Old gold

Used to play this back in 2010. Can't believe I never left a review. Nice unique setting and fun gameplay. Hordes occur too frequently though.

Great blend

I like the mash-up between the old version and new version here. Nice work

Needs work

Short, linear, constant hordes providing artificial difficulty, and horrible latency during the finale. However, it at least has some lighting

Needed to be finished

Not-so-great map design compounded with a very long finale with way too many supplies. There's also no rescue.

Great scripting tools

Very good tool and allows you do almost anything inside L4D2.

Art Safety Art

Blart Blart

Pros:

Great additions to the campaign - makes it less straight-forward
Same valve-quality gameplay
The new areas are well-polished

Cons:

Lots of dialogue from the original was lost
Some areas feel less polished than others
NAV is a bit off in new areas
Nick floats above the ground in the intro

Conclusion:

A great re-design of Hard Rain. Not many issues, and none of them are game-breaking. Good work!

Pros:

'Choice' system
Sacrifice ending
Multiple varieties of maps

Cons:

Bad voice acting
Ammo is spread too thin
Bad map layout
Horrendous brushwork
Generally rushed
Map length is inconsistent
NAV is iffy
Director spawns infected right in front of the player
Saferooms are poorly equipped

Conclusion:

This is probably one of the worst campaign's I've ever played. Everything that's listed as a con is a result from a lack of polish. SpeedBoost, you really rushed this campaign and spent no time with it, and it shows. 

However, the map choice system is neat.

Pros:

Decent gameplay
Some areas were well-done
Not too long

Cons:

Bad NAV mesh throughout
Lackluster finale
Bland design in some areas

Conclusion:

Not too much to say about this campaign. The execution issues mar the campaign more than it should.

Pros:

Great environment detail
Plenty of supplies
Awesome idea - potential for a full campaign

Cons:

Bad lighting - map is too dark
Map is small
No room to maneuver during hordes

Conclusion:

A great map that has a few kinks, but will probably be sorted out in later patches. I would recommend a day version or creating a few lights in several areas to even out the dark areas.

Pros:

Great map designs
Good spread of supplies
Nice ambience
Gameplay is mostly solid
Finale is well balanced

Cons:

Some panic events can be bypassed
Too many panic events and hordes
Map layouts are confusing and cluttered
Maps are somewhat short

Conclusion:

A solid campaign that is marred by a few issues, but other than that it's good. The two biggest offenders are too many panic events (an average of two per map) and the confusing map layouts, with little direction hints placed in the environment.

Pros:

Good map design and layout
Great color correction
Good spread of supplies
Finale was good
Decent survivor dialogue

Cons:

Lackluster ending
Somewhat short

Conclusion:

The campaign is good, however the ending seems like you didn't know where to take your idea of a trainyard finale. I wouldn't call piling into an elevator an escape. The color correction was good, at times it would transition awkwardly (Between the church and the streets) but other than that, no real issues besides the somewhat short length.

Pros:

Great scenery
Good layouts
Well-done NAV mesh
Nice touch with the BBC broadcast
Authentic feel 
Decent voice acting
Good spread of supplies
Panic Events and hordes weren't too big or too small
Campaign-specific music
Werewolf Tanks
Great attention to detail and visual design

Cons:

The objectives can become a little unclear at times
Somewhat long with a short ending (effort /= payoff)

Conclusion:

A great campaign. Well worth the time to play. I would advise playing with friends, as it can get harder on your own. The ending seems reminiscent of One 4 Nine, though - it's short and is badly done with an awkward camera position. I would recommend changing the camera angle and making the ending shot longer. 

Pros:

Great map design
Good spread of supplies
Redesigned map 2 safehouse and starting area
Survivor dialogue that isn't ambient_generic!
The bridge is realistic
Fun gameplay and events

Cons:

Some brushwork is a little sloppily put-together
The sand texture on the beach looks bad
Witches spawn too early in map 1 

Conclusion:

A great campaign. It's come a long way since I first saw it in 2009. A few little issues but nothing that drags the campaign down too much.

Pros:

Great visual design
Good boss fight
Awesome co-op play

Cons:

No tier 2 weapons until map 4
Constant hordes + inconsistency
Bots sometimes struggle in map 2
Map layouts can be puzzling
Vending machines didn't output anything 
Can't really call "lock picking" a gameplay mechanic
Awful color correction in the interiors of map 2 and 3

Conclusion:

A campaign that has its fair share of issues. I'll go through the cons.

1. Tier 2 weapons should be placed in early map 3, about halfway through the campaign. It provides players with a sense of progress and makes them feel a little more well-equipped. Which is all the better, considering that supplies can be few and far between.
2. Hordes can be overdone - and you've certainly overdone them. They are so often that they become progress hindrances - and it's obvious you did it to extend the map length, which is something no developer should do. Ever. And on top of that, the hordes are inconsistent - they'll come for an exploding pipe underground, but no sign of any hordes appear when a barricade explodes above ground. 
3. Self explanatory. Ellis and Coach died because too many infected swarmed them during the "gate" sequence in map 2. 
4. This might have been just for me, but no matter how many times I used the vending machines, they didn't give me anything.
5. The map layout can be really confusing at times - I went in circles numerous times.
6. It's not really "lock picking" - its a func_button_timed. Anyone can do those. Unless you make certain doors be a puzzle or have some sort of "lock pick" inventory, then you can't really say lock picking is a feature. It's better described as taking 5 seconds longer to open certain doors.
7.  The color correction in the end safehouse of map 2/initial surface is absolutely terrible. It drains nearly all the colors inside the building and gives a soft orange glow, and it's quite noticeable. Lessen the color drain affect and it will look better.

Sorry for slamming the campaign in my review, I'm just trying to give you my opinion from another developer.

Pros:

Visually appealing maps
Well designed 
Great spread of weapons and supplies
Good intro
The way map 2 ends is pretty awesome

Cons:

Finale becomes overly difficult 
Somewhat short
Could've used more exposition in the bunker

Conclusion:

An overall good campaign, even though it isn't technically finished. 

Pros:

Great map design in map 3
Decent visual design
Fun finale
Unexpected outro
Good spread of supplies

Cons:

Bad map design in map 1 and 2. Became frustrating to play
Tedious gameplay in maps 1 and 2
Boring visuals in map 1
No intro

Conclusion:

A campaign that has potential that hasn't been realized yet. A decent campaign with loads of room for improvement

Pros:

Amazing detail in the maps
Great map layouts
Lots of character dialogue
Great event ideas
Noteworthy areas that are visually well-designed
Good amount of scattered supplies

Cons:

A little difficult at times
Lots of hordes

Conclusion:

A great campaign! I'm a hard critic, but this campaign managed to earn a high score - one that I don't give out often. 

Pros:

Terrible yet funny voice acting from the truck driver
Good map design
Well-detailed maps

Cons:

Truck part is very buggy
Constant hordes
Unbalanced difficulty
Boat scavenge is difficult when alone
Lack of supplies

Conclusion:

A well-detailed campaign marred by issues that make it frustrating to play. 

Pros:

Stays true to the design from Bioshock
Great map design
Colorful
Lighting is well-done

Cons:

Too many infected spawning at once
Not a fan of the "let's build" maps
Needs ammo piles
Needs a survival version
Unbalanced gameplay

Conclusion:

A great map that isn't so hot once the gameplay starts going. Overall, a solid effort.

Pros:

Decent gameplay
Has some good ideas
Nice detail in the first map

Cons:

Bots aren't cooperative in map 2
Nothing notable or spectacular about the design
Bad map design and layout
Finale is unbalanced

Conclusion:

A campaign that unfortunately has nothing truly notable about it. It doesn't stand out in the crowded space of campaigns and maps.

Pros:

Great bridge design
Infected only come at you from one way
Good NAV
Plenty of supplies
Attention to detail

Cons:

Not a fan of custom music
Red concrete texture taken from 2019

Conclusion:

Overall, a fun map. However i'm not a fan of custom music in survival maps, so it deters me from replaying it. Overall, an 8.5/10

Pros:

AMAZING visual design.
Some interesting gameplay mechanics.
Beautiful level design
No use of filters to pretty up the levels
Great NAV work
Good soundtrack

Cons:

Massive performance problems.
Frequent FPS drops (60 -> 20)
Unoptimized
Finale was confusing
Frequent hordes
No soundscapes
Safehouses aren't done right

Conclusion:

(V1.1)

A great campaign. Has the best visual design I've seen in a while in L4D, however it is marred by optimization and performance problems which are frequent enough that it distracts from the gameplay and takes most of the score away from the final verdict, giving the campaign a 7/10 in its first release. Obviously there's room for improvement, but for now the campaign is playable. 

As for the safehouses issue, the ending safehouse of one level isn't the same as the starting safehouse of the next, so there's some continuity issues there. Especially when you go in one door in one level and go out the same door the next, but it's a different building.

Pros:

Great foliage
Decent survival rate
Good lighting
Custom content

Cons:

Small space to fight in
The map is very small
Confusing layout
Not enough supplies

Conclusion:

A nice survival map that could use some more work.

Pros:

Great quality
Consistent design
Awesome visuals

Cons:

Lackluster finale 
Each level is a little too long
A tad boring

Conclusion:

A great campaign that's unfortunately brought down by the finale. It feels anti-climatic and is very easy. Otherwise, a solid 8.5

Pros:

Actual facial animation!
Great rig - no problems

Cons:

FPS arms look a little off the gun at times.

Conclusion:

Can we get Sam B next?

Pros:

Great attention to detail
Nice events
Solid map length
Good looking animations and custom models
Level design is fantastic
Great lighting

Cons:

Hordes come often (V 1.0)
Oversaturated color correction
Campaign comes with arby's re-anim mods (V 1.0)
No Tier 2 Weapons until the 4th map
Too many pistols in map 2 and 3
Hardly any variety of melee weapons

Conclusion:

Overall, a great campaign that is a bit overshadowed by it's two biggest current issues, the horde and the weapon mod issue. Overall though it's a solid campaign that could use a bit of work.

Review for: Version 1.0

Pros:

Great visuals
Thorough detail throughout the campaign
Some excellently crafted environments (the two planes + the road area)
Custom music that fits
Tom Savini!

Cons:

Uneven pacing (4th map is pretty long while the others are normal)
Radio voice is too distorted
Melee weapons are very rare

Conclusion:

Overall a very satisfying campaign that is a bit long but is very expertly crafted. The events are timed right and no horde was too big or too small. The visuals are pretty damn good, and there was amazing detail in some parts and good detail throughout. Overall a 9/10

Pros:

Good quality models
VGUI Icons
Name Swap

Cons:

Hands are downright horrible - it's like they were hacked together with no thought of quality. 
Same faces - but no mouth movement

Conclusion:

The FPS arms alone drag the score down due to how horrible they are. Otherwise it's a good mod.

Pros:

Excellent amount of detail
Fun events, like the falling rocks
Good concept
Custom music and voice acting

Cons:

Lack of ammo piles
Bots stood in the lava, not caring that it was hurting them
Could use some more weapon choices during the middle of the map
One of the first blocked off areas, the one with the delivery truck, is glitch-able
Many areas where getting out of the map is possible

Conclusion:

Nice! Solid good work, guys. A couple problems here and there but nothing that really detracts from the value, except for the bot problem. Not sure how to get around that one though, so I didn't take off too many points for it.

I noticed a lot of the same cars but differently colored, but thanks to L4D2 having like 5 different car models total, I didn't take off any points.

Pros:

Greatly Designed
The Volcano and the lava's design is impressive
Nice amount of detail
Lots of fun events

Cons:

Appears unfinished 
Hardly any sound effects
No Intro
Bots easily die in the lava
The explosion doesn't appear significant - add some funky color correction, more shaking, and an explosion sound effect and some slow motion.
Too many supplies

Conclusion:

A very good start! However, the map feels unfinished - no intro and hardly any sound effects.

A solid 7.5/10

Pros:

Good looking animations
Smooth and fluid

Cons:

No animations for two pistols
Reloading takes a bit longer than usual

Conclusion:

A great mod but feels incomplete.

Pros:

Graphically, it's one of the best maps I've ever seen.
Impressive helicopter animations
Excellent effects
Best use of cubemaps I've ever seen
Solid gameplay
Massive improvements since the original beta

Cons:

Relies too much on color correction, smoke and lens flare for it's impressiveness
Some small NAV problems - like bots can't rescue you if incapped on the flamethrower
Tanks spawned in easy kill areas

Conclusion:

A great map! Hopefully we'll see more in the coming weeks. It's definitely improved since the original beta, which is something not too many maps do.

Pros:

Great map design
Plenty of supplies
Nice ambience
Great cinematic concept.

Cons:

Bots can, and often will fall out of the helicopter and it is easy to do so yourself
NAV is terrible, bots stood in the fire in the atrium area in the first map
Random Horde?
Finale is extremely hard
Could use some more props
Visual bugs in the first map

Conclusion:

A good start but it has a long way to go. In my eyes this shouldn't of been released so soon, it is plagued with issues in the first map alone. There is no "ground" on the helicopter ride and the environment seems to be lacking other buildings and general city detail. The Bot NAV is also awful, they stood in the fire area of the atrium and refused to move. The finale needs more supplies.

Overall 6/10

I will change my score once the campaign has been updated with most of the issues fixed.

Pros:

Great atmosphere
Good level design
Custom melee weapons
Nice intro and outro
Custom music
Custom events

Cons:

Some of the music is a bit louder than what it needs to be, for example, the saferoom music.
Can get a little hard at times.
Hardly any story to this - It's basically get from point A to point B.

Conclusion:

A great campaign! 

Pros:

Great design
Good NAV
Awesome lighting

Cons:

Obvious use of color correction - tone it down
CC is distracting at the finale
Confusing, disappointing ending
Lots of hordes in maps 3-5
Bots have some trouble with staying alive

Conclusion:

Just like Mass Effect 3, this campaign is great. All until the ending. It's confusing. Disappointing. And the color correction could be toned down slightly, and for some reason I got constant hordes in maps 3-5. Rammed up the difficulty.

Otherwise 8.5/10

Pros:

Somewhat interesting map
Good survival rate

Cons:

Supplies are too spread out 
Map could use more detail
Infected only came from one or two areas at a time, mainly the room we started in or the ones behind us if we're on the warhead area.

Conclusion:

A good map, could use some improvements but it's good.

Pros:

Great atmosphere
Seems similar to The Passing
Great ambient sounds
Didn't find any issues with NAV
Good environment detail

Cons:

The Finale is a bit too much on the bots. They had trouble keeping up with me.
Seems to have an identity crisis - The campaign doesn't have anything memorable in it

Conclusion:

A great campaign! Virtually no problems with NAV, great environment, but the campaign doesn't seem to have anything memorable to it. Good job though!

Pros:

Creepy environment
Excellent use of soundscapes
Perfect lighting
Explosions look good at night
The cemetery is especially creepy
Fires look amazing
Good blend of lighting - neither too dark or too bright.
Path system adds a little variety
Added Survivor Dialogue

Cons:

Dynamic Path system is a bit flawed - you can tell the difference between valve work and Acermors' work
Infected have a bit too much of an edge with the roofs in versus
Grace period from alarm event has been removed, amping up the difficulty and giving bots more trouble
General lack of zombies in bits of maps 3-5
Not too much has been changed.
Many instances in which Survivor lines were overlapped by other survivor lines.

Conclusion:

A good re-release of an already good campaign. The lighting steals the spotlight here, almost managing to hide the questionable design choices. There's really no new content here besides about 30 seconds of extra paths, so this campaign seems to be a showcase of "been there, done that" but with upgraded lighting. 7.5/10

Pros:

Nice, long campaign for a beta.
Survivor Dialogue

Cons:

Confusing map layout
Supplies are rare in map 3
No soundscapes
NAV can be finnicky at certain points (Highway)
All maps need more supplies

Conclusion:

Good job! I like the length but it definitely has some edges to work out.  

Pros:

Great atmosphere
Decent story

Cons:

Map quality can go from decent to bad
Bad NAV
Constant hordes
I like a challenge but damn this is one I can't beat.
Fog is too close
Confusing map layout
Too little supplies

Conclusion:

It tries, but it doesn't hit the mark. Unfortunately, this campaign feels less than half-baked in the oven, falling prey to design issues and questionable choices made during development. The campaign is practically impossible to play with bots - they have a tendency to not pick up weapons and have a hard time defending themselves. Constant hordes, confusing map layouts and lack of supplies pretty much kill the campaign for an average L4D2 player. 

3.5/10

Pros:

Stays true to the original
Great visuals

Cons:

Unbalanced gameplay
Awful bot NAV
Bots constantly trigger the cameras and blow up the weapons cache
Many little bugs
Difficulty spikes

Conclusion:

A great concept, but unfortunately, marred by bad execution. Bot NAV is downright terrible, and are player dependent for the entire campaign. 

Could've been great. 6/10

Pros:

Good use of displacements and fog
Visually appealing
Looks the part of the movie, mostly

Cons:

Too difficult on your own
Bot NAV is iffy
Could be more true to the movie in terms of outside the house
Auto-starts
Little variety of supplies
Skybox could be extended

Conclusion:

A decent attempt that needs some work.

Pros:

Infected come from one area - yet it's challenging
Good amount of supplies
Great NAV
Sandstorm Effect

Cons:

The Base is ordinary - nothing makes it special
Terribly small
Hardly any melee weapons - this is necessary for a map this small

Conclusion:

It's pretty good, although hampered by the map being terribly small with no real exploration.

Pros:

Excellent Atmosphere
Skybox looks Great
Good spread of supplies and weapons
Challenging

Cons:

Small
Closed in

Conclusion:

Great map! I love the atmosphere however the map is a bit on the small side.

Pros:

Excellent animations
Great weapon quality

Cons:

None I can think of

Conclusion:

Quality work! Your mods are very good, haus.

Pros:

Looks great
Fun little events like Hillbilly help
Great intro
The dogs are funny
Good amount of supplies
Good design
Good balance between easy and challenging

Cons:

The house itself looks blocky, most notably on the first level.

Conclusion:

Great map! However the retreat itself looks blocky. As this is the main focus of the map, it detracts from the score more than it usually would.

Pros:

Excellent design
Great use of the rain
Good amount of detail
Decent amount of supplies
Makes for a good challenge
Awesome ambience
The infected come from all around the forest - you never know where they'll pop out.

Cons:

The houses have no props in them - it would make for better detail.
Supplies are all in one place - spread them out
Bot NAV can be a bit messy in some areas

Conclusion:

I liked this! It's a very good map and makes awesome use of the dynamic rain storm. 8/510

Pros:

The train finale is pretty cool.
The environment can look decent at times.

Cons:

The environment ranges from decent to poor.
It's okay to copy and paste some stuff, but not entire sections from official campaigns.
Ambient sounds are practically non-existent
What is the point of the radio on the first map?
The garage  door event can by bypassed as the infected burst through the wall right next to it
The finale is broken - never saw a tank or SI
Poor intro
Poor finale
Blocky brushwork
Short maps
The poster is not relevant at all to the campaign
The third map is confusing

Conclusion:

Overall, it tried but didn't get there. 4/10

Pros:

Great attention to detail
Great quality

Cons:

The dirt detracts a little bit from the look

Conclusion:

Pretty good. Fits Nick's role and looks great on him.

Pros:

Good scale of environments
Custom Music

Cons:

Bland textures and environments
Lacks detail
No witches

Conclusion:

Not really much to say about this campaign. It suffers from what a lot of campaigns do unfortunately, and there's nothing truly notable about it. 6.5/10

Pros:

Looks Great
FPS Arms
Gives Nick a more "badass" look
Character select screen

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

This is great. I really like it.

Pros:

Excellent Quality
Feels like a BF3 rifle
Great anims

Cons:

None at all

Conclusion:

Awesome gun. I use this all the time.

Pros:

Bots react much faster now.

Bots keep going after death.

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

This mod makes single player much more enjoyable.

Pros:

The hotel is visually excellent
3D skybox is good on the 3rd level
First map looks good, lighting is on par
Lighting looks great in Hotel map

Cons:

Confusing level design and layout
Lack of supplies in third saferoom
no intro
Hotel area lacks detail
No survivor dialogue
WAY too many car alarms. 
2nd map is bland, boring and visually unimpressive

Conclusion:

There's my two cents. Unfortunately for this campaign, the only saving grace and notability is the hotel area. It's greatly designed, but fails in the sense that there is very little detail or clutter to it.

Pros:

Excellent lighting
Definitely looks like a club
A survival map with an Intro 
Artwork is unique.
Great theme
Some areas look awesome, such as the bars and the blue room.
Rate of survival is okay - nothing too bad or too good.
Good Poster

Cons:

If it's a club, there should be music of some kind playing.
Too much artwork. It's like you're advertising the Dali guy.

Conclusion:

It's pretty good. While there is only slight room for improvement (a good thing) the map as a whole didn't wow me.

Pros:

Great looking environments in some areas such as the museum and subway.
Interesting design choices
Museum looks awesome
Use of a gauntlet event

Cons:

Environment can be lacking detail in some, most notably the second map's hallways.
Horde is too large for the elevator event. Bots were all incapped.
Needs a bit more lighting in the first part of map 1
Supplies are too thinly spread out in map 2
Final level's finale area needs to be camp-proofed
Hardly any survivor dialogue
Big 30 FPS drop in the museum entrance

Conclusion:

Some of the environments, like the museum, subway tunnels and the elevator area look great. Others are just plain with lack of details such as the hallways in map 2. Otherwise it's a great attempt at a campaign, needs some tuning.

Pros:

Excellent design.
Interesting puzzles
Challenging on any difficulty....yet fun.
Ending has a huge twist
Easter Eggs
The pipes event is FUN
Long, enduring maps
Well-spread out supplies
NAV is perfect
Extremely fun with 4 players and even bots
Even fun on the higher difficulties

Cons:

None.

Conclusion:

It's unusual that I give a 100 to any map. For that to happen, it must be perfect in every form. Nihilanth, I award you a perfect score on the basis that your map itself is perfect in every form. No horde is too large or too small, no bot had a mishap, and no event was TOO hard.

Congratulations. This campaign is the most fun I've had in a while.

Pros:

Good layout
Visually interesting

Cons:

No intro
No survivor dialogue
Very short
extremely easy

Conclusion:

I finally got around to this and I'm a bit less than impressed, only one map and it's short. While it does have a good visual style it doesn't have the gameplay to back it up. 7/10

Pros:

Insanely Fun
Original
Optional "no zombies" mode
Knome easter egg
Creative
Awesome destruction

Cons:

A bit short on length
Isn't replayable after the first few times

Conclusion:

A short yet sweet campaign that is fun, original and daring. 9/10.

Pros:

Great Scenery
Good placement of supplies
Awesome brushwork and attention to detail
Fun events
Great replayability

Cons:

A few areas that lack detail but nothing too bad.

Conclusion:

A great campaign with many fun elements that i'll definitely come back too. Epic!

Pros:

Excellent Quality Models
Anims looks great

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

An awesome mod. Try it and you'll see what I'm talking about

Pros:

Excellent Quality
Looks great

Cons:

None

Conclusion:

This is a good replacement for the boring, regular anims of the sniper.

Pros:

Great design
Visually pleasing at times
Good map length

Cons:

Brushwork is a tad blocky
Environments can look bland, boring, flat and incomplete at times
Poster has L4D characters
No real story

Conclusion:

For a first attempt, this is great!

Pros:

So amazing!
really helps me out, I can't play L4D2 to save my life!
I mean really, THE MAP IS VISUALLY INCREDIBLE

Cons:

ABSOULETLY NOEN

Conclusion:

download this map hard it is so awesome guys i mean seriouly

Pros:

Excellent Map Design
Good use of sounds
Really grabs the 'China' feel
Awesome theme
Intricate detail

Cons:

Finale is glitchy (APC door refuses to open)

Conclusion:

EXCELLENT Campaign. I will play this again! I love your work!

Pros:

Great Scenery
Epic Scale
Awesome lighting
Neat poster
Great Gameplay
Good pacing
Atmosphere is ****ing awesome
Excellent placement of weapons and supplies

Cons:

NAV is terrible on first part of map 1

Conclusion:

A great campaign, 90/100.

Pros:

He's a cop!
Great model
No right hand warping
Extremely detailed

Cons:

Nothing really

Conclusion:

It's awesome! Very good attention to detail.

Pros:

The airliner intro is awesome! Not to mention detailed!
Great scenery.
Really has the "China" feel.
The finale is sweet!
Awesome new music!

Cons:

The parachutes on the plane should not have randomized spawns. It's aggrevating when you can't find the last chute.
Short
Even with Game Helper on, it's confusing on where to go.
The NAV is awful on the upper part of the airliner

Conclusion:

An excellent campaign. I will play this again and I reccomend it to everyone!

Pros:

Absolutely Amazing Theme.
Unlimited Possibilites.
Very little bugs for something this unprecedented.
LOTS of fun.

Cons:

Turrets fire at you instead of infected in Sandbox
Some issues with survivors not picking up kits and weapons in Base
Putting down items in Sandbox is a bit iffy

Conclusion:

This is a great new concept! I LOVE IT!

Also, I fired Louis because of his pills addiction :P

Just shy of 100. 

Pros:

Decent Scenery
Feels Like China
Outro and Intro is cool, even with the too-shaky camera
Good Custom Music

Cons:

Two tanks together at the end of the second level
Second Level become boring when you get to all the barricades
Had a bit of trouble finding the Radio for the Finale at first.
Custom Music is a bit too quiet at the finale
Textures repeat too much..use blends
Blocky brushwork 
Horrible 3D skybox lighting

Conclusion:

An Okay effort at a China Campaign.

Pros:

Good pacing
Sky Bar looks somewhat nice
Good for a WIP
Nice looking poster
A new concept

Cons:

Can get boring at times
Bad lighting
Bots often get confused and stuck as where to go; Bad NAV indication
Kinda hard

Conclusion:

So far, so good!

Pros:

Cool lighting
Good "futuristic" feel

Cons:

NAV was off when I last played it
Supplies are few and far
Automatic startup
Confusing map layout

Conclusion:

Nice map.

Pros:

Good displacements
Decent amount of supplies
Map looks great visually
lots of detail

Cons:

Framerate drops
NAV is uneven
Bad Poster 

Conclusion:

It was an okay map.

Pros:

Great Theme
Awesome Brushwork
Good-looking Replica
Spread-out supplies
Sepia is a nice touch

Cons:

The sepia really takes away all lighting, making the map not as fun as it could be, which gives it a drab, dull look. While it does fit the theme, I didn't really like it.

NAV also needs a bit of work, too many special infected spawn at one time and they only come from one place.

Conclusion:

It's a pretty decent map. Great theme.

Pros:

L4D1 Survivors are a nice touch
Ambient Rain
Great Lighting, good job on the use of sprites
NAV is a bit off, but decently balanced
feels like the L4D Style

Cons:

Map feels small and cramped; doesn't stay true to the "open-world survival' premise
Skybox buildings look like huge blocks; push the fog a bit farther?
Hard to survive
Badly placed supplies
Lack of supplies

Conclusion:

A decent map, we need more like these.

However, spread around the supplies, and add more.

Pros:

Fun
Nice Idea
Easy to survive to at least 4 minutes
Barricades can be built fast

Cons:

Pace is a tad fast
Hard to keep the barricades up, even with 4 players

Conclusion:

Good fun, with only a few very minor problems.

Pros:

Great Lighting
Excellent Atmosphere
Fun little puzzles
Neat little transmission overlay
Cool, futuristic feeling (Almost like Doom 3 or Dead Space)

Cons:

Terrible voice acting
Beginning is extremely hard with only pistols on Advanced and Expert

Conclusion:

Great map! Might i suggest adding an extra pistol at the start so players either have the choice of melee or dual wielding?

Pros:

Looks promising
Awesome Intro
Decent Poster

Cons:

Crashed when I got control of player, got a GHardware cache error of a haystack model (de_inferno model)
The new Survivor skins, while new and cool, do not mix well with their old outfits
Extreme FPS Drops
Crashes often IF you get past the intro.

Conclusion:

Looks very good and promising, but needs to be fixed.

Pros:

Great Pacing!
Love the atmosphere
Food Court level is great
More Mall
Good Brushwork and modeling
Changes for the better from DBD2
Cool new intro and music

Cons:

Slight oddities with the new level's NAV
Increased Difficulty
Still no Intro Dialogue

Again, large file size, and with the new download cap for the public server it can take over an hour to download (Didn't take away points)

Conclusion:

Awesome addition to the DBD series! I love it! I'm going to go as far to say this is better than DBD2! More cinematic, better changes to the NAV, and great new additions.

Pros:

Fun
Can train people
Fun with friends
You can switch teams

Cons:

Like i said before, needs at least some light, but I didn't take away from the score.
No insruction as to what room goes where/what console spawns what, etc.

Conclusion:

It's decent, better than your other Training Maps around here.

Pros:

Good Brushwork
26 Cans
NAV is good
Custom Skybox

Cons:

A bit blocky
Weapon selection is poor

Conclusion:

It's ok. Dev Textures actually don't look half bad on a map for once, so I excluded it from the cons list.

Pros:

Good Brushwork
Felt like Resident Evil
L4D1 Survivors
Puzzles
Traps

Cons:

Continuity, you are underground and then suddenly above it in the next map.
Red Queen is too quiet (sound files wise)
Empty
Doesn't feel like Resident Evil after 1st map
Lazer Hallway is a bit cheap
Only pistols for about half the first map
Weapons shouldn't be absorbed, give players some choice!
Missing models since Sacrifice update
Poor texturing and placement of Umbrella logos

Conclusion:

Well, It's good, but the main irk is with the scenery and geometry. While it maintains a look of Resident Evil, poor texturing and emptyness brings it down. A good attempt though.

Pros:

Great Port
L4D1 Survivors
Good placement of supplies
No lighting issues like the previous ports

Cons:

None, really. It's a Valve map so I can't really make cons about things that aren't in the author's control.

Conclusion:

Great Map.

Pros:

Great Feeling
Loved the trailer hanging over the edge, but why not make it hang lower?
Good Atmosphere
Good amount of supplies

Cons:

Map is very small
Many spots to camp, most notably in the trailer, and in the corner of the overturned bus
Not many places to setup a decent defense

Conclusion:

A good map, just needs a little fine tuning. Maybe you could possibly remove the bus and add on to that area? And you could lay down a 'clip' brush by the bus, so players can't camp in the corner.

Pros:

No lag for me (I'm running an i5 Processor)
Great Brushwork
Excellent Lighting
Awesome models

Cons:

Missing Textures on Balcony above Snowman
Model pop-in
NAV is horrible, bots got stuck often and made no attempt to follow or even spawn to me
Infected spawn WAY too early and too much, I survived literally 45 seconds.
The chairs in the cafe should be prop_physics
The ladder on the first floor doesn't go up high enough before you fall
No Melee Weapons
Supplies aren't scattered
Only a few weapon choices
No 3D skybox at the back of the lodge
Some doors are openable that shouldn't be
Many areas where a clip brush should be
Feels empty

Conclusion:

Well, I'm disappointed. It feels rushed to get it out and more work should've been done, but I understand your time constraints. I'm sorry for the bad score, I really am. I try to like this map, but the cons outweigh the pros so much the map seems to be only good for eye candy right now.

Pros:

Great Scenery
Good Lighting
Decent Survival Time
Supplies are scattered decently
Great Skybox
Good Weapon Balance

Cons:

Only 2 houses enterable
There's not much to see outside in terms of scenery
Magnum and some weapons like Sniper Rifle and Axe, etc. are missing.

Conclusion:

Great map.

Pros:

Extremely Epic
Great placement of Supplies
The Other Survivors help
Feels like a last stand
Ending

Cons:

Louis has a hard time tracking targets, thus rarely fires the emplaced gun.
Many special Infected spawn two Chargers, Spitters, etc at a time, which shouldn't happen.

Conclusion:

Just shy of a perfect score. If you could download ONE Survival map off of this site, download this.

Pros:

Great Feeling
Nostalgia
Just the right amount of difficulty
Great level design and puzzles
Custom Music

Cons:

Bots have occasional trouble
Finale outro is a bit lackluster.

Conclusion:

A great, nostalgic Campaign.

Pros:

Great Detail
Fishes
Awesome Poster
Good textures

Cons:

There's two main areas of supplies
Infected spawn too early 
A bit Hard
Lack of detail in some hallways (like 1st, 2nd, and last pic)

Conclusion:

Great design, needs a little bit of updating.

Pros:

Great Idea
Good Textures
Great Concept

Cons:

Bots get stuck commonly
NAV issues
Supplies are VERY hard to find
Very little supplies
Missle Targeting System is broken
Very little detail, most shops are empty
Extremely Shiny
No real out-of-the-way places
Cubemaps needed

Conclusion:

Needs a lot of work.

Pros:

Slow-mo is good

Cons:

No way to trigger the survival start unless you noclip to the otherside of the map, which is impossible on multiplayer
Map is way too small at first
Little starting supplies
Skybox is iffy
Slow-mo is too long
No clues

Conclusion:

A great attempt.

Pros:

Reminds me of Still Creek
Great gameplay
Custom hints
Great out-of-the-way places
Fun to gather up all of the Propane and gas tanks, then use them as a giant bomb in Survival

Cons:

Custom music is too quiet 
Map is relatively small in length
Bots get stuck in the chicken wire by the speakers and jukebox
Bots sometimes fall from the ladder and die
NAV is uneven (bots had a hard time following me)

Conclusion:

A great map.

Pros:

Good spread of supplies
Great Soundscape
Jukebox
I love the feel of the map
M60

Cons:

Map is linear, pretty straight-foward with no real out of the way places
The bodies on the police car don't ragdoll like they should
The Survivors' scream at the beginning is too loud
Tank can use the cars to it's advantage (making them prop_static should fix this)

Conclusion:

A great map, just make it bigger and fix the tank issue.

Pros:

Good setting
Great visuals

Cons:

No NAV...wtf
Not fun

Conclusion:

Why did you release this when it needs SO much more work done?

Pros:

New twist on the finale
Plane crash still cool as ever
It's Dead Air!

Cons:

Maps look a bit bright, especially finale

Panic Events are easy
You can Rush the campaign

Conclusion:

A port that is not too shabby. Lighting could be improved.

Pros:

Nostalgia
Unique theme
Not too hard, but not too easy (as in just right)
Custom Music
Custom Graffiti
Gary Motherf***ing Oak!

Cons:

Supplies are thinly spread out
Textures can seem a bit flat
Pop-in (grass can suddenly appear right in front of you, then disappear as you walk away)
'Tall' Grass is not tall

Conclusion:

This desperately needs a campaign. The only things that drag it down a bit are thinly spread supplies, flat textures, and minor pop-in (i didn't deduct any for the Grass)

Pros:

Dark
Initial defenses
Lots of supplies

Cons:

Typo in map poster (It's 'Emergency' not 'Emergancy', that was just a typo in the original CEDA logo)
Not enough props, map is quite empty
Map is also small
Darker than what is shown in the screenshots....much darker
Tent is no longer safe, so why have a sh*tload of supplies in it?
Bots have a hard time dealing with the infected

Conclusion:

This is a map meant to be played with friends. There's no problems, but some improvements (namely lighting) may be necessary for this map to shine.

Pros:

Amount of zombies onscreen in front of you can be impressive
Endurance Maps
Fun to kill zombies

Cons:

Endless hordes
Campaign is very overrated
Intro glitch
Doesn't really tell a story
More melee weapons!
Intro music on each map is annoying
Rare Stretched and crappy textures
Too many health kits
Maps are wwwwaaaayyyy too long (6 very large maps)
Not your typical plug and play campaign- will require at least 2 hours to finish it (an hour over the norm)

Conclusion:

An overrated campaign that doesn't have too much to show besides killing zombies. Endless hordes and the length broke the campaign for me.

Pros:

The Concept is fresh.
The Map design is a fresh, new look from L4D2's apocalypse setting

Cons:

2nd and 3rd map are cramped, too many infected
No clear instructions or goals
PLENTY of supplies
Bot NAV is terrible

Conclusion:

A Far Cry from what usual mappers crank out, this is a fresh new idea that we should be seeing more of.

Pros:

Great Brushwork
Good representation

Cons:

Missing textures galore (just white lines) (I looked in the VPK with GCFscape, and if there are any custom materials, you forgot to pack them in)
Why can't we go in water?
Map feels a bit small

Conclusion:

It may be me, but I do not know. I have addon support installed. But otherwise, great map!

Pros:

Open ended gameplay
Fun to hold down the fort
Supplies are well spread out
Looks good

Cons:

Too Cramped, get rid of some vehicles in the streets
Hard to manuever in the floor below Minigun
Too small of a map for such a big setting
Bots have a bit of trouble getting around

Conclusion:

Good job, this being your first map. The streets feel too cramped, though, get rid of some vehicles, needs to be more open ended. It's also hard to manuever in the floor below the miningun, mainly because of the debris. The map also feels too small, especially for a "big city" setting.
Overall, pretty good.

Pros:

Great Skybox
Unique 
Fun to Play
Visually Pleasing

Cons:

Wasn't very open, felt cramped
Choppy Intro
Not enough detail on buildings and street below (the buildings are all a dull grey color)
Bot Pathfiniding was bad (IE they wouldn't follow me
Supplies were few and far between 

Conclusion:

A great map, but it has some flaws. The skybox is great, until upon closer inspection you can see the "Box" and some black lines below the NYC skyline.

Pros:

New finale= good
more maps

Cons:

FIVE maps? Really? How the hell do you extend a 2 map campaign into 5...
Too open
Conversion did a number on the graphical quality. 

Conclusion:

Needs more work to be up to standard we have been seeing with you lately.

Pros:

Great design
Lots of items

Cons:

Map is too small
No areas to effectively hold out past 7 minutes
Map needs more detail

Conclusion:

Its a good attempt, just make it so we can go outside, make an effective hold out area, and place some more detail inside the supermarket. Besides the outside view, it looks like there was no such thing as an apocalypse.

Pros:

Great Design
Sense of scale is amazing
Finale is beast
Great lighting

Cons:

Should've made it to where the Survivors had to jump from boat to boat in the docks level to get to the freighter
..Finale is also too easy!

Conclusion:

It's a fine attempt at a map, didn't see any bugs, though. add some more detail to the lighthouse in the docks level though. And it would've been funner to jump from half-sunken boat to boat to get to the freighter. Overall it's pretty good.

Pros:

Looks good
Looks like Pandora from Avatar
Visually pleasing

Cons:

Not really spacey, more like extra-terrestrial jungle
Only one map(Yes, I know it was built for survival but still)
Music can be annoying at times, even if it does relate to the B-movie title

Conclusion:

Great map, but it looks more like a jungle than space.

Pros:

Looks good
Has that 'swedish' feel to it

Cons:

Too hard to defend
not enough weapons
why can't we go upstairs?
Need some snow

Conclusion:

Great concept, but put some snow in to make it really seem like Sweden. And why can't we go up? Isn't that the point of a hotel?

Pros:

Great map design
Right amount of weapons
surprisingly hard

Cons:

AI glitches
A bit small

Conclusion:

Great map, only problem is the AI gets confused. Make it a bit larger, too.

Pros:

Great map design
Pretty open
Lots of different spaces

Cons:

Not enough weapons, some even missing
Orange sky should be changed to nighttime, to fit the environment

AI bots can get confused

Conclusion:

Good map, just needs some changes and additions and it will be good.

Pros:

Very Entetaining
Levels are long enough to the point that it's cool
Great level design

Cons:

No good weapons until halfway through
Wind effect on helipad is crap, would've liked to defend myself there and it was annoying for teamates to slip.

Conclusion:

Great map, keep it up.

Pros:

Great map
Nice looking resort
Visually appealing
No spawning errors like in your desc. at all.

Cons:

HORRIBLE looking space beyond the fence by the pool. A beach would be better.
map is a bit small
No respawning guns 

Conclusion:

Great map, but a beach would be better instead of a crap-looking lake. And add respawning guns. 

Pros:

Awesome level design
No glitches whatsoever

Cons:

A bit too easy
Bile bombs and pipe bombs are ineffective, due the the Infected being largely spread out.

A lot of supplies.

Conclusion:

Very good map, love the airport setting, now all we need is an Airport  Terminal survival map.