Probably one of the best survival maps I have seen for l4d2 ever! Enviroment, soundscapes, fog, skybox... everything is amazing! You should move the survivors closer to the start button (or add another button at start and keep the one you already have so you can choose where you want to start) Remove alot of the supplies. I found like 15 fire/explosive ammo. 1-3 is enough. Bots get stuck at a few parts. They sometimes get stuck at the church windows and refuse to use the doors. They also start to "hang" sometimes at the church tower area. And the biggest con I found. I could go up at the tower and then jump from the tower up on the church roof. I lost 30-40hp but the zombies could not reach me up there and I got gold medal without even trying. I will rate this 95+ if you fix the problems. This map is almost perfect :P. It would be awesome if you use this in a campaign someday

First off, I want to say that this is a FANTASTIC map for a new mapper, in fact the best I have seen, and I want to see more work from you in the future. Now, here is what you did right. The environment was great, the darknesss provided tension in the gameplay, and the multiple holdout points added dynamic replayability to your map. The map was huge and was fun to explore and the graveyard setting was pretty cool. Now, here is what you did wrong, and why. You had too many weapons and supplies to make surviving painfully easy. Honestly, 16 health packs, 16 ammo packs, and 9 M60s is ridiculous for one map. An entire campaign doesn't even reach that amount, except for the health pack count. You had way too many overpowered camping locations, 3 to be precise, the church, the basement, and the spawn. The basement and spawn were overpowered because you had to defend one entrance, and the church was overpowered because of it's enormously large amount of supplies when the zombies had to come from the front if you were on the second floor. You didn't spawn the player near the finale starter which causes confusion, and the ground looks very unrealistically flat. Now, here is how you fix your map, to make it amazing: 1. Remove most of the supplies 2. Spawn the survivors close to the finale starter 3. Fix the overpowered camping locations: a. Church - Move the supplies you didn't remove to the floor, and add a zombie entrance, like a hole in the wall, behind the current supply location. That way it's not easy to camp at the top and you have to go down for supplies. I would recommend adding the entrance from that scaffold you have outside. b. Basement - Add more entrances, maybe a hole in the church floor and a destructible wall entrance from underground tunnels. c. Spawn - Add a way for the zombies to come up from behind. All-in-all an amazing first map, congratulations. I want to see your work in the future. Gameplay: 30/50 Aesthetics: 25/30 Uniqueness: 10/10 Replayability: 10/10 *BONUS: Great first map +10* TOTAL: 85/100