Reviews for Hong Kong
-
doedipusPosted this review
hoo, boy
the map is busted as hell, but it's beta, so whatever. the bugs I encountered didn't make it worse, and really improved on the bland design. there was a bug on map 2 where one of the party spawned in the end safe room instead of the starting one, skipping it. there was a bug on map 3 where we accidentally got around the trigger for the finale, and since the chopper spawned without the event, we didn't realize we'd skipped it until the "credits" lighting bugs everywhere day/night changed seemingly at random honestly, if those bugs get fixed, it'll probably be fine. some of the areas are pretty unpopulated, especially in map 3, where most of the map is a parking structure, but that's about par for the course around here. needs work/10
-
-
duckandcoverPosted this review
a really bright map
love this map, second stage went by really fast when one of our team members instantly started at the end very beginner friendly
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Chan-1994-APosted this review
Pros:
1. The second map of this chapter scenery was beautiful, the sky colo(u)r was charming.(as your screenshot you see); 2. The escape route wasn't complicated, I never get lost while I played this map first time; 3. Although the textures were monotonous, but it didn't matter;
Cons:
1. Hong Kong was left-hand traffic country, the cars run along the left side, not the right side(as Japan), and the people use British English, so "Computer Center(電腦中心)" was "Computer Centre"; 2. Opposite, the map 1 difficulty was too hard(the hordes never get stopped), and the map 3 finale was too easy(Tank won't appear in the finale); 3. In the finale(map 3), the computers won't get on the helicopter, you need to make them incapable to quit the area.
Conclusion:
I've linked your map "Hong Kong" to my character mod "SDU Coach"(you can search for it on L4DMaps or Workshop), SDU was the well known Hong Kong special forces, I thought it matches with this map. I really like this map, I hope you can promote this project, fix up some bugs(as the computers won't get on the rescue chopper), you can replace the helicopter WITH a rescue BOAT.
This review was posted before the latest release.
-
FYI, in map 1 you needed to switch that alarm off and climb that ladder before you move down the garden and to the safe room :)
-
You can totally rebuild the map 3, my suggestion is that the rescue area is better harbor/harbour(as Hong Kong Victoria Harbour), and there's a rescue BOAT near the dock, and the survivors must run to the boat as faster as possible, then escape from the mutation area.
This comment was posted before the latest release.
-
-
kennyinbmore
Posted this review
Pros:
-None
Cons:
-Jesus, i have to explain ALL of the cons?? It might be easier to do this CONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONS!!
Conclusion:
I understand this is you're first map but CONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONS!!CONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONS!!CONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSVCONSCONSVVCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONSCONS!! CONS CONS!!!!!!!!!
This review was posted before the latest release.
-
XD
-
-
Machiavellus
Posted this review
Pros:
-None
Cons:
-Monotonous textures -Various parts with below subpar architecure. -Skybox didn't work at all? -Died on map 2, restarted at the saferoom at the end of map 2 -Numerous bugs -Horrible map flow -Confusing events
Conclusion:
This has got to be the worst map I've played by far. It's beyond unfinished. Every step in the map I found another flaw in the design. Map 1 has a great example of terrible architecture, you head down an escalator and make a left turn. The left turn in the first place is completely out of place as that's not really where someone would put an escalator but even more, the stair well down to the left is just a cheese wedge that barely blends into the escalator. All the walls were plain and boring. There was a gnome I couldn't pick up. Map 1 had a series of display cases that held numerous things that would never be put into a display case, I'd look the other way if they were all items you could carry, pills, medkits, etc, but various things were just physics props. Gas cans in a display case???? I also saw almost no reason to recognize this as a campaign based in China. I gave this a 1 because it was by definition a map, but that's it.
This review was posted before the latest release.
-
-
==Maverick==Posted this review
Pros:
- 'Noob mappers' as yourselves actually finishing a campaign, even if it is full of glitches -Interesting use of clipping
Cons:
- Broken second map...if you die, it repawns you in the saferoom - Broken finale, I fell out of the helicopter - Crash Course vehicle glitching through the map - A ton of other graphical glitches - Tank in the elevator with no indication
Conclusion:
Considering youre a new mapper, a shouldnt be based on map design, but on your skill level...having only about 100 hours of mapping myself I know how hard mapping can actually be)unlike probably all these other reviewers). I did have fun with the campaign...it was actually quite refreshing to play a campaign with some 'features' for once rather then a dead serious campaign that offers gauntlet after gauntlet(which is FAIL in my opinion) Good job for your first campaign, it was actually more fun then a lot of other campaigns Ive played that had 8-9 ratings.
This review was posted before the latest release.
-
-
AmpliDUDEPosted this review
Pros:
======== In general ======== + Good street textures used in map 2. + Gutter in map 2 was nice as well. + Long enough for 3 maps. + Very easy campaign.
Cons:
======== Map 2 ======== - Very unoptimized framerate. - Walking over first bridge and you can see the border of the map. - Unrealistic shopping-mall leading to trains. - That yellow stuff was really not suiting. ===================== ======== Map 3 ======== - Graphical bugs throughout the whole map. - Bots wont automatically get on to the lift. - AI navigation was partly very unoptimized. - Through entrance, ground may be transparent. - Bots don't get aboard the chopper. so end can't be reached. - Skybox problems. - Way to easy finale. ===================== ======== Miscellaneous ======== - Bots only pick up items very rarely. - All in all very unoptimized campaignl. - Textures were not really high res sometimes. =========================
Conclusion:
Well nice try I guess, but some few major corrections would be applicable here.
This review was posted before the latest release.
-
-
Lex347b
Posted this review
Pros:
Doesn't crash impressive for a first time mapper to make a campaign has some Chinese elements map is playable with bots until the helicopter in the end length of maps interesting glass ball idea
Cons:
Not optimized (bad fps) empty map doesn't look much like China bad textures
Conclusion:
Please continue on this map, I want to see how much it can improve, as it is playable, but needs to be more full, and optimized (fps)
This review was posted before the latest release.
-
End of results.
Posted this review
Review