average

Poor performances even with a GTX 1080 Ti and a strong 5GHz CPU, due to lake of optimisation and not respecting the engine limitations, especialy on the first map.

Final is impossible in exp realism with bots. After 15mn holding a spot (even using cheats to have infinite vomitjar molotovs and first aid kits) i gave up.

Overall some good ideas like the lights which can be turned on, even tho some stuff are anoyong af, like too many hordes, no time to enjoy the maps.

Bad

Felt like an uninspired, unfinished, empty project. Too flat, too empty.

Totaly uninspired campaign

Totaly uninspired campaign, 3/10. not enough details, rooms conected to room with corridors... I belive this camapaign was made to test the editor.

No botnav errors, no glitchs.

Pros:

- performances of all the maps are 10/10.
- Amasing landscape.
- Amasing level design, finaly someone talented that is able to make floors not !@#$ing flat everywhere.
- Maps are steep and so beautiful.
- Good use of magnificent 2D sprites.
- Ambiance is 10/10.
- Lighting is 11/10!
- Skybox is just purefect. I felt like playing thoose old rally games which took place in Great Britain (Mobile 1 rally championship 2000) soooo  good!
- There is way enough supplies (well balanced, still a bit too easy).

Cons:

- Add more areas to explore if it doesn't kill the performances.
- 3 first maps are way too easy.
- 2 last maps are also easy.
- Could use more tanks e.g. make a fight with 5 or more tanks at the same time would be amasing.
- Final is too short i want more fighting with the tanks.
- In the final level the 1st tank get stuck near the area where you grab the food.
- in map 4 a tank was also stuck in the small corridors.

Conclusion:

1 word : amasing.

I rate it over my favorite campaign which is Suicide Blitz 2. I give it a 10! Worth it!

(i will make screenshots of where the tanks get stuck).

Pros:

- Very fun events
- Good overall design and pathways
- final is fun (but could be a bit more difficult when climbing to the choper).
- Not too much shotguns? Good!

Cons:

- Map is not finished. Need more details, and more complex geometry in some parts of the maps.
- i want more tanks on all maps! :)

Conclusion:

Extremly good campaign! A bit too easy in exp realism but the overall design is very good, subway parts reminded me of HL1 ofc :). I hope to see a good final release with more details and gorgeous graphics. Will ofc change review if a new release is made :)

Title

A good campaign fun and satifacting.

Pros:

- some serious creativity (liked the speedrun part ala DeFraG) etc

Cons:

- buggy
- not fair in exp realism

Conclusion:

Kind of disapointed since it's too hard in exp realism and it lakes some stuff like maybe guns or supplies? Yet could'nt finish it.

Pros:

- fair try
- campaign is in final state

Cons:

- cheap lvl of details
- cheap lvl design / pathways

Conclusion:

An average campaign that i wont play again due to it's boredom.

Pros:

- couldn t find any but a fair try

Cons:

- cheap lvl design and pathway
- not challenging

Conclusion:

An average campaign.

Pros:

- creative nontheless

Cons:

- small corridors can be hard to handle and make it challenging BUT it worked the other way around in this campaing, it was way too easy

- low geometry detail
- change textures, its all the same and they are realy flat, there are noo borders on the textures which could make it more tasty etc
- super easy final
- boat not sinking §§ i am disapointed
- could have found so many ideas to make it super unic, yet i found none in your campaign :|
- lake of special decoartions/ambiance

Conclusion:

Kind of disapointed i have to say but ill wait for a new version ;)

keep it real

Pros:

- can't think of any but it,s a fair try nontheless

Cons:

- way way too easy
- super cheap design and pathways

Conclusion:

Not realy a good campaign, not challenging at all and prety boring, loads of supplies, super easy final etc :|

A very average campaign i would say.

Pros:

- Awesome aquarium lvl
- Crash area was superb
- Some original (and good) idead here and there
- Pathway was kind of cool (i would like to see some events where we would have a choice between going left or right for ex)
- Final was nicely balanced

Cons:

- Magnum = too easy in exp realism
- Some parts have cheap textures and cheap geometry
- Would be better if we were forced to kill tanks at the end of map 1 or 2 iirc before going to the safe car.

- map 1 bug,the helicopter sound is still there when you are in the building...

MAP 3 is BUGGED, even in local with a top notch computer the ping goes up to 100 !!

Conclusion:

An excellent upcoming campaign with original stuff never seen in any other campaigns, still waiting for a bit more tasty textures and geometry in some parts.

Keep it real !

Pros:

- superb and dynamic event at map 2 iirc (where you have to get parts of the computer)?
- Fun
- Original

Cons:

- a little bit cheap lvl design sometimes, ie in the tunel somewhere (map2?) the sky is just a fail in that tunnel ;)

Conclusion:

A super fun campaign and pleasant to play.

Pros:

- good difficulty balance
- BIG BIG size levels => challenging => goooood!
- superb environnement and ambiance
- some original things here and there
- level design is superb so far
- liked the city a lot

Cons:

- sometimes the witch appear at the exit of the telepheric.
- pathway feel sometimes a bit cheap ;) let us more choices of pathways.

Conclusion:

Played it today, was big in all aspects of the term ;) had so much fun, was intence !

keep it real!

Pros:

- fair try
- Nice start
- Nice fountains

Cons:

- final is not realy what people are witing of a final
- linear pathway

Conclusion:

Kind of disapointed by this campaign to be fair so far.

Pros:

- Loads of SI (f yeah!)
- Challenging in exp realism
- Good lenght (not too long/not too short either)

Cons:

- Realy cheap level of geometry/design
- Also pathway is super linear, there is no second ways etc.

Conclusion:

I play exp realism only and this campaign was a very good and an enjoyable challenge. The only real dowpart is the cheap level of geometry/design.

Not in my top 10 but an enjoyable campaign nontheless.

Pros:

- kinda cool pathway through roofs etc

Cons:

- Lighting and textures are not realy good.
- Way too easy
- Too short
- some cheap lvl design at times
- total copy of hl2 without real inspirations i'm afraid

Conclusion:

A fun campaign but could be enhanced to be better.

Pros:

- re creation of another game
- could have some funy parts

Cons:

- cheap lvl design
- prepare Dolipran for a headash

Conclusion:

Fun at start, headash 10mn after.

Pros:

- Excellent campaign

Cons:

- lvl design could be better in some rare parts
- i want more tanks ;)

Conclusion:

- In the top 10
- Since all campaigns are overrated on this website i'm gonna rate 10 all the campaigns that i think are worth the top 10.

Also props to the creator of the music used in the teaser >;)

Pros:

- Scenario is good
- lvl design is very professional, every levels are very well made and are realy beautiful.
- Secret lvl
- Overall excellent balance. Challenging final in expert realism o/

Cons:

- Lake of pipes/bb/molo at the last map maybe?
- Would be nice if at start of map 1 a magnum spawn all the time near elevator, and not randomly.

Conclusion:

This is simply the best custom campaign available for L4d2 at the moment (06-2012).

Pros:

- good overall lvl design
- I liked the 2x same infected
- Challenging

Cons:

- a few spots have poor design.

Conclusion:

In the top 10 of the best custom campaigns.

Pros:

- Nice texture (a little bit like Mirror's Edge)
- Beautiful
- Overall nice lvl design except for a wierd part where you replaced stairs near an elevator with some cheap construction.

Cons:

- Very very short
- No real final
- Not challenging unfortunatly

Conclusion:

Good campaign but i'm not gonna play it again. It lakes content.

Pros:

- Original

Cons:

- super cheap lvl design
- i don t like Lord of the Ring

Conclusion:

stoped at map of Lord of the Ring was way too cheap :l

Pros:

- Nice final

Cons:

- very cheap lvl design
- cheap gameplay
- not rly fun
- only one way to do it
- maybe map design was dine for HL2 solo (it was bad i think) but definitly not for L4D

Conclusion:

Not a top campaign for me.

Pros:

- Fun !
- Original
- Nice final

Cons:

- Boat map has some clipping errors
- some part of the levels have too cheap design, not enough decoration
- Too easy in Expert Realism mode

Conclusion:

Very nice campaign, but a bit too easy and levels need more decorations.

Pros:

- extreme fun
- realy unic gameplay
- unic special abitlities
- very good performances on all maps

Cons:

- only one thing : MORE CURVES LESS ANGES regarding level design :)
- Like Leggs said : Cutscenes might leave an incap'd teammate to die. It s an anoying bug :l

Conclusion:

A must, super super fun but i remove 5 points for lvl design and the lack of curve :)

Pros:

- some good idead of lvl design in some rare places

Cons:

- very cheap lvl design
- we don t feel like being traveling through a forest which is realy disapointing
- cheap lvl gameplay
- Not rly fun and absolutly not scary

Conclusion:

Avewrage campaign.

Pros:

- good lvl design
- original

Cons:

- Cheap sand texture
- Could have added sand storm and stuff like this
- Final is kinda meh.

Conclusion:

Descent campaign but map 4 had too much boomer bile and map 5 final have a bad balance.

Pros:

- I realy liked the 2x hunter or 2x same CI at times in the subway part
- Ending was OK

Cons:

- Texture ambiance is cheap in many places
- Cheapy lvl design :l need more detail, fill in the places =)
- Map with elevator is graphicaly bugged, comfirmed with team mates, there is some graphical glitchs. 
- Also if someone fall from highway he can t come back because elevator will not work a second time.

Conclusion:

Mitiged conclusion, some part are good but overal feel cheap because of textures and lack of details.

Pros:

- Good lvl design
- original progression / scenario
- very good and original ending
- Not too easy
- Custom speachs about Canada :D !

Cons:

- very short once you know how to play it :)

Conclusion:

In my top 3 of the best campaigns.

Pros:

- Excellent lvl design
- Original environnements
- some funy and original moments
- Very good end

Cons:

- a bit too easy on expert realism except final which is ok regardiing balance =)

Conclusion:

Excellent campaign, a must. TOP 3.