Good map

Pros: Nice color scheme
Unique custom elements
Events and such
Interesting layout

Cons: A bit dull
Small bug
2nd to last chapter was too short

I like the color scheme - very outrun. We had an issue in last chapter safe room where the map didn't transition until we teleported out and back in again (sourcemod commands). Other than that - decent map, rather easy but that's not a bad thing

bad

you need to realize the difference between "difficult" and "really stupid". this map is about undoable. the "traps" come with no warning most of the time. too many instant kills, no heights where the survivors hang, they just fall (and die). disappearing weapons isn't "hard" either- it's borderline unplayable

invisible walls

either get rid of them or put fences or something so we know where to go. get rid of teh walls before another review

shit

Cons: 

* Endless hordes

* Hordes for no reason

* Hordes in closed spaces that bile is useless in

* Witches/tanks during hordes

* Witches/tanks during unending hordes

* Endless hordes

Pros: 

None

Problems

I'm not giving this map 1 star, because it had a lot of custom content that was quite elaborate and well done. 

As it is, this map was unpleasant and sometimes unplayable. The spawning - both common and special infected - was pretty rough. I'm not sure if you had some increased spawn timer for god knows why, or if the map was just bugging out, but we had special spawns quite frequently and the same with the hordes, which made it fairly rough. 

We had to noclip out of the first area, since the door would not open, not by bashing, not by any of the buttons around there, anything. The event in the first chapter featured a never ending horde, and with the extremely small area it was impossible to outrun (if that's what we were supposed to do), so we noclipped again. Frequent hordes, tons of specials, we made it to the third chapter and had to noclip again when the train wouldn't go all the way down the tunnel to the safe room. After maybe 3 hours we gave up on the 4th chapter on the puzzle in the clock tower with the music, since it was pretty difficult to run back and forth to figure it out while having to deal with only a few seconds between spawns. 

I see that you've listed the common infected's ability to open doors as a feature and not a bug, but it caused a lot of problems, with common infected getting stuck/unshovable by the doors, blocking areas, etc. 

Not a fun map. Won't be recommending this one.

Burning Night

Nice map, I enjoyed it. 

It may be a tad light; we beat it with only 1 restart in 2 player expert realism. The difficulty level was perfect for that mode though, as the plentiful spawns made everything doable. 

No events were overly difficult or impossible, which is rare among maps, and all were easy to figure out what to do. The overall layout and design was clear and simple, so navigation was intuitive. There weren't many glitches and the scenery was nice. 

Good map.

2032

Pros:

Dynamic item spawning - unusual but pretty awesome

Custom common direction

Linear map design without being boring

Well-done back story


Cons: 

Short map

Sections apart from finale are too easy

Campaign only, no realism (no deduction from score, just wishing)

Overall: 

GREAT map for training independence on higher difficulties! This map is completely doable for the beginning 2 player team or a nice introduction for a beginning solo player, even if it's only in campaign, expert campaign with 1 player is easily ("easily") completed without too much worry. That being said, although the finale is a great area to test your masochism in, the rest of the map is entirely too simple in terms of difficulty, there's a definite lack of special spawns prior to that, although this could be a good thing. 

The story is quite excellent, there's a lot of small details in the map that contribute to the overall atmosphere. I liked being able to hide from the common infected while they ran past, the custom infected patterns, sounds, and others lent to a more engrossing environment, and the final moments of the map were comprehensive endings that provided just enough material for closure without becoming too boring.

In conclusion, this is a awesome map, it will set the world on fieri

Nowhere Is Safe

Pros:

Map is linear and isn't terribly difficult to navigate 

Complete map with a working finale

Shows good promise

Some nice small unique areas like security cameras

Cons: 

No melee weapons

Stretched textures on many areas, bad reflections, low res cars

Optimization issues - finale ping spike of 150 extra ms, small ping spikes throughout campaign and frequent small fps drops

Grammar and spelling has serious issues

Map decisions that make no sense (spawns, hordes, etc)

Overall: There's little to play in this map. It is linear and non-confusing which can be great and is definitely an excellent change from many convoluted maps with no direction, but the poor quality of scenery kind of ruins it; many indoor areas feature stretched textures, reflections are broken in many areas, and the vast majority of cars in the tunnels are extremely low resolution.

I did like the outdoor forest part, one of the few forests I've not hated, but it was rather short and, like most of the map, suffered before and after with some of the weird spawns in the map; limitless pipe bombs, guns of very specific type (lots of t1s and M16s/AKs and pistols) with no melee and only one magnum spawn iirc, etc. The endless hordes were a tad tiring, but wouldn't have been so much a problem if there had been melee spawns around, likely.

This map shows a lot of promise and with some care it could turn great. One of the most easily apparent problems is the grammar and spelling throughout the map, and if that's fixed the map would look a lot better.

Pros:

funny at least

Cons:

Contains malicious scripting that erase ALL your key bindings, so don't install!

Conclusion:

Best map ever

Pros:

Incredible atmosphere
Neat custom textures and models
Challenging gameplay
Puzzles
Extremely long

Cons:

Spawning is terrible- all spawning in plain sight
No L4D2 weapons like magnums and melee make realism near impossible
Very scarce ammo piles 

Conclusion:

As a map, this campaign measures up to the rest of Leafo's excellent maps with great attention to detail and careful fidelity to its theme. The creepy atmosphere combined with the difficulty level make this a truly miserable experience (in a good way). 

As a port, this campaign needs some serious attention and TLC. While dual pistols only is quite appropriate and expected in L4D1 versions, the changed game mechanics of L4D2 require some better weapons; the extremely rare ammo piles combined with the lack of melee and magnums made realism an awful and unpleasant experience. Opening up this map also revealed issues with the port; some zombie spawns were scripted as CI spawns.

The issues with the port made this an abysmal journey. CI spawns on top of players with no warning resulted in damage/incaps/death almost instantly on expert, and the lack of melee and magnums made it impossible to defend from these surprise hordes. No ammo meant that we relied on the dual pistols for headshots, which was pretty damn hard with their poor aim. 

As a whole, this port is definitely not worth playing. It might be doable on regular campaign mode in normal or something, but not appropriate for higher difficulty games.  

Pros:

Scenery was excellent, especially the part with the sunset 
Nice water reflections
Indoor areas (tunnels) were very well done
Outdoor areas were beautiful
Lots of custom models
Optimized well
Layout was easy to defend from; open enough areas to pick off zombies from afar, but enough walls to back up against
Not many bugs
Bot nav was great
Lots of supplies to compensate for length

Cons:

Excessively long
Textures were sometimes repetitive 
Areas started to look all the same after the 4th or 5th chapter
Easy
Couldn't do speed runs because of water
Got lost in a few areas
Not enough health packs in finale
Finale was a bit tricky to get out of 

Conclusion:

This map is ridiculously long at 9 chapters, but is easy enough in gameplay to enjoy it until the end; it's balanced well, and is quite enjoyable as an end result. It's a very finished and thought out map, with few bugs, great layout, and lots of gorgeous scenery to keep attention. 

Great map, if you can sit through it to the end. 

Pros:

Works as intended

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Great mod, enables private games when wanted. A lot easier than going offline to play. 

Pros:

Survivor voice cues were well done
Outdoor areas looked lovely 
Easy enough to find the way around
Looping map layout was a neat idea, and nicely executed 
Survivor zombies, cop zombies, and CEDA employees were used well
Bot nav was good
Supplies are better
SI spawning is better
No bugged areas for CI spotted

Cons:

Map layout overall was mediocre 
Minor FPS drops and ping spikes throughout all chapters, especially during events
No ammo in 2nd/3rd safe room
1st chapter forest layout wasn't very good- sloping forest areas with little visibility meant it was hard to defend from
First gauntlet was a bit early, considering it was near the start of the map; it also ended in a bottleneck space which was tricky
1st chapter had a boss infected near the beginning and 2 events total- probably too much
2nd chapter event had horde + 2 tanks with little maneuvering room
3rd chapter had a few areas of massive CI spawning very close (behind a nearby closed door or corner, etc)
3rd chapter event had no camping spots + horde + tank
Finale had no camping spots, we had to use a glitched out spot (on top of army tank near helipad)

Conclusion:

Updated review for 10/05 version

 Pretty decent map. The atmosphere was very well done and the scenery looked excellent. There were some nice details included like voice cues and survivor zombies, and it looked like a lot of the bugs from the previous version were fixed. 

There were some lag problems here and there - event ping spikes seen across 3 different servers, 2 official and 1 local- but these weren't too bad, and overall there weren't too many glitches. The worst part were the layout of the events, which were pretty unimpressive and were entirely based on luck due to the lack of camping spots, room to navigate, etc. 

It's a nice theme, and very well done. The dam looks awful pretty and is cool to play around. Good map

Pros:

Scenery was amazing
Mountains gave the appearance of an endless map
The fields were unique and beautiful
Beach area was nice, especially with the sand appearance
Indoors areas were detailed 
TV show was a cool touch
Flowers!
Rain was great
Custom melee weapons
Custom tank skin
Layout in general was good
Adequate supplies for most of map
Bot nav appeared to be functional

Cons:

Finale was a bit tricky with the tank spawn- we bypassed it by having one person fetch the items and not go any further until everyone else was at the rescue point
Minor FPS drop in finale with lots of zombies
4th chapter was a nightmare, frequent and endless hordes with little supplies or direction

Conclusion:

Dear god, this map was gorgeous. Excellent work, really. 

Pros:

Nice layout
Good scenery
Bots are great
Supplies are placed well
No bugs/glitches found

Cons:

Tough to find a camping spot for finale

Conclusion:

Nice map

Pros:

Excellent scenery, love the tunnels and winter areas especially
Creative and well-done finale
Open layout
Few bugs
Custom melee weapons

Cons:

Events a bit difficult 
Needs instruction- easy to get lost
Supply distribution weird- lots of throwables in first chapter, also no magnums

Conclusion:

Nice map

Pros:

Scenery was beautiful
Layout was pretty good, was generally clear on where to go 
Lots of unique gameplay elements- event with gas cans in the middle of the map, trains at the end
Amazing level of difficulty, very challenging but still quite playable
Chapters are decently balanced
Events are difficult, but enough bile to make them easily passable
Supply distribution was generally nice and appropriate for the level of difficulty- enough defibs, thank you

Cons:

Large amounts of events and hordes is kind of excessive, especially for unexperienced players
Bot nav could be better- they got stuck in a couple places, didn't always pick up supplies
Beginning is a bit difficult- event right at the start with poor weapons is a little much, and there are a ton of hordes before you even start that event
There's an area with an event right after a gun store-type place, and there's an unbreakable door right before leaving the room to start the event- good to get tanks stuck on
Trains caught a lot of people unawares
There's one chapter with a bridge run to the saferoom- here CI spawn inside this saferoom, which make it near instant death the majority of the time, pretty frustrating to survive the whole chapter only to die right outside the SR
Scavenge event was a little hard 

Conclusion:

I personally enjoyed the challenge of this map, but it's probably inaccessible for some people. Great map though, with few cons.  

Pros:

Good, clear layout
Working rides and other animations
Looks great 
Excellent optimization- didn't notice any lag, even with all the outdoors areas
Supply distribution was decent
Custom music
Fun map
Survivor voices

Cons:

Infected spawning was bugged out. A few chapters had no SI spawn for most of the chapter, and sometimes the CI spawning wasn't working either. 
Map was way too easy, might have been the infected spawning though
Ride is bugged out- kept falling through it 

Conclusion:

It's pretty immature to give yourself high ratings, but this is still a nice map. Not sure why the infected spawning wasn't working, but once that and the various bugs are addressed, it will be a great map 

Pros:

Incredibly beautiful map
Diverse areas 
Open world feel
High levels of detail
Custom graffiti 
Custom models
Bridge theme was very nicely done
Beach house was amazing
Detail in the distance gave this map a very realistic feel
Gorgeous water areas
Mustangs throughout the map
Nice paintings
San Francisco theme was said to be fairly faithful
Layout was great- easy to find way, but still lots of areas to explore
Adequate amount of direction
Excellent bot nav
Finale was pretty good

Cons:

Supply distribution is poor- sometimes there are too much and sometimes too little. Lots of weapons (ok), very few defibs (not ok), magnum/melee was scarce (not ok), big events didn't have too much health items, lots of throwables in first 2 chapters but too little in 3-5, etc
Map's chapters are quite unbalanced- first 2 chapters were incredibly easy, others were very difficult. Skipped the third chapter.
Very long chapters
Bridge parts were drawn out, tedious and excessively difficult 
Lag in spots- first horde event had bad FPS drop and ping spikes; second horde event had moderate FPS drop and ping spikes; several areas of FPS lag in the finale
Bridge areas were bad- lots of cars made it very hard to defend from CI effectively, and had several spots where the zombies would get stuck and non-shovable
Event in bridge part was unnecessary and had no camping spots

Conclusion:

This map is visually amazing; it takes some little done themes and makes good use of them. With the huge amount opf custom areas and tiny things like paintings, plants, and clouds, the detail in this campaign was astounding; I especially loved the beach house, which included a full kitchen. The layout is excellent, and the bot nav was well done. 

Unfortunately, the gameplay is subpar. The bridge areas were very difficult and tedious, and the supply distribution meant an abundance in the first two chapters but left us lacking in the other 3. 

Still, this is a nice map. It's not impossibly hard to complete, and the open areas were fun to explore. If some of the gameplay issues were addressed, this would definitely be a 10/10 map.

Beautiful. Keep up the good work!

Pros:

Top notch level design and layout
Scenery was lovely
Few bugs noticed
Unique chapter themes
CI/SI spawning was excellent
Incredible amount of small details - tank behind cage, witch placement shop areas in the mall, tank tunnel in finale, etc
Very huge, very open map, but still not easy to get lost and confused in
Author receptive to comments

Cons:

Supply distribution was in general not very good. The starting weapons were godo weapons, there were very few magnums, and the huge amount of health kits made the 3rd chapter (mall) much too easy in comparison to other levels

Conclusion:

Excellent map, the scenery detail is astounding. Be sure to check out all the mall area, it's probably the best done shopping center in all the L4D2 maps.

Pros:

Optimized well
Wasn't difficult
Working teleports were pretty neat

Cons:

Visually repetitive and boring
Incredibly unclear layout
Bugged safe rooms
Never found finale
Large amount of glitches- many, many floating items
Some weird textures 
Bot nav wasn't too good- they died in the water a lot
Supply distribution was poor 

Conclusion:

The map is listed as having 4 chapters... we went through at least 10 safe rooms. Sometimes the safe room we spawned in would be a safe room for the next chapter, and all we had to do was open and close the door, but sometimes the game would go straight from one safe room to another. Sometimes we would lose all our weapons, health items, and throwables to the next chapter; sometimes we'd switch characters. I'm not sure what happened with the safe rooms, but it was pretty annoying. 

Never did find the finale. The various levels were repetitive and boring, and the layout was confusing enough to make it impossible to figure out where to go. We never did reach the finale, although it displayed us being on it several different times. 

Pros:

Very, very nice layout
Excellent bot nav
Absolutely lovely scenery
Open feel, good amount of areas to explore
No direction but none needed

Cons:

Way too easy- too many supplies, too few hordes, too few events
A whole lot of invisible walls
FPS lag in 1st and 2nd chapters- seems like specific locations
1st chapter game froze 

Conclusion:

Bugs need to be fixed and finale setup needs to be addressed. Nice map overall 7/10

Pros:

Map layout was pretty good
Excellent graphical work
Theme was well-done and map kept faithful to it
Various extra mechanics worked
Very few bugs 
Not easy to get lost
Interesting, compelling scenery 
Custom graffiti was very well-done, some of the best I've seen next to One 4 Nine and Warcelona 

Cons:

Supply distribution was very poor for the gauntlet theme
Far too many witches- made realism a pain, probably would be bad on normal mode too
No defibs until late (not sure if respawn closets were present)

Conclusion:

This is a really great looking (and functioning) map- this sort of theme is way underdone, but looks excellent here, and the different elements like the moving floor or room with the rods worked fine- but unfortunately the gameplay is abysmal. A map that is 1 long gauntlet is fine, but the supplies weren't right. We found 1 melee weapon in the first map- a frying pan, as luck would have it- and after that nothing until the end of the 4th chapter. Fighting gauntlets without melee (and magnums since it was realism) was incredibly annoying and frustrating, and the lack of other things for gauntlets like throwables, shots/pills and ammo piles made it pretty irritating as well. The third chapter was a nightmare- we simply didn't have the right supplies to make it through the maze and then that little horde in the room before the first stairwell, and that was if we got lucky and didn't have a witch in our path so we couldn't avoid her (how can we kill an unavoidable witch in realism when there's an endless horde and nowhere to run?)- unfortunate-timed SI in the maze were killer too, although that was partly our fault. 

Gauntlet-themed maps aren't bad by necessity, and this map was indeed perfectly laid out for a good gauntlet run, just that the supplies and spawning made it terrible.
 
Played this map for 3 hours with 39 tries. Started on expert and had to finish on easy- even then we kept dying. I don't know if the map maker hasn't played this map very much in L4D2 or what, because this map was ridiculously difficult to finish, and not in a good way. 

Looks good, plays annoying. It might be ok if you find a better melee in an early chapter and then never die, but otherwise, no. 

Pros:

Interesting level design
Nice layout
No witnessed bugs
Pretty easy- lots of supplies, easy events, etc

Cons:

No direction
No defibs
No melee beyond level 1

Conclusion:

Yep, it's orange

Pros:

Creative, unique map
Nice layout- pretty open but wasn't too easy to get lost in
Security cameras that would start hordes
Great creepy atmosphere
Very well-done interior areas, outside was very pretty
Rooms were nice

Cons:

REALLY REALLY needs some direction
Bot nav on ladders- they fall down and die frequently
Needs more magnums throughout map- just first one in beginning
Unbalanced- chap 1 was very hard to navigate, chap 4 near end was unduly difficult

Conclusion:

Never played Metal Gear Solid so I can't comment from that respect, but only from the map by itself.

This really is a great looking map, and has a lot of creative elements in it, but it really needs some direction. All chapters in general were pretty irritating to try and navigate around, and chapter 4 was worse- running around trying to find an exit while being chased by 2 tanks and a horde isn't too fun, also kind of impossible on expert. It doesn't have to be game instructor parts or voice overs or anything, just a few arrows here and there would have been nice. 

Pretty nice map overall. 

Pros:

Awesome
Extremely detailed- just an ungodly amount
Dark, gritty graphics added to the atmosphere
Custom everything
Special infected skins are epic
Custom survivor skins
Very difficult; great team challenge
Very long; took us over 3 hours
The supply distribution overall was quite impressive, it was cleverly and skillfully done 
Incredible artistic work, beautiful in its own way
Excellent layout- extremely extensive, but still doable and able to be figured out
Magnums, yay! 
Breakable boxes, sometimes with items inside them
Various rooms 
Extremely varied chapters, each with wholly unique elements 
Queen model, alien egg models
Cave theme is quite underdone, but quite well done here
Exploding barrels yeahhh
Switches are easy to identify 
CI and SI spawning are excellent 

Cons:

First and second levels NEED direction; we only got through it because at least one teammate was dead and spectating
Safe rooms bugged- players who didn't survive would spawn outside of them
Finale was glitched out- stand in front of the door 
Difficulty might be too much for some 
Dark atmosphere might be too much for some 
Length might be too much for some- 6 very long maps
Safe rooms contain no items- not an issue personally

Conclusion:

Wow!! Phenomenal map!! Simply amazing, I'm telling everyone about this one. 

Expert recommendation is spot-on; the supply of defibs was clearly intended for those playing in expert realism, and thank you for all those (we needed them). The amount of magnums, too, really made this approachable.

The staggering amount of custom elements in this map really set it apart and make it visually impressive, but the clever layout and gameplay design seal this map as a truly great map. You're an excellent map maker, keep up the good work. 

Pros:

Great layout
Clear level design
Lovely scenery
Generally doable level
Few bugs/glitches 

Cons:

Finale is a bit difficult

Conclusion:

Nice map

Pros:

Very nice looking map, excellent scenery
Superb layout and general design
Forested area is lovely, very well-done
Urban part is nice
Graphical detail is great

Cons:

Bots are truly terrible. Tried the first chapter with bots- they wouldn't pick up weapons or health kits, and wouldn't revive each other. 
First chapter- too soon for an event (even an easy one), definitely too soon for two events
First chapter- graphical glitch in the building when standing on top the mattress
Third chapter- water area looks a bit strange 

Conclusion:

Looks like a lovely map with a lot of potential, just needs a bit more finish. 

Pros:

Beach, neighborhood, space areas all nice and well-done
Supply distribution good 
Chapters and areas are pretty balanced 
Lovely scenery
Events good
Doable in higher difficulties without being too easy 

Cons:

Finale a bit difficult/confusing

Conclusion:

Nice campaign

Pros:

None found

Cons:

Unable to launch- crashes host's game to desktop

Conclusion:

Won't run in single-player or multiplayer, crashes L4D2.

Unplayable. 

Pros:

Great layout
Nice environment
Generally detailed and finished 
Easy without being too boring
Big map
Good finale
Functional bots
Nice supply distribution

Cons:

Bad lag problems in 4th chapter event- host's ping went up to 150 at worst, a little lag on the finale too

Conclusion:

Lag needs to be worked on a bit, but this is generally a nice map

Pros:

Pretty decent layout
Ship looked nice
Scenery was ok
Bots were ok
Map functional

Cons:

Unbreakable door by radio meant tanks and zombies couldn't enter
Generally unimpressive
Finale uninspired
Finale too difficult for how easy the rest of the map was- unbalanced

Conclusion:

Ok map

Pros:

Nice layout
Functioning bots
Good amount of spawn closets
Appropriate supply distribution
Scenery was lovely 
Good finale

Cons:

Some invisible walls

Conclusion:

Well-made map

Pros:

Phenomenal custom artistic work, grafitti, posters, everything
Looks great
Amazing graphical elements, scenery was outstanding
Decent layout
Working bots
Excellent direction, really quite a relief in add-on maps
Ch 3 Nice radiation effect, very clever and well-done

Cons:

Too many hordes
Too little supplies, esp. ammo
Too easy
Serious lag problems; very frequent FPS drops, plus ping spikes for other players
Ch 1 alarms in like every shop? Really?
Ch 2 items floating in SR
Ch 2 too many locked doors
Ch 2 dropped 45 FPS down at one point
Ch 3 teammate spawned outside SR
Ch 3 water reflection in pool outside SR messed up
Ch 4 spawning really messed up. First attempt 2 players spawned outside saferoom and one incapped instantly, second time around a player spawned dead
Finale execution terrible
Finale SI spawn terrible
Weird finale
Crash to desktop

Conclusion:

The lag was absolutely unacceptable, the safe room bugs were terrible, but glitches are understandable; what didn't make any sense was the execution of this map. Why were there so many hordes? Why were there so few supplies? Why wasn't there a tank until the 3rd chapter, and then why were there 2 so close together? What's with the massive amounts of special infected in the finale? 

It's clear that there was a lot of work on this map, and the art direction is really quite outstanding and shows the amount of effort put into this; but this isn't just something to look it, this is a video game and needs to be playable. The scenery and graphics can't overcome the poor implementation of infected and supplies, and that's not to mention the bugs. 

Didn't finish this one, the negative points of the campaign were kind of overwhelming, didn't feel like having to start the finale over and over again after the bad spawning messed up the game. 

Worst FPS drop was down to 15 from usual 60. The only time I EVER lag like that in L4D2 is hosting super hordes, any other mode on any other map on any other server will put me down to 55 at the worst. Just terrible. 

Pros:

Amazing graphics
Phenomenal scenery
Awesome music and sound effects

Cons:

No direction makes this map impossible. Couldn't finish any of the chapters
Finale puzzles are unduly hard
Very confusing layout
Couldn't reduce music volume
No supplies anywhere but right outside safe rooms

Conclusion:

This map looks amazing but is unplayable. 

Pros:

Excellent graphical detail
Amazing scenery
Great layout
Train ride was well-done
Nice attention to little details, like the choppable fruit, custom doors, etc 
Bot nav was well-done
Few glitches/bugs

Cons:

Few places zombies got stuck in and couldn't be shoved
Too nice of a map to be this short
Finale was quite easy

Conclusion:

Great map! Very well-done, I'll have to play more of your maps in the future. 

Pros:

Well done open-map layout, was spacious without being too easy to get lost in
Lovely graphics
The waterfront areas looked good
I liked the mountainous part
Nice concepts, nice execution
Pretty easy without being boring

Cons:

Saferooms are BUGGED. Teleporting to wrong safe rooms, objects floating around
Had a few bad zombie spawns (in sight)
Bots USELESS. Wouldn't pick up weapons or health packs for quite a bit of the campaign.

Conclusion:

The map overall was a whole lot of fun, my only complaints are glitches. The safe room bug was annoying when my teammates were at the start of a chapter and I was at the end, and the poorly done bots are quite frustrating.

Pros:

Large map, with lots to explore
Easy- few events, just mostly hordes
Urban environment is nicely done
Lots of fun to play

Cons:

Could use more hordes in general to make up for the lack of events and tanks
A few bugs- esp some supplies are glitched
Lack of direction
Supplies are very low
Lack of respawn closets
Some shipping crates are weird colors- VERY bright/bold colors

Conclusion:

I'm giving this map a higher rating than I should because I found it a lot of fun to play. Local server started messing up so we were unable to finish it, but I'll try it again today. 

Even though this map is easy, the lack of supplies can be frustrating. While chapters 1 and 2 were fun to explore and very easy, we died multiple times on chapter 3 and actually had to scale it back to normal- there were plentiful health supplies, ammo, weapons, etc in chapters 1-2 but chapter 3 had barely any, which made it rather difficult. The lack of sidearms from the beginning forth was frustrating if you died and started again at the next chapter. I want to play this on super hordes, but dying and then not being able to find a melee weapon would be pretty miserable.

Also, it was tough dying and not finding defibs or respawn closets. 

The absence of instruction and open layout can be confusing. This is not necessarily a bad thing- I enjoyed being able to wander around, and the low difficulty would be fine by me in realism, but others might hate it. 

There definitely need to be more zombies in this map.

Please keep working on this map, it looks amazing! Added this to my watchlist. 

Pros:

Creepy atmosphere
Puzzles are tough but still pretty doable
Actually a good amount of supplies 
Custom weapons, shotgun sounds, and SI skins
Map layout is a maze but not an impossible one 
Challenging 

Cons:

Pretty dark
Kind of heavy on the over-saturation 

Conclusion:

Haven't finished this one yet but it is amazing so far. Be sure to play this one in realism. 

 

Pros:

Unique level format 
Interesting events 
Space ships

Cons:

One single extremely long chapter
Is probably inaccessible to inexperienced players
Bots are completely useless 
Several areas where zombies get stuck and can't be shoved
No direction whatsoever 

Conclusion:

This map isn't like any other you've played, but that might be a good thing. Bots can't contribute and die off very fast, zombies get stuck in areas you can't push them off, there's one chapter, and there's no direction- one of those campaigns which is fun at first and then gets frustrating, especially if you don't know the map or are not playing with a human team. 

Pros:

Great use of the voice clips
Lovely scenery
Hidden surprises
Unique areas and events

Cons:

My little pony?...
Poor map layout
Unbalanced; map is generally quite easy, but the finale and I believe the 2nd gauntlet is very difficult
Many locations with unshovable zombies

Conclusion:

Clearly a great deal of thought and effort went into this elaborate map, but it's rather unfinished and the map layout is poor. A map with less detail and better layout would be preferred, as this map is nice to look at but frustrating to play.

Pros:

Looks cool

Cons:

Animation has never worked for me
Funky sound

Conclusion:

Ok mod. Used it a few times and then disabled it, the sound was annoying and the animation didnt' work anyways.

Pros:

Interesting and unique, to say the least
Good for fans of puzzles

Cons:

Lack of weapons
Overly difficult to figure out for the first time
Fog might be a bit much

Conclusion:

I played this for the first time in expert realism, which was pretty miserable; we wandered all over the map with nothing but one pistol as defense for maybe 90 minutes, restarting several times, before giving up. Next few times I played on easier difficulties with people who knew where they were going, but that couldn't make up for that terrible first impression. Was there something terribly obvious we were missing that made it so difficult to figure out where to go? Probably, but still.

 

Pros:

Genuinely creepy
Unique set 
Lots of hordes
Great design

Cons:

Might be a little inaccessible for those who play on lower difficulties

Conclusion:

Nice map. Played it for the first time with the Super Hordes mod, which ended up being one of those fun disasters; fortunately there's some good camping spots in the map, which could compensate for horde intensity, mods or no mods.

(Played L4D2 port from l4d2maps.us)

Pros:

I liked the intro 
Witch room was cool 
Nice graphics and layout
Original

Cons:

Could use some more weapons

Conclusion:

I'll be watching this one for updates, it looks promising.

Pros:

Great map layout
Unique features
Lovely graphics
Well-finished, few bugs

Cons:

Map chapters were a bit long

Conclusion:

What a fantastic map!

Pros:

Funny
Creepy
Detailed and unique
Interesting horde events

Cons:

So campy

Conclusion:

Very nice. Not to my liking, but it's a finished and well-designed map.

Pros:

Well-finished map
Varied chapters 
Interesting and unique events
Finale was different
Good balance of challenging and fun

Cons:

Maze-like layout in parts could be confusing to some

Conclusion:

I especially liked the indoors parts. Infected City is a good map- not outstanding, but still well-made and nicely playable. Good job.

Pros:

Well-made map
Impressive easter egg
Custom tanks
Varied and interesting chapters and layouts

Cons:

none

Conclusion:

Nice map

Pros:

Space jockeys
Fun
Original and unique map

Cons:

1 chapter makes this map hard, but not fun hard, just irritating hard

Conclusion:

Weird ass map but I love it

Pros:

Absolutely fantastic scenery, especially the indoors parts

Cons:

many of the events are difficult to figure out and get past
There are occasional bugs

Conclusion:

It's gorgeous enough to overlook any problems

Pros:

Hilarious
Easy and fun
The ride was great, worked pretty well

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

I've never been on the ride but it was funny

Pros:

Looks great
Well-done

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

After I first downloaded this mod, I forgot about it; when a smoker dropped down from somewhere right in front of me it scared the shit out of me

Pros:

I love the opening scene
Super open map design
Nice scenery

Cons:

Finale is overly difficult

Conclusion:

One of the better maps

Pros:

Absolutely hilarious
Perfectly disturbing
Well done, it looks nice and finished and functions 

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

10/10 would bang

Pros:

Amazingly detailed
Doable on harder difficulties, not excessive
Gorgeous scenery, just everything
Very original
Open map design
Well-done layout

Cons:

Super long chapters can be frustrating and tedious when you die
Finale able to be bypassed by simply gathering the cans before the event is triggered
That one chapter where it's so easy to get lost

Conclusion:

My #1 favorite map, definitely the best I've played. It's clear there was a lot of time and effort put into this map, and it shows in how lovely and polished this map is.

Pros:

So gorgeous, I love the gold and jade color scheme and the designs on it

Cons:

I can't see how lovely it is after it's covered in blood :/

Conclusion:

Great mod

Pros:

Hilarious and fun map
Unique designs and challenges
Original graffiti and voice files
Very open map design

Cons:

Event with closing the doors with the score going is bugged, it's easily bypassed by standing in the back of the store directly off the doors
Finale can be difficult- bots almost always die early on, which can make it frustrating 

Conclusion:

Great map, one of my favorites. Few cons are easily overlooked.

Pros:

Nicely done
Not excessive cleavage or anything else, it's tasteful
Looks nice
Almost like the original, it's not over the top 

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

Good mod

Pros:

Hilarious ending
Absolutely gorgeous scenery- I LOVE the desert!
Great detail
Interesting
Original graffiti 

Cons:

Finale can be a little difficult sicne there's no where to camp out at 

Conclusion:

Generally polished and well-done

Pros:

Completely unique layout calls for different strategies
Puzzles 
Really graphically unintensive- my crappy laptop could handle it- despite this still good looking

Cons:

Finale can be frustrating 

Conclusion:

Great map

Pros:

Graphically simple- good for PCs that regularly have lower FPS

Cons:

No finale 
Buildings are boring 
Repetitive

Conclusion:

Looks and plays liek a low effort map.