All Items
Daily Reward
16:16:12 Collect

Reviews for Nightmare on Liberty Street

Write Review
    • kurochama
      kurochama
      kurochama
      kurochama

      Posted this review

      6

      Too short although it has potentials to be better

      • kurochama
        kurochama 
        @EshmawyMan:
Actually map 2 of this campaign has a serious bot navigation problem like I mentioned on the review. Bots can't follow players after climbing a ladder in the beginning of map 2. On the finale, actually you can use the cars to avoid water. I jumped from one car to another because it would be bad if there's a special infected when walking in the water. & probably the author wouldn't come back, as the last update of this campaign was in 2011. But it's still possible to fix if there are other map makers willing to take over this campaign.
      • EshmawyMan
        EshmawyMan 
        Hey i just played this map and i cursed a lot because it was SP & Expert XD No way to do it with Expert SP mode... I am writing a review soon just in case the author comes on. I replied to you on " White Forest " Campaign post...
    • ErrorUnknownGT
      ErrorUnknownGT
      ErrorUnknownGT
      ErrorUnknownGT

      Posted this review

      6

      Review

      Meh campaign. Very bland in terms of design, very little atmosphere. Bad navmesh in some areas, bots getting stuck and such. Other than that it was ok. No glitches/bugs. Nice work.
    • jn31
      jn31
      jn31
      jn31

      Posted this review

      2

      Pros:

      fun

      Cons:

      too hard

      Conclusion:

      nice map! i like it!
    •
      gio895
      gio895

      Posted this review

      10

      Pros:

      * Design
*  Entertaining
* Fully qualified
* High-detailed
* Perfect supplies

      Cons:

      None

      Conclusion:

      To begin, this map was a huge experience. One of the best maps I've played around here.
When I saw the pictures, I knew this was the map to play, because of the high textures.
The beginning was amazing! No saferoom at all! Me and my mates went rambo from the first second.
The second map was the most funny part. My mate fell down that hole! Couldn't stop laughing at that bit.
The ending was pretty poor... Helped my mates safely to the helicopter and BANG, a witch in my back, making my friends escape without me! Huge surprise! 

To be short:
Best. Map. Ever.
      •
        Mariowned 
        From all the negative reviews I have received, it's hard to tell if you are serious or joking. If you are sincere, then you have made my day. The campaign is supposed to be constant chaos and torture, which makes it fun. You played it exactly how it was designed and I am so happy you enjoyed it. In fact, I would love you play the campaign with you and your friends. Thank you so much for the positive review! (if not trolling)
    • Whiie
      Whiie
      Whiie
      Whiie

      Posted this review

      4.7

      Pros:

      * Scripted events (towers falling, floor breaking etc.)
* Unique in its own way.
* Fairly entertaining.

      Cons:

      / Ugly visuals - gray fog, bad lighting etc.
/ Crowded supply spots. Loot should have been scattered around instead.
/ Map 2 was way too easy - managed to complete it with no damage taken on advanced with one other player.
/ Pointless cutscenes.
/ Endless horde in the finale.
/ Short maps.
/ Ugly, texture-less water.
/ Very linear, hardly any alternative paths.

      Conclusion:

      It clearly needs work but it still feels like *some* effort was put into it. Bad visuals, way too much loot and lack of overall variety. With some work it could probably be made better.
    • Mz Cookies
      Mz Cookies
      Mz Cookies
      Mz Cookies

      Posted this review

      3

      Pros:

      - Floor breaks in map 2
- Decent amount of supplies

      Cons:

      - Some pointless cut scenes
- Hard to follow, needs more guiding arrows
- Maps are too short
- Boring environment
- Lack of detail
- Endless hordes
- The radio isn't highlighted, it's extremely hard to find
- No tanks in the finale

      Conclusion:

      Well, I struggle to find some good things in this campaign and that's unusual for me.
    • TheLittleBrownDog
      TheLittleBrownDog
      TheLittleBrownDog
      TheLittleBrownDog

      Posted this review

      3.3

      Pros:

      - College campus idea is a cool idea, that's what made me download the map.
- The first breaking floor thing was unexpected and a nice touch.
- Details on the buildings are good.

      Cons:

      - The breaking walls look very cheap.
- Too many hordes, and they can spawn right on top of you.
- No direction to the finale trigger.
- Cut scenes were annoying, unnecessary, and made people crash often.
- Too many tanks.
- The map just isn't long enough to be a campaign. The only way to win is to rush.
- First area is too open, and most of the detail work just isn't done yet.

      Conclusion:

      As a TF2 mapper who's never dared to touch L4D2 authoring tools, I can say that you're well on your way to making some good maps in the future. We didn't like this one, but that was mostly because it obviously isn't finished yet. I'd suggest, given its length, that you go the direction of Helm's Deep, a staged survival map. That would work great with this layout. Keep at it, I can't wait to see this map in the future!
    • Partsman[PA]
      Partsman[PA]
      Partsman[PA]
      Partsman[PA]

      Posted this review

      7

      Pros:

      Lay out and navigation is nice.
Graphics and sounds nice.

      Cons:

      Too many zombies and tanks at once.

      Conclusion:

      Ok i played it twice on a normal server and could not beat it and it was not fun. 
I played it on a friends modded server and it was actually really fun. 
The zombie hoard needs calmed down to meet normal server functions.

End of results.