Pros:

+ Phenomenal display. 
+ Difficult.
+ Limited supplies.
+ Prop placement. 
+ Extensive in length.
+ Skybox fits the environment. 

Cons:

- Hunting Rifle location glitchy.
- Light placement. 

Conclusion:

The area around the Hunting Rifle is critically flawed, the zombies just fall down below the surface of where we are and don't really attempt in chasing us when staying where the pipebomb and molotovs are. The light in the Hunting Rifle area, you could get stuck behind it. I'd recommend pulling it out a bit further to avoid that. Overall it's an enjoyable survival map with great looking graphics throughout the map. Pretty open, not such a tight map. Your choice of props were understandable, didn't have any unnecessary props or placements.

Pros:

+ Limited weaponry and supplies.
+ Extremely difficult to fend for yourself and defend a certain spot.
+ Turret became handy at times.
+ Dark tunnels. 

Cons:

- Unusually dry.
- Random props.
- Acceptably small.
- Lack of props.

Conclusion:

Red lights give sort of a panic effect which makes it far more of an adrenaline rush once you get attacked at an awkward moment. Some of the props were unnecessary to have in this environment, there are other props however that'd be more suitable for an underground environment. When I think of underground, I vision water.. Whether it's a puddle of water, a leak or flooded water I still would assume there'd be some sort of moisture in here besides blood.(;

Pros:

+ Lots of detail.
+ Snowfall.
+ Firework effects.
+ Clever way to start the event.
+ Trees are nicely designed, as well as the insides of the buildings.
+ Mystery Gifts scattered throughout the map.
+ Limit of supplies & Location of weapons and ammo.
+ AI Nav isn't bad.
+ Challenging.

Cons:

- Could use more decorations for plain buildings.

Conclusion:

Recommend you download it ASAP. It's pretty fun, has glorious lighting with decorations and great textures. The Mystery Gifts aren't always the same thing, they're randomized which was pretty creative. 

Pros:

+ Difficult.
+ Interesting theme.
+ Like an old mini game.
+ Different threats.
+ Unexpected custom models.
+ Finale.
+ Weaponry is always with you.
+ Medkit drops. 
+ Sky box is fine.
+ No lag.
+ Respawn.

Cons:

- AI Support.
- UFO has a little too much HP.
- Evasive maneuvers were complicated. 

Conclusion:

To be  honest I was looking at the screenshots of this map before downloading and I thought it would be terrible. Turns out that I had quite a lot of fun playing it, it's very difficult even on Normal. The bosses and other threats had a reasonable amount of HP, I personally think that the UFO in the finale had a bit too much HP. It felt like I was shooting at the critical spot and not doing the right technique to defeat it. The flashing notifications that you were doing damage was helpful though. I would highly recommend not playing with AIs but only with friends or online. The AIs will just stand there and heal you at the worst moments. I nearly raged due to their idiotic "help." Doing this on your own is definitely a challenge to be tested, recommend it completely. 

Pros:

+ Challenging.

Cons:

- Sloppy layout.
- Terrible placement of weapons.
- Building with the safe room door is unaccessible.
- Very cramped.
- Starting the event.
- Lighting was a tad off.
- Broken turret disrupts FOV. 
- Too many turrets.

Conclusion:

By sloppy layout I'm referring to the control room, I know it's a zombie apocalypse but come on..you're overdoing it in that one position. The map was basically overflowing with turrets, literally scattered through the map. Lighting was kind of off, walls seemed to flash black at some times, near the turret on the far left side of the control room. Starting up the event was an awkward way to enable, coming in contact with the light some how, would start the event. Lack of space was critical, especially with the tanks and amount of zombies sprawling in. Still a beta map, I'll remake a review once the map is complete. Adding it to my watchlist so I don't forget. All in all, it's not the worst map on this site, but it's most certainly not in the high ranks either. 

Pros:

+ Church Guy.
+ Ammo stash in a reasonable spot.
+ Amount of zombies.
+ Sewer tunnels. 

Cons:

- Simple Design.
- Name doesn't fit the campaign setting or description. 
- Found no way to get outside.
- Low selection of weapons. 
- No tanks.
- Lots of empty space.
- FPS drops frequently throughout the map.
- Very small map.
- Way easy [Played on expert] 
- After completing the level, 'takes you to No Mercy campaign.

Conclusion:

I really found no way to get out into the parking lot and enter the store, thus the MalMart is only a background and really has no interaction with the map. There tends to be a FPS drop throughout the map, on and off. The setting kind of doesn't make much sense, why is there a guard building in the underground tunnels of a sewer? If it isn't a guard building why would it have a siren..especially underground. The Church Guy was amusing though and put a smile on my face. The thing that got me really with this map was that there was really no challenge at all, other than lag. I played this on Expert and still there was no trouble with surviving, even sought for a challenge and replayed the map. Once you complete the map and close the safe room ending doors, it relocates you to No Mercy. Which by obvious facts, isn't part of this map.

Pros:

+ Jail setting
+ Length
+ Decent amount of zombies
+ Tank somewhere in there
+ Models.

Cons:

- Lots of empty space
- Unbelievable amount of weapons
- Lots of ammo
- Kinda boring
- Simple, even on expert.

Conclusion:

I wouldn't want to play this map with bots, or by myself. Was a good first time map, not very complete in game play but claimed to be complete. Lots of empty space, way to much infantry and the models don't really fit with the map. Would be nice if you had more security in there other than the dead security corpse near the end of the level in the tower.

Pros:

+ Nice Designed House.
+ Includes Many Weapons.
+ Enough Zombies.
+ AI Support.
+ AI Nav.
+ Great FOV.
+ Enough Supplies.
+ Gnome.
+ Lighting.

Cons:

- Zombies Can Get Stuck A Bit.
- Mass Gnome Spawning, Caused A Bit Of Lag.
- Invisible Tank..? 

Conclusion:

Had a pretty fun time while playing this, the gnome lag did get to me a bit. The invisible tank could be personal so I didn't really drop the score because of that. The lag and the zombies were my main problem. The zombies could tend to get slowed down and or completely frozen in a spot if you go in the blue room, near the rescue button. The map isn't bad, it's got a nice design and a challenge to go along with it. I definitely recommend. :-D

Pros:

+ Looks Like Death Toll, Dark Carnival, Blood Harvest &' Alien Swarm.
+ Awesome Feeling.
+ Tons Of Zombies.
+ Huge Chapters. 
+ Ammo Usage.
+ Scavenger Hunt Like. | Explained In Conclusion.
+ Lighting.
+ AI Support.
+ AI Nav.
+ FOV.
+ Multiple Tanks.
+ Pretty Straight Forward.
+ Challenging.
+ Decent Intro.
+ Sick Finale.

Cons:

- Lacks Direction A Bit.

Conclusion:

Ohh.. My.. GOD.!! That's all I can say when I finally beat this campaign. Definitely a recommended map, and a personal favorite. I personally think that this campaign should be added as on of Vavle's main list of campaigns because this is just amazing! As I said in the Pros, "Scavenger Hunt Like." I meant, you really need to search for your supplies because it isn't all in one spot all the time, there isn't always going to be a pile of guns, this campaign shows that you can't have everything. You need to work to get your equipment here, and if you don't take the time to look for your stuff or supplies, you will most likely die. The beginning was pretty cool — scratch that. THE WHOLE CAMPAIGN WAS COOL! :-D. What really got me was the scavenger hunt. I agree with AdamsKurzt on his observation that the campaign does have parts where it looks like other campaigns, I saw in the finale; the part where you are about to go down in that square thing. That is something in the game Alien Swarm. Thought that the finale was really cool too, you had to fight for your supplies. (; Great Campaign, Romka &; AGRESSOR

Pros:

+ Great For Halloween.
+ Decent Weapon Rate.
+ Creepy Moon.
+ AI Support. 
+ AI Nav.
+ FOV.
+ Lighting.
+ Decent Sized, For Each Map.
+ Haunted House.
+ Funny Conversations.

Cons:

- Not Really Scary.
- Typo For Finale - Read Conclusion.
- Not Enough Zombies In Finale.
- To Many Ammo Stacks. 

Conclusion:

It's a pretty fun map, it's even funner on Halloween IMO. But it's not really scary, even on Halloween; First of all the only thing that made me jump in this campaign, was when I ran in a room and the tank was standing right in it. None of the models or ghosts made me freak. They were actually pretty funny, especially the holographic faces that would appear in random doorways. xD - the finale's typo was once I hit the button for rescue it said; "Get to the helicopter on the other side." Not in those exact words I'm sure. But the helicopter was definitely in the text. As for the amount of zombies in the finale, I really ran into maybe 5 - 10? `Could be a director glitch, or due to me running in front of everyone. In conclusion, a pretty fun campaign. Happy Halloween Everybody.! 

Pros:

+ Big Map.
+ Challenging.
+ Lighting.
+ Weapon Placement &' Ammunition Placement.
+ Laz0rz!!! O:
+ Includes Every Weapon.
+ Many Places To Defend From.
+ Sniper Tower.
+ AI Nav.
+ AI Support.
+ Lighting.
+ Slow-Mo! 

Cons:

- Ladder In Garage. *Read Conclusion*

Conclusion:

This is a amazingly fun map, you and your friends are very good with mapping. I definitely think you should make more survival maps, possibly a campaign. The only think I found wrong with this map was the ladder in the garage. It was a bit jumpy, but still accessible. I'm looking forward to seeing more maps and possibly a few campaigns from you. (; Great survival map, BranZyme, Hugo, ThaiGrocer &' Nullvector.

Pros:

+ AI Nav.
+ AI Support.
+ Weapon Placement.
+ Ammunition Placement.
+ Supplies Placement.
+ Great Textures.
+ Campaign Layout.
+ Difficult.
+ Enough Zombies.
+ Awesome Layout | Finale.
+ Ship , Effects.
+ No Glitches.!
+ Size Of Campaign.

Cons:

- None Really.

Conclusion:

Decent sized campaign, with great effects &' custom models &&' music. Very fun and exiting. I really do recommend this campaign. (;

Pros:

+ Replica Of The Original.
+ Weapon Placement.
+ Ammunition Placement.
+ Supplies Placement.
+ Great Defense Spots.
+ AI Support.
+ Textures.
+ Lighting.

Cons:

- Some Places You Couldn't Get To.

Conclusion:

Amazingly fun survival map, it's just like the original map in CoD. I recommend playing this survival map. Great job, Alex 'Livewire' Williams. 

Pros:

+ Beautiful View.
+ Nice Layout.
+ Weapon Placement.
+ Ammo Placement.
+ Supplies Placement 
+ AI Support.
+ Lighting.
+ Disadvantage To Every Spot To Defend From.
+ Challenging.
+ Well Made &' Graphics.

Cons:

- No Hunting Rifle Found.

Conclusion:

A great survival maps, you have your advantages in a lot of spots, but a lot of those spots have disadvantages. (; 
I recommend, it's very fun, challenging, and beautiful. Great job, xXDoomsayerXx.

Pros:

+ Loads Of Zombies.
+ Great Layout.
+ Long &' Fun.
+ Weapon &' Ammo Placement.
+ Textures, Lighting, Setting.

Cons:

- Rescue Call Glitch. -Minor-

Conclusion:

This campaign was insanely fun and exiting, even with bots. There are tons of zombies to kill, and quite a bit of tanks too,
which makes it really challenging on modes higher then Normal -With Bots.- The weapon placement was placed just right to the point of where it isn't to easy, nor to hard, as well as the ammo. There is a minor glitch, the rescue caller, you can run in it .. o_O That's the only thing I found wrong with this campaign. 5✩.

Pros:

+ Fun and Challenging .
+ Places To Defend From Aren't Terrible .
+ Nice Placement Of Weapons/Ammo .
+ Nice Layout .
+ Lighting .

Cons:

- No Magnum .
- To Many Gas Cans / Propane Tanks .
- Doesn't Include Many Weapons .
- Pretty Small Survival Map.

Conclusion:

This survival map isn't the greatest, nor the worst. It could use quite a bit more work, it would be great if you reduced the amount of propane tanks and gas cans, and replace them with more weapons. 

Pros:

+ Nice layout.
+ Lots of zombies.
+ Weapon placement.

Cons:

- None really

Conclusion:

It's an alright map, it's not impossible to survive.

Pros:

+ Great HD map.
+ Weapon placement.
+ Auto start.
+ Lots of places to defend from.
+ AI support

Cons:

- None 

Conclusion:

This is a great map, nothing is wrong with it really. It's really fun, and challenging. It's not like other survival maps where you have all the weapons in a stack for you, the scavenger line was pretty funny. The think I like about the weapon placement is that it isn't all in one spot, you have to roam the map to find the weapons, and there is no roaming, getting your weapons, then starting the timer. You have to work to find your weapons and to survive, I love the idea.
The props for the map are in HD, very nice design and texture usage. Great AI support, the lighting is perfect, and give me a nice winter-like feeling. 100/100. Well done :D

Pros:

+ Very fun and just like the original.
+ Ways to survive expert are still there.
+ Great weapon placement.
+ Zombie neon colored clothes.
+ Awesome scavenge finale.
+ Finale looked real nice.
+ Bot nav.

Cons:

- Zombies glitched. - Read conclusion. 
- Really dark

Conclusion:

The zombies glitched one time in "Garage Coop" after you destroyed the barricade. The zombies had a weird clothing difference. I liked it, brought some color in that map. The tank glitched in the finale,  stuck behind a fence. Great replica of the original campaign, "Dead Air." 

Pros:

+ Difficult
+ Great layout.
+ Many weapons and supplies.
+ Simple
+ Lighting

Cons:

- None

Conclusion:

This is a very fun survival map with a lot of places to defend in. Great usage of supplies, but it is still very challenging.

Pros:

+ Nice textures and lighting. 
+ Great supplies placement.
+ Lots of places to defend from.
+ Very difficult to defend :D
+ Awesome idea.

Cons:

Nothing really.

Conclusion:

Got 21:29:27 :)

Pros:

+ Awesome Idea.
+ Looks just like City 17.
+ Weapons and supplies placement was perfect.
+ Dead Combine Soldier in finale. :P
+ Challenging finale.
+ Custom Music :D.

Cons:

- None.

Conclusion:

This is a very great and fun map, I don't recommend playing with bots, because they screw you up when it comes to getting on the train. It is a very easy map if you've played the original map on HλLF-LIFE Episode 1. And to the others that have purple and black sky, you have to install "Left 4 Dead 2 Add-on Support"

Pros:

+ Nice design. 
+ Nice weapon & ammo placement. 
+ Rain setting is relaxing.
+ Lighting.
+ Beautiful moon.
+ Lightning effect is just so awesome.
+ "No Mercy (+)" sign ftw.
+ Fun to defend, pretty challenging. 

Cons:

- We are very limited to where we can go. 
- Slide is glitchy.

Conclusion:

When I said we are limited to where we can go I meant by; tents and upstairs, etc. You have all your supplies right there in the main room, many places to defend from.  

Pros:

+ Nice weapon & ammo placement. 
+ The "Eat" had a nice design. 
+ Kinda; challenging. 
+ Kind of a run and gun survival map.
+ Lighting is nice.

Cons:

- Map is pretty empty.
- Rooms just have stuff thrown on the floor.
- Not really suspenseful.
- Random elevator that we can't even use.
- The diner isn't even a diner, it's a storage room with a table.

Conclusion:

It's alright, I honestly think it needs more time into it but, the map design it'self is nice. The buildings inside layout isn't so nice. It's just the same thing in every building, trash on the floor, the outside is pretty empty. 

Pros:

+ Searching for supplies. [Look in conclusion]
+ Nice textures & custom models.
+ The tomb was awesome, had a nice design to it.
+ This was a nice long campaign, it was a bit challenging.
+ Made me think, "Where the f*** do I go now?"

Cons:

- No supplies in finale.
- Finale could cause headaches. :/

Conclusion:

This was a mad fun campaign, the whole campaign was, but the finale; not so much. The finale had no supplies in it, could really give you a headache. 

Pros:

+ Great spots to run and gun.
+ Good spots to defend from. 
+ Plenty of ammo / supplies.
+ Nice idea on the helipad.
+ Extremely hard, and fun.
+ The lighting was perfect.
+ The design was awesome and the textures were nice.

Cons:

- Some doors only zombies and special infected can break.

Conclusion:

There were supplies in other rooms, but the staircase door to them could only be broken by zombies and special infected. 

Pros:

+ Fun and challenging.
+ Dark and scary.
+ Great advantage of weapon, ammo, and medkits.
+ Great places to defend from.
+ Flickering lights make it suspenseful.

Cons:

- Bots wont go to the top of the tower, only to the second floor.

Conclusion:

This survival map is extremely fun and so epic that it crashed my l4d. LOL

Pros:

+ Nice start story.
+ The setting is awesome.
+ Ammo and weapon usage is alright.
+ Long campaign.
+ Saferoom level 5 has a nice design.
+ Finale setup was well made.

Cons:

- Smoker can still smoke you in level 3 saferoom.- More in Conclusion.
- To much supplies; moltovs, pipebombs, pain pills.
- Gets boring when you overuse the woods.
- Finale was original. 

Conclusion:

All in all it's not the best map, nor the worst map I've played. The finale was an original, a plain old airplane escape. The woods are a bit overused, and get boring.

Pros:

+ Decent ammo & weapon usage. 
+ Nice setting.
+ The lighting was perfect.
+ Decent size for a three map campaign.
+ Car escape at the end of level 2 was awesome.
+ Nice textures / models.

Cons:

- Didn't find any maxed weapons on the 3rd level, only found 2 ammo caches. {Was enough}
- Finale 
- Zombie spawn points

Conclusion:

All in all, not the worst map I've played. I liked the custom models like the cars, those were pretty cool.  The setting of the finale was okay. But the finale itself was terrible. There were no moltovs or pipe bombs, no defending spots. Like two of them, and they both require sitting in a corner, not very fun. Very tight area. Tanks didn't have a chance because all of our FOVs were set to him due to the lack of space. And the boat, it's original, but it also looks like the boat did nothing while we were fighting the horde. It wasn't fueling or anything. Just sat there and when the last Tank was dead, it moved up as yard or two. The zombie spawn points; they aren't nice at all. When I say this I mean that the zombies are either spawning right in front of you or around the corner from you. I personally think this map needs more work, on the finale, zombies, and lack of weapons and ammo on level 3. There was enough ammo on level 3, just lack of weapons.

Pros:

+ Fun
+ Very nice details / textures.
+ Weapon and ammo placement.
+ Campaign idea was awesome.
+ Lots of zombies.

Cons:

- Original finale.

Conclusion:

The finale could have more excitement, but it is just a simple helicopter ending. I honestly think that Valve should add this map to the list of the other 5 main campaigns; No Mercy, Death Toll, Dead Air, Blood Harvest, Crash Course. It would fit in nice, it is a very fun map. 

Pros:

+ Nice details / textures.
+ Nice weapon placement / ammo.
+ Exiting finale.
+ Loads of zombies.
+ Lighting was perfect.
+ No bugs / glitches.

Cons:

- Only one tank in finale.

Conclusion:

Very fun map, would be even funner to play with friends. Decent finale, very exiting. 

Pros:

+ Nice Textures / Design
+ Cool Idea

Cons:

- Automatically started.
- Didn't get the time to check out the map.

Conclusion:

It's a nice idea.

Pros:

+ Fun
+ Easy to survive
+ Reminds me of Lord of the Rings. 
+ Loads of supplies.
+ Great textures / feeling.

Cons:

- A little easy.
- Agreed that there are to many gas / propane tanks.

Conclusion:

@ Player, you have to unzip it then drag the .vpk in the addons folder, or double click it.

Pros:

+ Nice Design.
+ Horde size.
+ Usage of ammo & supplies.
+ Textures.
+ Nice size for each map.
+ Lighting.

Cons:

- Crash on finale.

Conclusion:

Very nice. 

Pros:

+ Nice Layout.
+ Long.
+ Pretty fun finale.
+ Pretty straight forward on where you need to be going.

Cons:

- Foggy.
- Tank skin glitched to my other maps.
- Messed up my custom skins for the survivors. [ Coach & Rochelle].
- Custom skins that I didn't like.
- Elevator would leave you behind sometimes.

Conclusion:

It's an okay map. Just wish it didn't tamper with my custom skins.

Pros:

+ Very fun And easy.
+ Gives us time to get our stuff every now and then.
+ PERFECT placement for weapons and supplies.
+ Lighting is perfect.
+ M60 Massacre.
+ Tanks don't spawn in your face.
+ Supportive AIs.

Cons:

- None at all.

Conclusion:

Perfect map, perfect everything. 100/100. Well done. My new favorite survival map. :D. 11:37:30. Ftw.

Pros:

+ Good Ol' Half Life Map & Symbols. 
+ Nice textures.
+ Very close to the original Half Life map.
+ Nice finale setup.
+ Fun finale, two tanks.
+Nice way to escape the finale.
+ Horde size, pretty good.
+ Weapon and Ammo usage. 

Cons:

- Sky glitched up sometimes. [Could be personal.] 
- Could get lost if you haven't played this map before in Half Life.
- Would be cool to have some Half Life zombie models in there.

Conclusion:

I didn't count you off for the three Cons because, this is a great map and doesn't have anything wrong with it. Also, the three Cons can be fixed. This is a map I look forward to playing a few times more. Good job.

Pros:

+ Very Fun & Fair.
+ Open Spaces.
+ Lots Of Places To Defend From.
+ Perfect Weather.
+ Awesome Lighting.
+ Nice and challenging. 
+ Weapon usage and ammo stashes were used.
+ Lots'O Chainsaws! :D

Cons:

- Couldn't find a magnum.

Conclusion:

Very fun and fun to play with friends. I like it, and encourage you to at least try the map because it is very fun.

Pros:

+ Jigsaw puzzle ftw.
+ Nice layout.
+ Awesome setting.
+ The pterodactyl was pretty sweet.
+ Lots of tanks.
+ Nice Lighting.

Cons:

None really.

Conclusion:

Very awesome map, fun to play with friends and single player. Nothing wrong with it. 

Pros:

+ Things set up nicely.
+ Nice Details.
+ Nice Textures.
+ Nice Weather.
+ Has you feeling like you're really in the game.
+ Nice beginning.
+ Nice Finale.

Cons:

- Not much of a challenge. 
- Would be cool on Level 2 at the elevator part, more zombies spawn and keep spawning until you get in the elevator, would have more action like in No Mercy elevator part in the hospital. 
- Could get lost on Level 3.
- A few glitches.
- No defibrillators on the battlefield in the finale.

Conclusion:

Played on Expert, not to much of a challenge. Okay map, not something I would play again, but something that I had fun with. I'd recommend playing it, not recommended to waste so much time on it. Once again, you can play this on Expert and not have a problem. IMO. 

Pros:

+ Nice Weather.
+ Nice Weapon Placement.
+ Nice Setting.
+ Decent Amount Of Defending Spots.
+ M60 Ftw.

Cons:

- Two Bots Would Suicide.

Conclusion:

Decent map for survival, recommend playing. 

Pros:

+ Great Details.
+ Death Toll Environment.
+ New Paths & Routes. 
+ Total New Finale.
+ Nice Finale House.
+ A Little Long, But Nice.
+ No Bugs / Glitches.
+ Nice Details, Rain, Lighting, Room Details. 

Cons:

- Lack Of Maxed Weapons.
- Lack Of Ammo Stacks.
- IMO: Impossible With Bots On Advanced+.
- Doesn't Really Tell You How To Destroy Church Bell.
- Church Bell Needs A Lot Of Damage To Be Destroyed.
- The Last Level, Out-Running The Zombies.
- Some Bots Were Stupid.
- Rochelle Teleported To Me When She Was Suppose To Die In The Finale.

Conclusion:

Great map, deserves a very good score. Professionally made, took me about 2 hours to finish! Had to change the difficulty from Adv to Normal. Can't really depend on bots, I would recommend playing online if your going to do a hard difficulty. 
I encourage you to download, worth playing. 93/100.

Pros:

+ Makes You Look For Your Supplies. 
+ Great Textures.
+ Nice Setting.
+ Fun.
+ Bots have good coordination.

Cons:

- Not enough weapons.
- Short.

Conclusion:

Pretty awesome map, no glitches, no exploits. Fun to play with alone if you have no friends like me. Lol.. Fun online.

Pros:

- Textures Are Awesome! 
- Insanely Fun.
- Makes You Feel Like You're Really Playing Mario.
- Weapon placement is pretty nice.
- Finale is pretty sweet.

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

A very fun single player/co-op playing map. Great work on this.

Pros:

+ Very Fun With Friends.
+ Low Gravity.
+ Cool Beginning. 

Cons:

- To many zombies.
- A lot of special infected.
- Hard to find the weapons and stuff.
- Hordes are kinda large.
- Bots are to stupid and can't even support.

Conclusion:

It's not a terrible map, I wouldn't really find it worthy to download but that just my opinion.

Pros:

+ Something to Relax You.
+ Variety of Things To Do.
+ Cool ending.
+ Expresses Pirates of The Caribbean.
+ Nice Work
+ Nice Textures and Zombie Placement.
+ Bots aren't stupid.

Cons:

- A few minor glitches.

Conclusion:

Not very much bad things about this map. Definitely worth downloading.

Pros:

+ Great Detail
+ Challenging 
+ Lots of action going on.
+ Beatable
+ Great Start Story

Cons:

- Glitchy Finale
- Power things were to far from the alarm turn-off
- Really dark in some places

Conclusion:

Pretty decent map, not to bad, very difficult for single player on advanced +. Grab a buddy, and this is one hell of a great map.