fun.
Action packed.
Great nav from the bots.
Fair amount of weapons, ammo, incendiaries, pill/shots and melee weapons.

Cons:

Could use a tad more decor.
Some maps are a tad too long.
The lasers are a tad over-the-top.
What was up with the chamber and the glowing stuff on map 4?

Conclusion:

Easily one of the most creative and original campaigns ever designed.  Along with MIC II, QE is fun with creative puzzles and challenges along with some really silly and bizarre designs.

The only true "con:" I can think of of is the replay value.  Or not...

Pros:

Original and credible level designs.  Very authentic  urban and city landscapes.
Well paced.
Fair amount of ammo, meds, pills and weapons.
Clever events and surprises.  No spoilers here!  Click!  ;-)
Excellent finale with a SCAVENGE ending!
Custom dialogue well acted.
Tense.
Large but not too open.  All five maps are the perfect length and it never feels boring or long.
I never once got lost.  Plenty of directional arrows and paths are so well designed you sometimes don't even need them.

Cons:

First map has nothing:  No ammo, weapons, med packs (aside from start) or pills along the way.  But it's not too bad since there are only a few special infected and events.

The cars are too shiny.

Needs more optimizing in some places.

There are no bars on the safe room doors.

Glitch on map 4.  The first long vent path has a ladder going up at the end.  If you look up half the images turn gray and your stuck for a few minutes.

There's no number of how many cans go in the cop car so you don't know how many to get.

Club scenario has too many tanks and witch.  If you don't use a propane tank to destroy the wooden planks you have to melee it for a long time.

The gas tanks aren't always easy to pick up.  It's a handicap when you have unending hordes beating the crap out of you.

Too many tanks at the finale.

Conclusion:

Quite possibly one of the best L4D1 campaigns ever designed.

Aside from some glitches it's tense, fun, original and exciting to play.

Well worth the wait!

Pros:

HUGE environments.
Well plotted courses.
Fair amount of hordes.
Great amount of special infected.
Unique atmosphere.
Good amount of meds, incendiaries and weapons.
Clear and simple events.
Luved the mountain slide and mountain climb on the final map.  Although that fake ladder of the cliff got me killed.  D'oh!
Fun finale.

Cons:

Some maps are WAY too long - in particular, Map2.  Should be half the length.
Not enough directional arrows.  I got lost on every map.
The environments are too wide.  Too many little places with nothing in them.
Voice over is terrible.  It's like an Iranian doing an English accent while drowning in a tub.  The volume is too low and can't be heard over the characters talking.  Move that dialogue to another time during the radio calls so the calls can be heard.
The rooms and streets need more decor.  The rooms are mostly bare and need some furniture, paintings, corpses, etc. and the streets need more debris and bodies.  The factories need more crates, barrels, equipment, etc.

Glitch: On map 2 there is  a jack-knifed truck in a tunnel right after the witch and the door with the pointless horizontal bars on it.  If you climb up to the left you can fall behind the truck and get stuck with no way out.

Conclusion:

It's a very good campaign, especially for a beginner.  It has a lot of potential but still needs improvements.

Nice work!

PS:  Shouldn't the title be:  Head FOR The Hills?

Pros:

Bizarre and original events.
Unique level designs.
Random explosions.
"Jockey-in-a-Box".
Turrets.
Elevator scenario.
Midnight Riders' music.
Railway run.
Scavenge ending.
Sufficient ammo, weapons, kits, meds, incendiaries, etc...

Cons:

Too many hordes at times.
Framerate issues in railway run and finale.
Fog is too high from ground and water levels.
Turrets aren't very accurate and more turrets are needed in finale for unending hordes.
Scavenge cans are too far from chopper in finale.
Bots are sometimes clumsy and unhelpful.
Map 4 is too long.
Steel doors take way too long to open at the end of the railway run scenario.

Conclusion:

A HUGE improvement from the pain-in-the-ass MIC from L4D1.  It's more fun, tense and much more destructive than its predecessor.

There are some problems with it, but over all it's a lot of fun.

Pros:

Excellent level design.  On par with Valve designs.
Exciting and slick.  The momentum is swift and direct.
Decor and direction.  Very few places where you don't know where to go.
Great hordes and specials.
Ample amounts of ammo and weapons.
No glitches anywhere.

Cons:

Map 2's trainyard has WAY too many infected.  It gets ridiculous at some point.

Finale.  Not clear where to go or what you're supposed to do.
3 generators to lift the one container?   I think one on the ground floor would've been fine and made more sense.  That way you can race to the roof level with several tanks and hordes attacking.

Needs more dialogue / instructions, especially in the finale.

Conclusion:

More good than bad here.  It's an excellent campaign that although it's only 3 maps, it plays like a full campaign.  

One of my favorite custom campaigns.

PS:  Gas Fever with no SCAVENGE map?!  Whaaaaat?!  :^O

Pros:

Well paced.
Fair amount of hordes.
Plenty of special infected.
Nicely rendered.
Maps improve (3 and 4) from boring 1st two.
Fair amount of ammo and weapons.

Cons:

Bland.
No directional arrows.
Bad bot nav.
Not enough pills.
No dialogue.
Too many red herring areas (open spaces that go nowhere).
Last map is too short.
Finale is too  easy.

Conclusion:

A good campaign that suffers from lack of originality and decor.  It's not very exciting or scary.  Most of the maps remind me too much of Valve maps.  It seems like just "run n gun" till the end.

CC:  Add more authentic decor like graffiti, automobiles with different characteristics, more corpses, dialogue, etc.  There's only one puzzle element (tractor) and these maps could use more.  Definitely needs arrows - gets confusing sometimes) and the open spaces don't help either.

Pros:

Clever concept.
Map designs have well configured paths.
Custom sounds, monologue and music.
Sufficient horde spawn and triggered spawn.
Good use of special infected.
Colorful, funny and decorative rooms, walls and stores.
The 1,000,000th customer set-up is original and fun.
Exciting and swift.

Cons:

Needs a few more directional arrows at times.
The security guard's voice and bad voice-acting.

Conclusion:

Almost flawless.  Definitely one of the best custom campaigns for L4D.

Pros:

Original design.

Lots of atmosphere.

Well placed ammo, weapons, health and incendiaries.

Fair amounts of hordes both tripped and regular.

Great balance of specials and tanks:  Not too many and 
placed a good time apart from one another.

3 maps at healthy lengths.

Great finale.

Fixed all the shiny spots and color washed spots!

Cons:

Sometimes there a few quiet spots with no enemies.

A few more tier 2 weapons would be nice.

Generator on map 2 is weird.  Why must you tap the highlighted corpse to start a generator 100 yards away?  Also, why do they want to shut off an alarm that has NO shut off switch?

Needs more directional arrows and on-screen directions.

Ellis keeps repeating the same line in the garage scenario on Map 2.

Glitches left:  Map 2:  Outside the mall there is a pile of infected corpses that are elevating off the ground a foot up.  It's right before the entrance in a fenced-in corner.

The finale:  The truck that creates the hole in the fence suddenly pops up without any sound effects or motion.  The sailboat is kind of dull escape and getting from the mall to it isn't at all difficult.  Needs more hordes and specials.

Conclusion:

One of the funnest custom campaigns out there.  Very creative and exciting!

Pros:

Very atmospheric from start to finish.

Great hordes at realistic times.  Not too many not too few.

Specials are clever and quick.

Weapons / ammo and health is all at key spots.

Well designed level paths.  Everything looks like an actual escape route constructed.

Nice work on the graffiti and math on the walls.

Exciting and well-paced on all 4 maps.

Nice 2001 reference.

Cons:

Aside from the ending, which is anti-climactic, everything is great!

Conclusion:

One of, if not the best, L4D campaigns.  Very creative and fun!

Pros:

Excellent use of hordes.  A lot but situated effectively.
Great amount of special infected and where they attack.
Well paced.
Nicely rendered and designed levels.
Exciting.
Nice amount of drugs and health packs on all maps.
Desolate and creepy.
Believable environments.
Normal = perfect level of difficulty throughout all maps.
Weapon acquirement grows as the game progresses.
Fair amount of ammo and weapons spread out through all maps.
Nice amount of drugs and health packs.
Excellent ending.  Very original and challenging.

Cons:

Needs more melee weapons throughout, especially before the gauntlet.
A few more tier 2 weapons would be nice on the last map.
The roof escape could be a little more expanded to go all around the roof to the end or make the chopper come a little later.  

Conclusion:

Clearly one of the most creative and imaginative campaigns designed.  The finale alone is the most fun you'll have on L4D2.  Brilliant!

Pros:

Map 1:  Nice and dark.  Realistically dark.
Tunnel scenarios are claustrophobic and tight.
No ammo piles are better in this map.  It adds to the tension.

Map 2:  Train cars were fun.  Nice place to fight from.
The warehouse is well conceived.  The trigger hordes and surprise hordes are well timed.
Path to safe room is narrow and precarious.

Map 3:  The bar is the best design of all.  The roof is wide and tactically sound.  The infected climb all over you on the roof.  The pool room and lounge area is wide and well designed.  Nice amount of incendiaries and drugs.  Ammo and weapons is more than enough.  The deck is my favorite part.  Wide and dangerous.  The escape is simple and sufficient. 

All three maps have a smart amount of special infected.

Cons:

Only three maps is OK but they aren't long enough.  It's a good fight but the towards the end the escape can feel a bit anticlimactic.

Bots can be a little clueless when you're being attacked.  They also luv to pick on the witch.

The warehouse scene needs more gas cans and or chemical canisters.  It's short and also not very challenging.

Needs a few more tanks in maps 1 and 2.  1 a piece is fine if the maps were longer.

Bar needs a turret on the roof.

Conclusion:

It's a very well designed campaign with some dark atmosphere and the tunnels are great.  The latter 2 maps aren't as challenging and the end needs to be stretched out a bit.

Nice work overall!

Pros:

Best bots I've ever played with.
Excellent level designs.  Everything looks practical and symmetrical.
Ammo, incendiaries and weapons are in logical and fair places.
Fair amount of hordes and specials.
Well paced levels.  All directions are clear and simple.
Excellent end.

Cons:

Not enough tier 2 weapons.
Hordes are sometimes "eternal" and can get out-of-hand.
Ending is a bit brief and not very challenging.

Conclusion:

A great campaign overall.  No real issues here and there doesn't need to be fixed aside from the bug on map 2.  There is point where you have to turn off the alarm in the labyrinth.  If you don't turn it off and try climbing over the car you die automatically.  That seems dumb.  Maybe place a gate there instead of a car?  Also, the exiting in the hotel in map 3 there is  a descending brick staircase:  the infected squat down on the stairs and stay there.

In the cafeteria:  was it intentional to have 4 boomers in a row?  Is that your jab at obese kids in US schools?  :D

Also:  the title.  "Dead High School" is not just an awful sounding title but the high school is only 1/5 of the campaign.  How about "School's Out Forever" (as in the exit is the school itself)?  If this takes place in "N' O'leans" (the apartment houses look like those there) then maybe call it "The Big Uneasy"?  If not, then how about "Urban Chaos"?

Last suggestion:  In the high school: can you put varsity jackets and short sleeved shirt with pocket protectors on the students?  Make the students real geeky!

Great job!

Pros:

Faithful recreation of Disneyland ride.
Great voice and sound effects.
Weapons and ammo are aplenty.
Good amount of hordes and specials.
Nice level designs.
Great finale concept.

Cons:

Maps are too short.
Ride is too long and there are no infected attacks.
Finale is too short.

Conclusion:

Loads of fun with Indy inspired art and music.

Pros:

Bizarre and beautiful.
Excellent level designs.
Funny.
Cola challenges are great.
Finale is hard but challenging.

Cons:

No voices (who is "she" and why don't we hear her?).
Too many hordes.
Not enough weapons and ammo at times.

Conclusion:

A truly unique and visually inventive campaign.  It's got a lot of great challenges and looks like no other campaign.

Pros:

Very similar to the film set.
Vast and well designed.
Many places to hold up.
3 floors and a large back area.
Ornate and distracting.

Cons:

Not enough ammo piles.
Too few mollies/PBs.
Needs more weapons and in more places.

Conclusion:

A great survival map that only lacks in the weapons department.

Pros:

Excellent level design - very spacious and sensible.

Little extras everywhere that make searching fun.  No spoilers!

Nice use of infected in well hidden areas as well as the hordes.

Very unique looking maps.  I especially liked the silo catwalks.

The readings through are well written and articulate.  Great concepts and ideas about the virus.

Cons:

Sometime it's easy to get lost since there aren't many arrows or obvious direction.

Needs more hordes for such long paths in maps.

Some glitches on chalkboards and safe room door on map 4 end (wouldn't close).

Can get a bit boring with long path runs.

Ending is too easy (on normal).

Conclusion:

One of the best gamer made with a few cons to slow it down.

Highly recommended!

Pros:

A 3D interpretation of a classic 1D game that incorporates the design from Super Mario Brothers flawlessly.

Tons of fun with the enemies from SMB.

Well designed levels and environments.

Colorful and wonderfully 8bit.

Nice panic events and well positioned infected.

Hordes come from everywhere but their entries are clear and clever.

Cons:

Too short.

Ending is odd and empty.  What's saving us?  You don't have to climb to the top to escape.  As long as all the survivors are on the bottom it ends.

Moving platforms are not clear enough.  Should be solid like the rest of the platforms.

Needs more directional arrows.

Bots are complete idiots and are not helpful.

Not enough tier 2 weapons.

No music from SMB.  (copyright issues?)

Needs more SMB enemies!

Conclusion:

It's very clever, colorful and a lot of fun.  It's a bit short and has some issues but hopefully these issues will be fixed soon.

Great job!

Pros:

Obviously, a terrific translation from one of the greatest games ever producer (HL2).

Well thought out events and stashes.

Tons of incendiaries.

Excellent break up of the Ravenholm scenario into 5 maps.

Fun as hell!

Cons:

Ending is a bit too easy on Normal.  Add the mounted gun spoke of and then increase the hordes and infected.

Needs more special weapons and health packs.

Conclusion:

It's up there with it's cousin campaign "City 17"!  One of the best addon campaigns ever!

I would REALLY luv to see this for L4D2!!!  PLEASE!!!

Pros:

Identical to the L4D version with a few additions.

I liked that the end platform was narrowed.  It adds tension to the area.

The shield!  I luv the shield!

Music.

Cons:

The beginning is a bit glitchy with bots getting stuck.

Is it possible to add infected combine soldiers (armored SWAT infected)?

The ending is still a bit brief and needs to be a tad more engaging when escaping.  Can you make the entrance to the train in the back instead of the front?  Running from tanks is so much fun!

Needs more tier 2 weapons.

I miss the falling ashes from the original.

How about some haz-mat infected?  Makes sense given the plethora of bile jars everywhere!

Conclusion:

See my review of the L4D version.

Great to see this campaign ported over to L4D2.

Pros:

A true representation of one the best game franchises in video game history.

Nicely mapped out and constructed.

Hidden items are fun and random.

Colorful and treacherous.

Cons:

Not finished!

Conclusion:

A fantastic idea for L4D and an excellent addition to the gamer add-ons.  I can't wait till it's finished!  Hopefully with a few more maps!

Pros:

Excellent duplication of the Evil Dead cabin.  Nice addition of environment to access roof.

Tons of zombies.

Nice spreading of weaponry, pills and accelerates.

Cons:

Too many tanks/smokers/hunters at times.

Conclusion:

One of my favorite film series reproduced to the tee with extras.  The only thing missing is the film projector in the cellar and its screen.

If you transfer this to L4D2 make sure there are plenty of chainsaws and shotguns!

Pros:

Excellent mapping.

Custom recorded audio dialogue is well done and pretty funny.

Challenging course and design.

Loaded with diverse and decorative environments.

Well placed and balanced weapons, ammo and pipebombs/malotovs through all 3 maps.

Excellent ending with a "reasonable" amount of hordes, tanks, etc.

Cons:

Needs a few more maps.  Maybe...

Conclusion:

One of the best created campaigns out there.  Aside from it being only 3 maps, it doesn't let up and is a true challenge all the way to the insane ending.