Pros:

* Selective fire for SMG and rifles.
* Added safety mode.
* Works bug-free!

Cons:

* No indicator message as to what firing mode the gun-in-hand is at the heat of an intense battle. This poses a problem for players, like me, who have disabled crosshairs or the whole HUD for realism purposes (- 0.5)
* Should be limited for fully-automatic SMG and rifles (- 0.0)
* Three-burst for fully-automatic rifles are not of the same rate as the SCAR-L: It fires two rounds in succession, but has a 0.3 second delay to fire a third bullet... but I still can stand with it. (- 0.0)

Conclusion:

Can I leave a suggestion here? You can also make an experiment by making this mod as a .SMX Sourcemod plugin (just to get rid of problems with overridden autoexec.cfg)... but I know you would not like the prospect of having a hard time making an .SMX plugin from scratch. Still, this is a great mod for players who want to control their ammunition values. Kudos to you!

PS: Waiting for indicator messages, just like what # Mentlegen is doing as of this moment :)

Pros:

* Excellent Finale mechanism.
* Start-to-finish intensity.
* Great level design.
* Dialogue usage timed for certain situations.
* Players will never know when the next great thing happens; totally random but epic horde events, aside from crescendos and gauntlets.

Cons:

* First two maps are atrocious, as # Ikl said, but not enough for me to ragequit easily. (- 0.1)
* Short... (- 0.0)
* No ammo on the finale (from safe room to the warehouse). (- 0.2)
* Three gennies on the second map + overwhelming hordes of infected + tank = worst case scenario. (- 0.5)

Conclusion:

Short or not, a great campaign overall... but with two major hitches: could use one gennie on top instead of three, and at least one ammunition pile should be placed anywhere inside the store.

Pros:

* 5 long maps for veteran Left 4 Dead 2 players.
* Location! (hehe, y'know I've ALWAYS wanted to go to the famous San Francisco's Golden Gate Bridge).
* Well-designed levels.
* Great eye for detail.
* Custom models.
* Panic events suit my gameplay on advanced difficulty.
* Golden Gate Challenge! (yes, I enjoyed the downhill part of the Golden Gate stage, before the cruise liner)
* Guaranteed replayablity!
* Finale was just right, in my opinion (with 13 gas cans and a little less zombies to take care of because of the large area in Alcatraz), even though it can be frustrating at times to go back and forth obtaining gas cans from the prison cells... but nonetheless, a great heart-pounding challenge!

Cons:

* I agree with # Fauckers; low-quality sand texture, but that doesn't ruin the mood for playing. (- 0.0)
* I do agree with everyone else saying that the finale is a bit laggy, but it's not that severe enough for me to hate it. (- 0.1)

Conclusion:

Five years of development... first release on this Site... I say it's really great! Fix a few cons in the list of reviews (especially the finale lag), and it'll be just as you, I and the rest of us have visualized! Kudos to you!

Pros:

* Great model.
* Great textures.
* Great sound.
* Includes a HUD icon, as promised.

Cons:

* # Mantuna's firing animations presents the very same problem as on # Doktor Haus' G3 sniper rifle: it's pointed downwards, and fires upwards on a ten degree angle when the player focuses on how the weapon fires. I know it's not your fault, though. (- 0.0)

Conclusion:

Easily one of the best I've tried for a long while. But I prefer to play the game with your SIG Arms SG550 sniper rifle, which is also one of the best. Sure hope I'm not hurting your feelings.

Pros:

* Great setting.
* Enjoyable gameplay.
* Guaranteed replayability.
* Everything is toned down a bit, unlike in version 3.
* New mechanics.
* New locations.
* Generally much better than it was in version 3.

Cons:

* Not much tanks; if one is encountered, it's only during the finale, and it'll be too late for him to attack me because I'm already boarding the chopper. Is it me or am I really that lucky to encounter none of those bodybuilders on [too much] steroids? (- 0.0)
* I kinda missed the Left 4 Dead 1 survivors during the train fight on chapter one... where are they? (- 0.0)

Conclusion:

This is definitely a keeper for me.... one of the best campaigns I've ever played. Tip of the hat for you!

PS: If ever you have contact with # Neojobabynou, please tell him to fix the chapter 3 crash on his Death Sentence campaign. :)

Pros:

* Great details.
* A noticeable change in the model.
* Has the feel of a bodybuilder being pumped with too much steroids.

Cons:

* None that I could think of.

Conclusion:

For a first submission, I say you're one of the best modelers. You're the new blood that comes to shock us end-users with a finely-crafted masterpiece of your own.

Kudos to your efforts.

Pros:

* Team Fortress 2 Victory theme! Good choice!

Cons:

* Unfortunately, sounds are cut a tad short... and it's quality is forced with too much amplification. (- .3)

Conclusion:

... something for Team Fortress 2 fans to enjoy! Nothing more, nothing less.

PS:
@ Ranger999: If you want, I'll send another version of your sound mod with a fix (which I made from scratch) to your e-mail address... you can say no to my offer otherwise. :)

Kudos to your efforts, nonetheless. :)

Pros:

* HD texture, normal maps and whatnot.
* New clothes.
* Has a feel of a former MMA fighter before he became that "big."

Cons:

* Color combination makes him look like a shady "Gypsy" bar owner. (- .3)
* Eyes also make him look like a shady "Gypsy" bar owner. (- .2)
* Clean. (- .3)
* Can't really make myself DL this again, because of the aforementioned cons. (no points deducted)

Conclusion:

I've used this once, but it never lasted in my addons list because he looked really clean for the Apocalypse (everyone has their own taste in their own game)... nothing personal.

Pros:

* It's Nick, only better-looking.
* Great details on his pinstripe suit.
* Hand-drawn incap panel is a wow factor.

Cons:

* None.

Conclusion:

Thanks to both you and # Eranthis for bringing the mobster out of our love-to-hate conman!

Pros:

* A SIG-550 Sniper-designated rifle.
* The best weapon model I have seen since CS: Source.
* Great animations
* Accurate model, looks much like the real weapon.

Cons:

* Scope reflections (and it's the cloudy sky)... but that's OK, I'm not that vain enough for detail. (- 0)

Conclusion:

Insta-downloaded, never regretted. Vive la Suisse (I don't know if I typed it right)!
Greetings from the Philippines.

Pros:

* Great environment.
* Has the feel of an official Left 4 Dead campaign.
* New weapons.
* Lots of surprises!
* Finale is a little bit challenging for me.
* Horde spawns during thunderstorm events on map 3.
* Fairly large chapters, but not to the point that you'll get lost somewhere down the road.
* Custom dialogue (yes!).
* Custom music.
* Industrial setting.

Cons:

* It's not really a con, but there's a cool glitch: there's no HUD for both custom weapons (find my recently-posted topic in the Safe Room section). :)

Conclusion:

Hell yea! This is now my proving ground for obtaining PENTAKILLS!

Pros:

* Great detail.
* Model accurate to the real-life SIG 550.

Cons:

* Firing sound's a little bit weaker; I understand that could be the sound of the real-life weapon when fired from a medium-sized firing range. (- 0)

Conclusion:

I downloaded the mod and fixed the script for my personal use; also I hexed it to replace the AK-47 (once again, for MY PERSONAL USE) and it worked like a charm. :)

Thanks, # Funreal!

Pros:

* Loading screen for the campaign is well-laid
* Optional lighting is a new feature.
* Final map has an armory for upgrading/reacquiring/replacing weapons.
* Mostly-dark places (especially the underground) is a fun place to fight the zombies.
* With the recent update, the turning bridge now turns around as promised!
* Even though I don't know the King of Prussia reference # haven012 mentioned, the "Prince of Russia"mall sign at the large train station is an ice-breaker for me.
* Guaranteed replay-ability.
* Has the feel of an official Left 4 Dead-ported campaign.
* Gameplay immersion is a plus.
* The "FLY ME OUT" graffiti is a good ice-breaker for me.

Cons:

* Loading poster seems to be too clean, but that's OK, other than that... (- 0)
* None encountered.

Conclusion:

This campaign doesn't just need a 10... it needs a PROMOTION for other players to try it! Definitely a keeper for me.

Thanks, # HazmatKat!

Pros:

* Great concept (objective-driven and also story-driven; it's like Call of Duty, only set in the Zombie Apocalypse).
* Great eye for detail (especially in the olympic-sized swimming pool, it reminds me of one time in Modern Warfare I)
* Secret rooms leading to other places with great perks for survival.
* It's set in Pripyat, unfortunately Chernobyl was not featured (except for a few radiation zones) but it's OK.
* Great, challenging gameplay.
* Custom soundtracks work, as promised.
* Fuses, dynamite packs, radiation zones and barrels of gas/toxic chemicals are a welcomed addition to the gameplay throughout the whole campaign.

Cons:

* Lags on many places, some of which are critical points in the campaign. (- 0.5)
* Great, challenging gameplay could turn to a TOTALLY TEDIOUS, exasperating gameplay after a few too many hordes. (- 1.0)
* Safe rooms are not that safe... SI spawns after the first ten seconds of stay in the safe room. (- 0.7)
* Pre-finale event is totally tedious. (- 0.7)
* Disappointing finish... a total lackluster; going down the whole building to meet the truck, then screen fades to black? (- 1.0)

Conclusion:

DISCLAIMER: This is not a troll review... I merely state most facts (that other users might experience or had experienced already) that are based on my gameplay, and this is how I rate mods and campaigns. If you feel that I trolled you, please double-check ALL pros and cons and my reason for rating it. You have been warned.

After the hype (well, I can't find an alternative term that will not hurt the developers much, sorry) generated from the announcement of this campaign (yes, I also waited for the campaign's release), it seems that Dneipr ALMOST lived up to it's legend... the only thing is that the rescue is a lackluster (read the "disappointing finish" segment), a total let-down, it feels like 'there should be some more, not just a fade-to-black event'. The whole "totally tedious" and "exasperating" part can be compared to SaltHell Park; but the former can be countered with fast-swinging melee weapons and throwables while the latter can be forgiving at times. The objective-driven and story-driven concept of the whole campaign is worth finishing each and every chapter... radiation zones are also a great indicator of where should you go (hey, I also liked it). Pripyat will NEVER BE Pripyat without the danger zones. Ratings received by this campaign is based on my own standards (which could be likened to a child praising strangers after being given a candy bar or something). The minus ones on the cons section are the ones I totally hate... but I can still give a leeway if there are optimizations and updates that will appear later on.

Before this will be labeled as a "troll review" or a "hate review" by either developers or other end-users, let me say one more thing: This is definitely one of the best campaigns for this first half of this year alone (at least I never downloaded the first release of this campaign which was riddled with bugs, as others say).

Pros:

* It's the Duke's General Lee!
* Comes with the Dixie Horn, as promised!
* It's HD, as # Funreal promised!

Cons:

* None, whatsoever

Conclusion:

The South will rise again with the General Lee!

Pros:

* Laser sights... with actual lasers inside!

Cons:

* None, whatsoever.

Conclusion:

One pro and no cons means an easy 10/10 for me (yes, that's how I rate mods)!

Pros:

* It's a Greyhound bus.
* More detailed than the previous mod.
* Has more gameplay immersion than the original in-game bus.

Cons:

* None, so far.

Conclusion:

Now that's what I can call a GREYHOUND Bus Liner.

Pros:

* Works as intended: changes particles in-game.
* Adds more realism.
* Boomer explosion feels more violent.
* Smoker's smoke effects changed from green to white (I'm not color-blind, white smoke has a bluish tinge when seen).

Cons:

* Conflicted with Urik's Particle support mod (file in question: 'error.pcf'), thus giving me this error:

attempting to create unknown particle system: Celestia_hair/Celestia_tail

I was forced to DL another Rochelle mod in order to accommodate to the changes (no points deducted, but still).

Conclusion:

All in all, the particle mod works as intended... one of the best in-game particle mods available for those who want a more realistic effects.

Pros:

* Darker atmosphere.
* More challenging.
* Pleasing to the eye.

Cons:

* None, whatsoever.

Conclusion:

... and # Princesa Luna has done it again! :D

Pros:

* Realistic re-texture.
* Looks better than the default in-game fire axe.
* Looks like the ones being used by firefighters.

Cons:

* None, whatsoever.

Conclusion:

# K1CHWA has done it again! Thank you!

Pros:

* Mike Tyson tattoo (never expected that one, I thought # Deathshadow was just bluffing XDD)
* Surprisingly fitting for Coach
* Fits with any Coach mod that doesn't modify the head! (only thing is I have both this mod and the New Orleans Police District Coach mod which, in real life, would be the grounds for his dismissal from the police force)

Cons:

* None.

Conclusion:

Awesome mod for the "hell of a man" that is Coach!

Pros:

* Great quality.
* It works.
* The Nepgear mod (I downloaded earlier) truly becomes alive with the voice pack.

Cons:

* Bots become dumb enough like they're waiting for commands, much worse if you're playing as Nepgear herself (note: I also have the Nepgear mod installed that time) (- .7)
* Limited number of voice files contributed to the above mentioned factor. (I know it's totally limited, no points deducted)
* Repetitive one-liners for each voicefile (no points deducted)

Conclusion:

Great mod, but I don't know what happened (followed #warriorvip123's instructions) to the bots being dumb enough. Recommended for versus and online use.

Pros:

* A better alternate for the default in-game Louis skin.
* Kinda reminded me of Burton "Gus" Guster from Psych, as he always wears formal clothing (Gus is also a pharmaceutical sales representative, much like the S-Mart Louis skin).
* Great stain details on the uniform, makes it look like he's been through it all.

Cons:

* None, whatsoever.

Conclusion:

... using this skin since the first time I downloaded it (almost two months back). Undoubtedly the greatest of the Louis skins I downloaded (IMO). :D

Pros:

* First song of the concert mod - Rock!
* Second song of the concert mod - Pop!
* Tank and Taank sound mod - a great thing to fight the tank even more!
* Compliments with the MLP posters I downloaded before!
* IT WORKS!

Cons:

* Weird pop music for the second half of the concert finale (no points deducted).
* Weird lines for Ellis and Coach (no points deducted)

Conclusion:

Hell yea! The last thing I really need is the stage mod, so that I can have many more reasons to play Dark Carnival!

PS: I am no Brony, but this mod rocks!

Pros:

* Now that's a KATANA!
* Much more detail.
* Better than the default in-game katana.
* Better than the other katana mod I had a month ago.
* It works fine.

Cons:

* None, whatsoever.

Conclusion:

Hell yea, now I feel I can f*** Shana (of Shakugan no Shana) up with this one!
For Rengacia!
*PENTAKILL!*

Pros:

* The surprise came to me when I saw the first part being dark... and hey, it works for me!
* More dark = more hiding places for my Rengar! Just kidding, More challenges!
* The dusk setting plus the fact that the place is in the eye of the storm encourages players to be MORE careful.

Cons:

* None, whatsoever.

Conclusion:

Many thanks to this, Luna! Expect more of your re-textures soon enough!

Pros:

* Great mod.
* Compliments well with the NLR Commando Bill skin.
* "Fits somehow" (even though I know it doesn't) with Princess Celestia (Rochelle)
* The violet color is a refresher every now and then.
* Great logo.

Cons:

* None whatsoever.

Conclusion:

Maybe I'm the only non-Brony here who picked this (and the aforementioned items) up just for kicks? Still, this is one of the best mods to compliment well with the aforementioned mods that I have.

Pros:

* Great reticle.
* Unorthodox reticle means that the rifles are custom-made for "civilian" use (referring it in-game).
* It works like hey, it's original.

Cons:

* None, so far.

Conclusion:

HELL YEA! PENTAKILLS!

Pros:

* Hi-definition nitrous oxide tank.
* Blue color is a refresher compared to the otherwise bland-colored oxygen tank in-game.
* Hi-definition gauge.
* IT WORKS!

Cons:

* None, whatsoever.

Conclusion:

... thanks, Funreal-sama, you're the boss!

Pros:

* John Deere.
* Looks exactly like the John Deere Chainsaw.
* Green color is a refresher every now and then.

Cons:

* None so far.

Conclusion:

... nothing REALLY runs like a Deere. It's a permanent keeper for me ^^

Pros:

* Now that's *THE* SPAS-12!
* Great textures.
* Buckshot shells on the side is a great addition!

Cons:

* None so far

Conclusion:

Now that's what you can call an AUTOSHOTTY!

Pros:

* This is the afternoon setting.
* It gives me chills while playing it.
* IT WORKS!

Cons:

* Some areas are over-contrasted (- .1)

Conclusion:

This is a great color correction mod for the Parish. I'm wondering WHEN will you upload the remaining color corrections for all campaigns. Gotta wait for that time :D

Pros:

* Darker than the not-so-dark Dark Carnival campaign... the whole campaign should be renamed "Nightmare Circus"!
* Much more challenges await you in the dark!
* Makes me wanna j*** my pants every time I startle the Witch or encounter a Tank!

Cons:

* None so far.

Conclusion:

This is by far the greatest re-texture for the Dark Carnival. Dim lights represents a sliver of hope, and the Darkness means disaster!

Pros:

* Darker than the already-dark Swamp Fever campaign.
* More challenging gameplay.
* Teamwork is REALLY needed in this re-texture.

Cons:

* None so far..?

Conclusion:

... Hell yea! More dark means more places for my Rengar to hide! Just kidding, anyways, this is great!

Pros:

* More red!
* High definition.
* IT WORKS!

Cons:

* Nothing so far.

Conclusion:

Hey, Funreal-sama, can I request for the same saferoom door with a wanted poster that has your current avatar on it? Looks way too wicked cool; BTW thanks for bringing us some Hi-def content here!

Pros:

* The Browning Auto-5 brings a different atmosphere to Left 4 Dead 2.
* Great textures and animation.
* Great sounds (used your custom soundpack).

Cons:

* None so far.

Conclusion:

One of the best autoshotty mods created for a serious L4D2 player (thing is I edited a script mod to reduce the shell capacity to believable amounts, which is five 12-gauge buckshot shells, for my personal use ^^).

Pros:

* Realistic
* Much more realistic with the US Army logo
* IT WORKS!

Cons:

* I don't have any dedicated graphics card. NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! (no deductions, it's a half-joke)
* None so far.

Conclusion:

... now I have more reasons to use the Browning, and make good-quality *PENTA KILLS!* Nah, just joking.

100% satisfactory gameplay GUARANTEED!

Pros:

* Fairly long campaign.
* Eerie atmosphere.
* New environments.

Cons:

* Gets tedious and boring after a few horde events. (- .6)
* Totally FRUSTRATING finale. (- 1)
* Lights are too effin' bright (FINALE). (- 1)
* Rushed finale escape (seriously, it's a what the f- moment for me). (- .8)

Conclusion:

This is one of the earlier custom campaigns I played three years ago, and I played it three times only. So far the only lowest-rated review on my record (MY OWN RECORD)... sorry if you somehow feel that I am biased.

Pros:

* Ahh, now I feel like PUDGE!
* Great textures.
* Default machete sounds fits well.

Cons:

* None so far

Conclusion:

... in the Zombie Apocalypse, better grab ANYTHING you can (including this cleaver).

Pros:

* It's an AKS 74U rifle, and it's a good replacement for the same ol' AKM 47 rifle.
* Better textures

Cons:

* Custom sounds TOO loud for that rifle, or I might be wrong on how the AKS 74 fires. (- .3)

Conclusion:

Sorry man, got to replace it with another custom AK 74 sound (not going to tell which one, as I can still be sued for modifying content FOR PERSONAL USE).

Pros:

* Good map detail and layout.
* Easter eggs.
* Fairly long campaign

Cons:

*  Too much lag WILL kill you... or is it me? (- 1)
* Horde-heavy campaign. (- .5)
* Two tanks on each half of the finale is a punisher. ( - .7)

Conclusion:

Sorry man, had to delete it after I failed with too many lags... and two tanks punishing each of my AI comrades in the finale became the final straw for me to totally delete it.

Pros:

* Looks more realistic.
* More wood.
* Scratches make it look more like it really IS a hunting rifle.

Cons:

* ... no cons as of far.

Conclusion:

... now this looks more like a hunting rifle!

Pros:

* Black M1911, nice!
* Custom animations.
* Custom sound fits well.

Cons:

* Both pistols use the right-hand model (no points deducted though, and I also know that the left-hand model M1911 is custom-made for the left-handed).
* Walking animation is way out of the bounds of comprehension. (- .3)

Conclusion:

Bring back the good ol' days of Left 4 Dead with the improved M1911!

Pros:

* Miku being the witch adds more danger to the gameplay.
* The custom soundtrack makes her even more dangerous.
* Double the fun when crowning Miku... HELL YEA!

Cons:

* ... doesn't replace the Bride Witch model from The Passing.

Conclusion:

... Miku? Check.
... soundtrack? Check.
... shotgun? Check.
... ammunition? Check.
... FOR RENGACIA!
*PENTA-KILL!*

Pros:

* A new look at the good ol' machete.
* Realistic.
* Scratches make it look like it was used in survival somehow.

Cons:

* Having TOO MUCH of the same thing means that it is a commercially-used product, not a Bear Grylls-exclusive survival tool (no points deducted though), but then again I might be wrong on this.

Conclusion:

Unlike the Kukri mod I downloaded earlier (which had a problem of blood not sticking on the blade), this Bear Grylls-exclusive machete is the best option I have for a machete mod. Gotta go hiking now ^^

Pros:

* Cute.
* Adorable (makes me wanna take care of her more).
* Goes along with the Nepgear voice pack mod

Cons:

* Here's a problem though: ALL FPS ARMS FOR EACH CHARACTER BELONGS TO HER (I just don't want to notice this but as a L4D player myself, it's somewhat troubling, and I don't know if it affects L4D2 characters as well)! (- 0.7)

Conclusion:

... not bad for a reskin. Only thing is that the FPS arms (for all characters) are all affected.

[edited] now I know what the problem is: You forgot to revert ALL FPS arms for (maybe) all characters when you decided to make a standalone Nepgear skin for Zoey (I'm referring to the Nepgear Party mod that spawned this skin).

Pros:

* Yes, I'm now in Japan fending from these godforsaken zombies!
* Nice atmosphere
* Temple bells (oh, you don't know how HAPPY I am tolling the bell numerous times)!
* Great background (reminds me of my home province in the Philippines)

Cons:

* There was one time in [Kyoto] that I'm being pulled by a smoker FROM THE WALLS while we're walking on the streets. Is that a part of the game? (- 0.3)
* As every serious reviewer said, being able to prepare the gas cans removes the challenge in the finale. (- 0.1)

Conclusion:

Overall, it's a great campaign. Man, I wish I was there.

Pros:

* Bill with the new uniform is bad-ass!
* His piercing stare with "Luna's personal guard eyes" makes you think twice about crossing him!

Cons:

* None so far

Conclusion:

It's a defining moment for Bill to have his NLR Commando skin. Makes you really believe that he's really a soldier for the New Lunar Republic. This skin compliments well with the "Hell's Angels Francis skin", making them look like they really have moral differences!
"ALL HAIL THE MOON PRINCESS!" - Bill, with his NLR Commando skin.

Pros:

* Scarier than the original Tank by a notch.
* Looks more powerful than the gorilla-style Tank.

Cons:

* Looks more like Renekton (from League of Legends) mutated into a gigantic mass that is the Tank... which will somehow fit in a game involving genetic mutations gone wrong. (doesn't affect the rating)

Conclusion:

It's the second tank mod I downloaded (first was the "Siam" mod), but this beast rocks!

Pros:

* Scarier than the original
* It is what the skin name is: a small lump of flesh!
* Exactly like Catking's last pro point: FUNNY AS HELL!

Cons:

* None so far.

Conclusion:

... man, that Jockey reskin is one sick s**t to add scares to the game, and I don't wanna mess with it! Thumbs up for a job well done!

Pros:

* Good texturing
* Great model
* Best sound, even better than the original pump shotgun.

Cons:

* ... uhh, none so far.

Conclusion:

One of the greatest shotgun mods I downloaded and hell, I'll never disable it! 

Pros:

* A reminiscent of the field shovel that I once used when I was playing CrossFire PH Server, and...
* Just like M3GAMAN100 says, it's good for killing MAGGOTS!

Cons:

* Why is it still using the sounds from the original frying pan? (- 0.1)

Conclusion:

... if there's a sound pack that goes well with the field shovel, it can be better.

Pros:

* It's a black XM8 (prototype, maybe).
* Better than the old-fashioned M16 that the game has.
* Just add custom sounds (mine's the XM8 sound from GRAW that's also here) and voila!

Cons:

* ... none so far.

Conclusion:

... one of my favorite guns, aside from the Kalashnikova (AK), heck, I preferred it over the AKS (redwood mod that I downloaded from this site also) when it comes to accuracy.